25 ms·
The trouble is that in the US, this sort of thing is seen as government unfairly competing with private industry. Of course, we just get private industry setti
by mikeash 10y ago
The trouble is that in the US, this sort of thing is seen as government unfairly competing with private industry.
Of course, we just get private industry setting up monopolies or duopolies instead, often with the help of local laws prohibiting competition. This is worse, but somehow more acceptable to the American electorate.
- E6300 10y agoI didn't know that! What a stupid position to have. Do they also think that the abundance of air competes unfairly with air salesmen?
- mikeash 10y agoNot quite, but many people's views on pollution regulations come surprisingly close.
- dredmorbius 10y agoSee coal vs. solar in TX, FL, AZ, NV.
- a_thro_away 10y agoAnything that is done at cost by the government is viewed by many as a lost potential profitable and taxable business; one that would drive up the GDP (Gross Domestic Product), a well used measure of an economy. Problem with using GDP, in my limited understanding, is that taxing things, even your breathing air, increases the GDP - I'd rather it not.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Anything that is done at cost by the government is viewed by many as a lost potential profitable and taxable business; one that would drive up the GDP (Gross Domestic Product), a well used measure of an economy. No, that's not how GDP works. The GDP measurement is independent of whether the action is performed by the private or public sector. > Problem with using GDP, in my limited understanding, is that taxing things, even your breathing air, increases the GDP No, that's not how GDP works either.
- refurb 10y agoSurprised you're getting downvoted. It's true, if the gov't performs a service, it's included in GDP. And no, taxes don't increase GDP.
- a_thro_away 10y agoI understand GDP as "taxable transactions".
- a_thro_away 10y agoThe OECD defines GDP income method as "an aggregate measure of production equal to the sum of the gross values added of all resident and institutional units engaged in production (plus any taxes, and minus any subsidies, on products not included in the value of their outputs).”
- a_thro_away 10y agoTaxes are included in the GDP income method, which is why taxing even air (even if free) would increase GDP. The OECD defines GDP as "an aggregate measure of production equal to the sum of the gross values added of all resident and institutional units engaged in production (plus any taxes, and minus any subsidies, on products not included in the value of their outputs).”
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Taxes are included in the GDP income method, which is why taxing even air (even if free) would increase GDP. The OECD defines GDP as "an aggregate measure of production equal to the sum of the gross values added of all resident and institutional units engaged in production (plus any taxes, and minus any subsidies, on products not included in the value of their outputs).” GDP is composed of four components. One of those components is government spending, which can be negative (ie, taxes) or positive (subsidies or direct purchasing). However, government spending doesn't come from nowhere (no, even if the money is printed or issued as debt). A change in government spending is always matched by an equivalent change in consumption, investments, and/or net exports, which are the source of that money. The secondary effects of tax policies may be to ultimately change the shape of aggregate supply or aggregate demand functions (at least, that's the argument for doing so), but taxation does not directly have any effect on GDP. So no, taxing air would not increase the GDP.
- E6300 10y agoOf course, if the service is one that everyone needs or that everyone can benefit from, it makes no sense to privatize it Everyone --($$$)--> Private enterprise --($)--> Taxes .......................................--($)--> Actual service vs. Everyone --($)--> State --($)--> Actual service or Everyone --($$)--> State --($)--> Actual service Not to mention: http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-01-14 http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-01-14
- ryao 10y agoMy understanding is that view only applies when the federal government is doing it. If a local government is doing it, the only ones that claim this are the people who would be losing business.
- mikeash 10y agoLaws restricting or prohibiting local governments from providing internet access to inhabitants are pretty common. I'm sure the actual underlying reason involves regulatory capture and lobbying from incumbents, but the unfair competition angle is convincing enough for the legislators in question to go ahead with it and not get ejected from office.
- ryao 10y agoA big problem there is that no one knows what laws are on the books in their own states regarding this. I know I do not in New York. I want to look it up at some point, but I don it yet know how.