3 ms·
Wouldn't the "military" only group be able to terrorize the agriculture only as well as the ag plus military ones? Something akin to the Danes at one point? T
by mc32 10y ago
Wouldn't the "military" only group be able to terrorize the agriculture only as well as the ag plus military ones? Something akin to the Danes at one point? They could just build it up so that they could go pillaging indefinitely, so long as they don't outright destroy their target civs.
- rmchugh 10y agoI'm not sure the Danes were ever military only, Denmark was also an agricultural society during the viking period. As I understand it, the viking raids were in fact organised around the agricultural calendar, with the two raiding seasons taking place after the harvest and after the sowing. And of course the Vikings were interested in acquiring farming land and often settled and farmed in their places of conquest. A more apt comparison might be pastoralist raiders as mentioned in Turchin's War and Peace and War, whose nomadic lifestyle led naturally to the development of military skills that could be applied in raids on settled communities. Turchin wrote a lot about the Tatars and the Mongols could also be a good example.
- mc32 10y agoI didn't mean for the imperfect example of the Danes to take it off tangent, it was only to illustrate a people I could think of for whom raiding was integral but your examples or any other is just as well. I think someone (civ) could have taken it further and been sociopathic and only relied on military force for survival. Obviously there are benefits in diversifying, but I think while not ideal, it's possible and could work, in some circumstances.
- jandrese 10y agoYou mean like the Mongols? They didn't stop and farm. Their entire society was built around conquest and pillage.
- mc32 10y agoI suppose so, I forgot western civ was one battle loss away from not existing as a continuous entity. So yeah, military only seems to be possible, even if the Mongols were not 100% faithful to this strategy, I think someone could have been successful.
- jwtadvice 10y agoUntil they established city centers, trade routes, spread religious freedom to among their subjects, developed population centers and their agricultural output, standardized exchange rates and quality bars, created systems of news and material delivery, and all that other stuff. Their empire was, of course, extremely short, as it collapsed with the death of their Great Kahn soon after it established itself and its following leaders abandoned the previous inroads in the West to focus on the prize of capturing China (that ultimately failed). Our history tends to focus on the expansion of their empire rather than its subsequent administration, I think in part for that reason.
- mc32 10y agoTrue, but I think it tentatively proves it's possible, if not effective, long term.
- neaden 10y agoAnd raising horses, nomad's still practice agriculture.
- ricree 10y agoThey didn't raise crops, but still practiced a considerable amount of agriculture based around grazing herds.
- clock_tower 10y agoIt does work to an extent, but it's self-limiting; for what pure militarism can and can't do, look at Sparta.
- yxhuvud 10y agoPrussia should also not be forgotten in that context.
- wavefunction 10y agoThey also took slaves who would handle the agricultural and manual labor tasks in those Nordic societies while the freemen raided.
- Spooky23 10y agoAgriculture also comes with structure. Once you get past subsistence farming, you need markets, credit and social order. Once you have those you get specialization. A purely aggressive group eventually loses and vanishes. Remember the story of the Danes was told by the recipients of their raids, who had an interest from a religious standpoint to portray them as awful pagans.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe longer you pillage, the more you raise the interest in being opposed. That's why the Mongol approach was so effective - you had a really short conquest period that happened once, then tribute was paid. The tribute was more than made up for by being on the Mongol trading network. IMO, all empires are small compared to the Mongols. They had it all. The Danes just had lousy farmland and good boats, especially during long cold spells. The Northmen in general had more impact as traders than as raiders. A similar pattern emerges in the Americas - the Apache word for the Comanche is Apache for "those a$$holes" because the Comanche were much more predatory of the Apache than the other way 'round.
- douche 10y agoThis worked for nomadic steppe people effectively from the domestication of the horse to the invention of gunpowder.
- taneq 10y agoAs production technology improves, producing your own resources becomes cheaper than the military action required to take it from others, which gives producing societies an unbeatable economic advantage. A tribe of pillagers could destroy a hamlet, but could never compete with the resources of a walled down.