6 ms·
Glyphosate was discovered by Monsanto and is one of the main components of roundup but it's not patent protected anymore and it's used in one form or another gl
by dogma1138 10y ago
Glyphosate was discovered by Monsanto and is one of the main components of roundup but it's not patent protected anymore and it's used in one form or another globally in 100's if not 1000's of herbicide products. So I don't understand why the focus on Monsanto other than it's an "evil" name that is more or less known.
This is also a weird request since the documents release was requested due to the fact that this was found to be unsafe, even tho quite a few other bodies found it to be generally safe even at pretty darn high doses (2000-5000mg/kg) including the EU Food Safety Agency which is a pretty strict organization.
- misja111 10y agoSo why is it a weird request? To me it seems logical that the industry wanted to know how the WHO came to its conclusion, exactly because those other bodies all came to a conclusion which was the opposite of the WHO's.
- dogma1138 10y agoWeird in the sense that it's usually would be the other way around and that a FOIA would be used to uncover some "coverup". This time it seems that there might be some political reasoning behind it there were issues about this matter handled at the WTO (not WHO) before especially between the US and China.
- colordrops 10y ago> it's not patent protected anymore Why does that make a difference? Monsanto makes $15 billion in revenue a year directly or indirectly from its glyphosate sales. They also sell GMOs that are glyphosate resistant, so they are helped by glyphosate sales whether it's sold by them or not. Seeds and genomics $10,243 million 68.3% Agricultural productivity $4,758 million 31.7% [1] [1] http://www.fool.com/investing/2016/05/26/how-much-money-does-monsanto-make-from-roundup.aspx http://www.fool.com/investing/2016/05/26/how-much-money-does...
- dogma1138 10y agoBecause China is the largest producer of Glyphosate, and most current patents regarding EPSPS resistance are owned by Syngenta.
- tptacek 10y agoThey make their money from the glyphosate-resistant GMO crops, not from glyphosate itself.
- colordrops 10y agoDid you see the numbers I posted? They make 5 billion off of glyphosate. Also, if the majority of their money comes from glyphosate resistant crops, isn't it obvious that they have a strong vested interest in glyphosate?
- Kalium 10y agoThe numbers you posted suggest that they make a maximum of $5 billion off of glyphosate ("Agricultural productivity"). It doesn't show how much of that is actually glyphosate. You're free to assume it's 100%, but it may not be maximally wise to expect everyone else to make the same leap of logic. I expect their ownership of the Climate Corporation, which is about climate and weather data, falls under "Agricultural productivity".
- colordrops 10y agoYou ignored the second half of my comments, which is that the other $10 billion of their profits are directly dependent on the commercial viability of glyphosate, no matter who sells it.
- Kalium 10y agoYou're right! I did fail to expressly address the second half of your comment. Please accept my apologies for this egregious oversight. The other half of your comment suffers from the same flaw. The source you provide has high-level numbers, but it doesn't show how much of that is actually glyphosate-related. You're free to assume it's 100%, but it may not be maximally wise to expect everyone else to make the same leap of logic. It is known for certain that the number is not 100%, because Monsanto is known to have revenue-generating businesses outside of glyphosate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kafkaesq 10y agoWhose "focus on Monsanto" are you referring to? The article's? Or the IARC? The article doesn't seem unduly Monsanto in any case.