6 ms·
The Vigilante Manifesto
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jdmaresco 10y agoWe released a blog post and video to explain more about the vision behind the app: https://medium.com/@CrimeNoMore/vigilante-manifesto-e665696a4ebb https://medium.com/@CrimeNoMore/vigilante-manifesto-e665696a...
- mikeash 10y agoInteresting idea, but highly unfortunate name. Why choose something with such negative connotations in this context?
- ch4s3 10y agoYour claim about 2015 murder rates seems to be fear-mongering, from where I stand. The murder rate nationally is at a 51 year low, even with the 2015 uptick[1]. What exactly is the aim here? Your question "Could we restore trust between law enforcement and community" doesn't seem to be answered in the post, and the implication that your app could do this seems dubious. Is you aim to get people to flock to 911 calls and film them? That seems like what the post is driving at, but never directly says. [1]https://mises.org/blog/fbi-us-homicide-rate-51-year-low https://mises.org/blog/fbi-us-homicide-rate-51-year-low
- incongruity 10y agoAdditionally, the focus on murder rates is flawed for a few reasons: 1) Murders are not evenly distributed in most (all?) cities. In Chicago, for example, violence is heavily concentrated in certain areas. That means it's not a generalized problem yet this app doesn't address that clustering in a meaningful way. 2) Murders are not the crime that most people will feel comfortable intervening in – and, arguably, not one that is most high-value to report in the moment – unless you're focusing on armed, trained responders – who are likely going to be Police (unless we're getting into militia here and that's a whole different discussion). Instead, less violent offenses seem more manageable as a starting point. What if a purse snatching was reported? To be honest, I'm still not sure what value the app provides – generally speaking, this looks to encourage mob justice which is fraught with risk of mistaken identity and violations of individual rights. For the creators – what, specifically, are you looking for members of the public to do? This strikes me as another one of the AWARENESS!! "solutions" – assuming that awareness is the problem – honestly, especially in crime solving, I don't think that's the issue. Awareness of identifiable precursors to crime? That'd be really useful (what they are, I have no clue). Awareness of active shooter situations? Also useful – but much more rare and less about fixing an more about avoiding for the general user...
- messel 10y agoI consider this app as an extension of my senses. I get a push message when an emergency is happening nearby. Maybe I can help, maybe its none of my business, maybe I'll completely avoid that block. But I get a choice, where my earlier ignorance is no choice at all. It's the technological equivalent of someone shouting for help. You can assist or not. Disclaimer: I helped build the backend so I'm biased.
- HorizonXP 10y agoBut how often is something like that even happening? I doubt many of Vigilante's users live in a place like Mogadishu, or Cape Town, or some stereotypical violent city where "avoiding an area" is necessary. And if you do, I'm not sure how the app really makes a difference.
- messel 10y agoGreat question. When I was a kid (11-12) I injured my neck and was pretty worried, stuck lying down, and my pop called 911 to ask for help. A neighbor two houses down was a volunteer fireman so he heard the call over the radio. He headed over and helped make my family and I much more calm while we waited for emergency professionals to show up. Caring about the safety of people in your neighborhood is a great start. Technology playing a role feels like less of a gamble and more of an inevitability.
- MichaelGG 10y agoWas your neck injured due to a crime? Maybe target this app as a public safety tool, not a vigilante crimestopper system. Edit: A really great angle is allowing groups of people to get notified together. Works best with phone integration. At my last company I created a 9-1-1 product that does exactly that. A user could load neighbours or relatives to be alerted and listen in to their 9-1-1 calls. That way if, say, an elderly relative called 9-1-1, nearby family could perhaps intervene (for minor stuff or cases where the caller is suffering from a mental lapse) or at least know what's going on immediately. This is also a great value add to businesses or campuses that want to know about emergencies in real time for coordinated response. Or just to know when paramedics come in the front door, who is having the incident so they can efficiently direct them.
