3 ms·
> The only thing a non-compete does is say that Employee A cannot work in their chosen field for some period of time after they are fired or quit. In doing so i
by masklinn 10y ago
> The only thing a non-compete does is say that Employee A cannot work in their chosen field for some period of time after they are fired or quit. In doing so it offers no consideration or compensation typically in the contract.
Many (if not most) EU countries require compensation for non-competes to be valid (usually at least 30% gross), and the non-compete can still be challenged in court if e.g. it applies to too large a geographical area (e.g. the entire state/country) or if it's broad enough to prevent the employee from finding work in the field.
- Fiahil 10y agoYes, and it's rarely enforced. Most of the time its activation is at the employer's discretion.
- masklinn 10y agoIt's not just that it's rarely enforced it's that it's rare at all, there's no point in putting one in the contract when there's 95% chance you'll get big fat middle finger in whatever labor court has jurisdiction if you try to activate it, and inane contractual obligations are a risky bet for the contract itself.
- dllthomas 10y ago> there's no point in putting one in the contract when there's 95% chance you'll get big fat middle finger in whatever labor court has jurisdiction if you try to activate it. There's potentially plenty of point if you don't expect your employees to understand that (or be able to count on it)
- cmdrfred 10y agoThat's how it works in the US, most of the time a non-compete is entirely unenforceable.
- cableshaft 10y agoDepends on the state. I live in Illinois. It's been enforced plenty of times here. They tend to argue over what is a 'reasonable' restriction, and it goes back and forth. For example: http://www.w-p.com/Articles/Illinois-Non-Compete-World-Now-Easier-for-Employers.shtml http://www.w-p.com/Articles/Illinois-Non-Compete-World-Now-E... And in 2013, the TekSystems recruitment company sued its former employee (a recruiter) over a noncompete and it got upheld in Illinois court: http://paulporvaznik.com/court-can-shorten-overly-broad-non-compete-in-recruiting-business-dispute/1604 http://paulporvaznik.com/court-can-shorten-overly-broad-non-...
- cmdrfred 10y agoIt seems that the same standard applies there, even if the judges in Illinois seem take liberties with it. From the first link: "3. Question: Does an employer still need to have "adequate legal consideration" in a non-compete agreement? Answer: Yes" It appears they have to compensate you for the agreement. Federal courts have ruled that your wage is compensation for your regular duties and thus the non-compete compensation has to be a separate payment that is negotiable. A contract is not valid if a party receives nothing in return for it. "Consideration to create a legally enforceable contract entails a bargained for, legal detriment incurred by the promisee OR a legal benefit to the promisor. Under the notion of "pre-existing duties", if either the promisor or the promisee already had a legal obligation to render such payment, it cannot be seen as consideration in the legal sense." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consideration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consideration
- cableshaft 10y agoWell it doesn't stop just about every company from adding it into their employee contracts. Out of the last six jobs I've had here in Illinois, five of them had non-compete agreements, including two startups, one small business, one major corporation, and a contracting company (TekSystems). The one job that didn't have a non-compete was a student job I held at the university while I was taking classes there. None of them offered to pay me extra outside of the salary for 'consideration'. I've ended up switching which industry I work for with pretty much every job I've had (still software dev though), so it hasn't been an issue so far. That being said, knowing that they're there has affected my decision making, including holding back on releasing games I developed in my spare time, to the point where I've been tempted to move to California to escape such bullshit.
- Fiahil 10y agoWell, I got this clause in all of my (two) employment contracts. Never heard of someone fighting over a non-compete, though. (I live in France)
- DavidHm 10y agoYeah. Germany is a big one on this. If ask you for a non compete, they have to basically pay you for the full duration of it. As a consequence, almost no one ever does, except for very high level executives.