3 ms·
Noncompetes are usually helpful in the service industry. If I hire you in my HVAC business and spend a year sending you on client jobs, then you leave, start yo
by brightball 10y ago
Noncompetes are usually helpful in the service industry. If I hire you in my HVAC business and spend a year sending you on client jobs, then you leave, start your own HVAV business and start contacting all of my clients that I sent you to work on...that's a problem. Without a means of preventing that it's almost impossible to grow a service business.
- Eridrus 10y agoWhen I worked at a consultancy there was a separate non-solicitation clause about clients that was written into my contract and I'm pretty sure was written into the contract clients signed too to not poach consultants.
- tristor 10y agoClient lists are covered under NDA and you can add a non-solicitation clause which is different from a non-compete and seems both reasonable and fair. NDA + non-solicitation: You can't start your own HVAC company by handing your sales person a copy of my client list and calling everyone who currently works with me. Non-Compete: You can't start your own HVAC company. Full-stop. Do you see the difference? Do you understand why one is reasonable and fair and the other is not?
- brightball 10y agoSee whenever I've seen a noncompete like that it's specifically said "within 5 miles of this location, up to 2 years, cannot contact any clients of this business" I'm in a right to work state though and that means that noncompetes don't hold up at all unless they have a reasonable and non excessive scope. In a right to work state nobody can prevent you from earning a living so in order for a noncompete to hold it has to ensure that you have plenty of other options in your field in the area outside of the scope of that agreement. I think we are talking about the same thing just using different terms.
- tristor 10y ago> "within 5 miles of this location, up to 2 years, cannot contact any clients of this business" What you just described is a textbook non-solicitation agreement. A non-compete would read something like: "You covenant and agree that, during the term of your employment with the Company and for twelve (12) months after the termination thereof, regardless of the reason for the employment termination, you will not, directly or indirectly, anywhere in the Territory, on behalf of any Competitive Business perform the same or substantially the same Job Duties." In a contract, terms like "Competitive Business", "Job Duties", "Territory", and "Company" would be previously defined. What this says in essence though is that for 1 year after your termination (either you quit or are let go) you cannot do the same job anywhere within the "Territory" which could be the city, state, country, region, or world-wide depending on how its defined in the contract. So, let's say in your HVAC example. A non-compete says you cannot work in HVAC at all for the term. A non-solicitation, like you says prevents contacting clients of the "Company".
- brightball 10y agoThat's definitely where the disconnect is then. The non-compete you are describing would be totally illegal in a right to work state. I'm 36 years old, have run a business and dealt with a lot of contracts like this for clients in the area and this is the first time I've ever heard of a specific "non-solicitation" agreement. My guess is that's because around this area it's what we understand a "non-compete" to be. I can't imagine anyone would ever sign a document that said they couldn't work in their field at all because they worked for this company.
- tristor 10y ago> I can't imagine anyone would ever sign a document that said they couldn't work in their field at all because they worked for this company. Yep, but they do. Even Jimmy John's was making employees sign a non-compete saying they wouldn't work for any competing fast food delivery chains if they quit. E.g. if you drove for Jimmy John's you can't quit to drive for Domino's. http://fortune.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-non-compete-agreements/ http://fortune.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-non-compete-agreem... They got sued and lost, but thousands of employees signed them because their only alternative was to not have the job or possibly any job.
- BeetleB 10y agoYou do realize this article explicitly highlights a Jimmy Johns non-compete which was about not working within N miles from a Jimmy Johns restaurant? I do not think this proposal makes the distinction that you make. Both are in the crosshairs.
- jackmaney 10y agoNo business has a fundamental right to exist. If you hire me for your HVAC business, and I manage to leave, build a competing business, and shut you down, then that isn't my problem. Your business never had a right to be free of competition from me. Period.
- brightball 10y agoIt doesn't and that's true, however, no business should have to constantly fear their own employees gutting their business from the inside either - and it appears that the above mentioned non-solicitation agreements cover that as entirely reasonable.