- jdmaresco 10y agoWe debated whether to leave those statistics in, even though we're citing major sources. You can look at these statistics from different angles. Our main point is that there is still a real and often growing problem with violent crime, especially in the communities we're working with. Many people still feel very unsafe and are looking for solutions. We've gotten a lot of positive feedback both from police and civilians. People are excited to see a tech company trying to help, and they have told us they feel safer when others are recording the scene in a peaceful and unbiased way. During our beta tests we had users help deter crime, break up fights, and support their neighbors.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhich 5 communities have the most growth in violent crime? (or 10 or 20 if you feel like it)
- ch4s3 10y ago>Our main point is that there is still a real and often growing problem with violent crime That's just it though, the data do not support this claim. The general trend is decreasing crime. In fact the sole source you cite says: >Many crime experts warn against reading too much into recent statistics. In fact, murder rates remained largely unchanged in 70 cities, and decreased significantly in five. “Even if the uptick continues in some cities, I doubt the pattern will become universal,” Dr. Sampson said. And sure, you have some positive feedback, great. But how often has your app been misused? How "concerned citizens" mistaken an innocent person as having been involved in a crime? What about the privacy of victims of crimes? How do you store your data? How do you ensure privacy? Do you give data to law enforcement? Without warrants? Do you disclose any of this data? What do you do to protect extra sensitive data like domestic abuse, and sexual assaults? Why should we trust you?
- SamBam 10y agoIn your video: "This is a real app, and these are real users." What does that even mean? "Real users" in this case means you downloaded a copy of the app onto their phone, before you started directing the actors?
- jdmaresco 10y agoAll of the people in the video who are using the app and responding to the alert are actual users who have been actively participating in our beta in New York City.
- dsl 10y agoHow are you getting live access to 911 calls? Or are you just showing crimes reported by other users?
- cypherpunks01 10y agoThe video appears to imply that the app has operators that are transcribing police scanner activity into app reports, I don't believe there is any non-public info being accessed or govt partnership here or else I would think it would be advertised. Can someone confirm if this implication is correct? I always had the idea that more and more NYC police radios are being trunked and encrypted in ways that the public can no longer access, does anyone know if this is the case?
- JshWright 10y agoI don't know about NYC specifically, but that is generally the case across the country (I'm a paramedic and ham radio operator).
- sctb 10y agoWe've updated the link to this from the App Store: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vigilante-crime-awareness/id1039889567?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/vigilante-crime-awareness/id....
- drivingmenuts 10y agoApple really needs to get a different URL for the app store. My first thought was "what dumbass at Apple thought that would be a good idea?" Then I saw it was a non-Apple app.
- moduspwnens14 10y agoMusic plays when I open the app for the first time, despite my ringer being off. It certainly looks like a cool idea, although it says my area isn't covered yet.
- cloudjacker 10y agoannnd you're dead, thanks Vigilante! Maybe they'll push respawns in the next update
- HorizonXP 10y agoThe lens of a camera cannot lie, but video editing can. In the spirit of trying new ideas, I think this is definitely an interesting one. I think it will be interesting to see how the public responds to this. That said, I see a couple of things happening: 1) Most people will not care about this, nor use it. Human apathy is pretty powerful, and I don't mean that in a bad way. I think the majority of us are happy going about our own lives, and don't really want to upset that order. If a crime is happening, I don't think a lot of people will react to it, especially like in the video. 2) A small percentage of people will react, but that's probably not what you want in a situation like this. In emergency response, the number one thing they drill into you is to ensure the area is safe and secure. Paramedics will not render aid to a person if it means they could be harmed themselves. It's useless to have the paramedic injured as well as the victim(s). LEO and emergency personnel are trained to respond to these situations, and are paid to put their lives on the line. Adding other citizens to the mix is dangerous and irresponsible. I understand that Vigilante is only encouraging people to record what's happening, but even that act is dangerously provocative. Nevertheless, it is an interesting idea, and I likely have outlined the same kneejerk reaction that most would have to this, and I could very well be wrong. I think this type of app would work best in larger situations like at protests or more open public spaces. Situations like those in the video probably won't happen often, and probably would have the issues I brought up. But then, how is Vigilante different from folks just posting videos on FB Live, Twitter/Periscope, etc.?
