4 ms·
> California also prohibits any employee agreement which claims employer ownership of intellectual property developed on the employee's own time I have always
by ekianjo 10y ago
> California also prohibits any employee agreement which claims employer ownership of intellectual property developed on the employee's own time
I have always wondered how could such a claim on ownership could exist in the first place. This reduces the employee to a mere company slave.
- throwaway_exer 10y ago> This reduces the employee to a mere company slave. Generally law enforcement will treat an employee as a slave if a company files any kind of complaint statement against the employee, regardless of how small the company is. Also, former employees have been convicted of violating employee handbooks. So slave is an apt description.
- GavinMcG 10y agoCan you please point to some examples of where employees were convicted of a crime simply for violating the private policies of their employer?
- samtho 10y agoI would like to point out that the parent's comment may have been technically correct, but slightly misleading. Police can only arrest (in the US) if you are actively committing a crime or have a warrant out for your arrest. Many companies instill policies that also overlap with the law and may turn over evidence to authorities thus placing a warrant out for the (former) employee's arrest.
- nickff 10y agoI think that the idea behind such employee agreements is that they encourage the sharing of new ideas within companies, as employees will not 'hold the ideas back' to use when they go off and start their own companies.
- aikah 10y ago> I think that the idea behind such employee agreements is that they encourage the sharing of new ideas within companies, as employees will not 'hold the ideas back' to use when they go off and start their own companies. It's up to the company to provide incentive for workers to "share new ideas" by rewarding innovation within the company, not limiting where the employee can work. Of course, most companies don't do that, steal ideas from employees without rewarding them in any ways or even give them credit when an idea leads to a successful product. Boss A or manager B gets all the recognition, and the employee gets nothing.
- nickff 10y agoThe company thinks it is providing incentive for the employees to share the new ideas by paying their wages; their argument would be that if a prospective employee disagrees with the assessment of the value of the work and ideas, that individual should not accept the agreement.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tristor 10y agoThat argument is flawed because an offer of employment is based on current and future expected value in a job role, not on unexpected new value that gets added by non required innovation. New ideas which bring new value should entitle an employee to additional new compensation if the company wants to claim ownership of those ideas regardless of where they are made.
- amyjess 10y agoIMO, more companies should use systems like YouEarnedIt to promote recognition of employees' contributions. My employer does, and I've learned a lot about what some people have done for us just by seeing their YEI recommendations on the screen in our break room.
- pjwal 10y agoWhich is why you rarely see successful lawsuits by companies toward former employees on this matter. Law is solidified by precedence and the rulings have been more and more against employers, rightly so. It's OK to trust in the system on this matter, as no one is ruling for employers on the matter.
- cgag 10y agoI also don't understand how using company property justifies ownership of intellectual work. What about using a company pencil should give you the right to any sketches I produce with it?
- dagss 10y agoWhen the company purchases equipment for use by you-as-employee, and you use that equipment for your own company spare time, how is that fair? A pencil is so cheap and undetectable that it makes a poor example, but if you stole my paint and painted a picture I would expect some compensation?
- distances 10y agoUp to the value of the paint only. If Leonardo had painted Mona Lisa with stolen colours, no-one would expect the painting itself to be ownership of the paint merchant.
- dagss 10y agoHowever everything the company does is seen in terms of investment... you invest in machinery and employees so that you can get more back than what you put in. When you loan from VCs, you can't tell them "you only get back what I loaned". They want a cut of the result. If you borrow something from the company for your own use, you are in a very real way making use of their investment. Since assumption is you didn't ask, why do you assume they want to give a bank-kind loan, not a VC-kind loan? (In fact, what we are discussing here are employee contracts where it is stipulated that such loans are of the VC variety... If you want to borrow under other terms, make a contract for it...)
- tehwalrus 10y agoBad example: I'd expect prison for theft (the paints aren't re-usable afterwards.) Better example: borrowing a rular and giving it back, using a company car but paying for the fuel and a service yourself, etc.
- walshemj 10y agoIt's derived (for anglo saxon based systems) from the common law governing "masters and servants" guess what we are
- amyjess 10y agoIf you're an exempt salaried employee, then there is no real distinction between "your own time" and "the company's time". I get paid the same no matter how many hours a week I work. On rare occasion, I've connected to our VPN or sent some emails outside of normal hours because something came up, with no effect on my salary. I'm lucky in that these occasions are rare, but some people are not so lucky. In the other direction, we have a policy that PTO has to be billed in 4-hour increments, and anything that consumes less than that doesn't have to be reported, such as an early-morning doctor's appointment that takes one hour. Is that doctor's appointment "on company time" because it was too short to bill PTO for? Does it count as being "on company time" if I'm looking at my phone when an email notification comes up because one of my co-workers CC'd me on something? Is it "on my own time" when I'm sharing memes back and forth with a coworker on our Slack?
- closeparen 10y agoSome interpret a salary as buying all of your intellectual output for as long as you have the job. This position generally holds that the employee needs to be hourly for the concept of "employee's own time" to make any sense.