3 ms·
I thought someone would nitpick that statement. Microsoft supposedly designed and built .NET as a cross platform framework, even though they only released it fo
by oblio 10y ago
I thought someone would nitpick that statement. Microsoft supposedly designed and built .NET as a cross platform framework, even though they only released it for Windows. Yet many years after .NET's release and the .NET Core announcement, they're still struggling to achieve parity with Java.
Meanwhile, many of the examples from your list don't compare 1:1 with .NET profiles, because... :
- Android Java
This was caused by Google, so not $VENDOR's fault (Sun/Oracle).
- Java Micro Edition
This is moribund these days.
- Java Embedded Edition with (compact profile 1, 2 and 3)
This targets a totally different use case than the average .NET profile (most .NET profiles are minor variations on a theme).
- Java Standard Edition
Let's just call this "Java" :)
- Java Enterprise Edition
Let's call this "Java" + libs. It's hardly a profile, it's just Java + stuff on top.
- MicroEJ Java
I don't really know about this one.
- Real Time Java
See my comment about Java Embedded.
.NET profiles are IMO, just an ugly hack to re-add portability to a platform that was designed with portability in mind but then lost it gradually as it became more and more integrated with Microsoft platforms.
- pjmlp 10y ago> - MicroEJ Java > I don't really know about this one. A Java version produced by IS2T for micro-controllers, think cortex-M class. http://www.microej.com/ http://www.microej.com/ http://www.stm32j.com/products/ http://www.stm32j.com/products/ As for the rest, we will have to agree to disagree. Regardless how it looks like in detail, in the daily work they are issues to take into account when trying to write portable Java code. .NET was designed with portability across processors and Windows versions, not for other vendors. Even Rotor wasn't fully compliant with .NET 1.0. When looking at the histories told by Don Syme related to the initial generics design and Ext-VOS, .NET genesis was to be a native platform based on COM. Actually something that was brought back to life as .NET Native + WinRT. As for the .NET profiles, they aren't perfect, but as someone that works daily with Java and .NET, I look forward to them.