- arprocter 10y agoHave you seen the movie Nightcrawler?
- smokeyj 10y ago> LEO and emergency personnel are trained to respond to these situations, and are paid to put their lives on the line. The keyword here is paid. We need more market forces in policing. It needs to be easier to fire bad actors and promote the good ones.
- incongruity 10y agoActually, training is a pretty important word there too... We can debate about the quality of current training standards for certain case types, but on balance, I think it's hard to dispute that many situations need the expertise of trained first responders (paid or unpaid). More people on scene doesn't always make things better. Without thinking about the specific problems this is meant to solve and working to enable solutions, this app can be just as dangerously bad as it tries to be good.
- teilo 10y agoNo possibility of controversy here. Especially with a name like that. Wow.
- 0xffff2 10y agoIt's absolutely unfathomable to me that someone thought this was a good idea. If I'm calling 911, it's because I need professional emergency services. Can someone name even one scenario where some random person off the street intervening is more likely to harm than to help when intervening in a situation based on this app?
- throwusawayus 10y agoI can't verify this, but I was told that the lead investor is Peter Thiel / Founders Fund. Seems believable, since it's consistent with his investment thesis.
- alistproducer2 10y agoSketch Factor[1] is that you? [1]: http://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/what-to-do-when-your-app-is-racist http://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/what-to-do-when-y...
- rymohr 10y agoOne time I was at the park with my three kids and all the sudden every parent at the playground grabbed their kids, rushed to the parking lot, and got the hell out of there. I had no idea what was going on. So we kept skateboarding. Next thing I know cop cars are zipping in and out of the neighborhood, dozens of police are running around jumping fences, and there's a helicopter circling overhead. Our car was parked in the center of the chaos, so we stayed on the far side of the park and watched. Would have loved to have an app like this that day. Still never got to the bottom of what was actually going on. Or figured out how all those other parents were privy to the situation before I was.
- adrianpike 10y agoMaybe they heard gunshots and the skateboards were loud enough they masked the sound?
- freeformed_co 10y agoI think a lot of people have experienced situations where they'd like to know (or at least have the option to know) what is happening around them.
- akc 10y agoI had no idea dessert bars were so dangerous.
- jamesfe 10y agoAre there a lot of people who have the time and flexibility of schedules to go chasing down 911 calls in their neighborhood? I'm not heartless, I certainly open the front door and take a gander if I hear my dog barking or a loud noise out front, but beyond that, I'm not sure I'd just leave my family in the house with no plan other than to videotape what could be a violent criminal in the heat of the moment. Also, what relationship does this company have with a user once that user gets shot in the chest for running around and videotaping an armed robbery with their flashlight beaconing their position and activity to the criminal? What about when someone calls in a sexual assault - are there protections for their privacy?
- EdHominem 10y ago> What about when someone calls in a sexual assault - are there protections for their privacy? How do you think the company gets the 911 calls? You should focus your privacy concerns upstream. > I'm not sure I'd just leave my family in the house with no plan other than to videotape what could be a violent criminal in the heat of the moment. Right, but so what? Someone else might, or might be able to from their window. And if not, you weren't going to anyways. > Also, what relationship does this company have with a user once that user gets shot in the chest What relationship does Google have to a movie-viewer who doesn't like the movies playing in the cinema that they asked Maps to direct them to? > for running around and videotaping an armed robbery with their flashlight beaconing their position and activity to the criminal? You can choose to move away from the alerts, you know... The app doesn't compel you, it only informs you. I can see many non-violent but interventionary tactics people could use. A pastor could use it, and respond to the 'Children harassing an old man' call the website uses as an example. Not immediately, as if they could stop any ongoing violence, but later to try to find the perpetrators and reach out to them.