4 ms·
It reminds me of a story my father told me recently about a mining company and a plastic dinghy. They had a job to complete that required access to a caustic p
by ehnto 10y ago
It reminds me of a story my father told me recently about a mining company and a plastic dinghy.
They had a job to complete that required access to a caustic pond, so they organised a small plastic dinghy to get out and take their measurements.
Even though it was just a dinghy, they still required a certified skipper on board, plus a saftey officer and then the technicians to take the measurement.
They had estimated an 8 day job, not realising that the pond had shrunk by half since the original satellite imagery.
So the technicians fly out and get prepared, but the mining company hadn't organised half the things they needed to. So for the next 8 days the technicians are waiting for saftey and job approvals and twiddling their thumbs.
Meanwhile the skipper and saftey officer are back at the port awaiting the technicians go ahead.
Now the dinghy, it was sitting on the grass at the boatyard. These resources are all charged per day, and while they're booked for the job they are on standby.
At this point, the dinghy on the grass and it's hardy crew had cost the mining company $16000 just for standby costs.
Eventually the job goes ahead, it only takes 4 days because the pond had shrunk so much, and the dinghy is only used for 2 days.
Total cost for the little plastic dinghy and crew was $25000. The mining company was fine with this.
- enraged_camel 10y agoI work as a consultant/developer in the B2B software space. Part of my job involves documenting clients' existing processes and converting them to requirements. The type of inefficiencies you describe are EXTREMELY common. The fact of the matter is that the vast majority of American companies are simply stuck in the 70s/80s (sometimes the 60s) when it comes to how things are done. Most of their business processes are manual and paper-based and communication is archaic, usually relying on many single points of failure, who happen to be human operators. As a result, stuff falls through the cracks all the damn time. I've been thinking about how companies can manage to stay in business even when they're run so poorly. I've come to the conclusion that it's because many of them, especially the larger ones, face no real competition. All the other companies in their space are run similarly. As long as a decent amount of revenue keeps coming in, the leaders (many of whom are approaching comfortable retirement) simply don't care. I've also realized that, at the aggregate level, the primary reason the American economy is so ahead of other economies today is due to the head-start it enjoyed following World War 2, when most of the developed world had been devastated while America was virtually untouched. If there had been any sort of real competition, things would be very different today - and we're starting to see that as other economies are starting to catch up.
- stdbrouw 10y ago> I've come to the conclusion that it's because many of them, especially the larger ones, face no real competition. All the other companies in their space are run similarly. I'd argue that a better way to describe this is that there is competition and possibly even a lot of competition, but all competitors have to deal with the fact that their employees are not perfect, management is not easy, teamwork is inherently hard and that over time every company accumulates its own set of weird workarounds and inefficient procedures, so this in itself does not lead to a competitive disadvantage.
- keithpeter 10y agoYour work sounds interesting. Do you capture what really happens in the manual system (trust based work-arounds(1) and all) or do you work from what the procedures say should happen? Just wondering. (1)E.g. An reference number is needed to set up X on a system. To get a reference number you need to get Y to sign off. Y is notoriously slow, and I have been doing this for years. Z lets me have a reference number on trust knowing that Y will sign off because my paperwork will be in order. Someone new would not get that trust until a few successful cycles. C.F. Lave and Wenger, communities of practice.
- enraged_camel 10y agoWe capture what really happens in the manual system, as well as what should happen. Sometimes the latter is pretty vague, or (believe it or not) simply unknown, in which case we learn the very final goal (e.g. "all invoices should be approved in under 24 hours") and work backwards to discover bottlenecks. This can take many weeks, sometimes months, because it requires interviewing subject matter experts. Implementing the software comes at the very end, ideally when the underlying process itself has been re-engineered. We found that you can't simply take an existing manual process and implement it in software, because if you do then you also capture many of the inefficiencies and bottlenecks.
- keithpeter 10y agoExcellent answer. One wonders how you identify the 'subject matter experts', and the extent to which you rely on their answers to questions versus direct observation of what they do. My experience (anecdotal, informal) is that there can be quite a difference between a verbal description and what actually happens, and the difference has to do with situational knowledge (as in "oh yes, I forgot about Fred. With Fred we do ZZ instead")
- briandear 10y agoThis is a great example. However mining is typically a private endeavor where the mining company and thus the customers of its production (and shareholders) bear the cost (typically.) What gets me is when it involves taxpayer money. I would be distinctly liberal with spending tax money on projects if the funds were more efficiently spent. However it irritates me to no end when I see vast inefficiencies with our tax money while we perceive ourselves as working hard every day to earn money. When someone talks about raising taxes, I scoff because I feel like if public projects weren't so wasteful, our money would have a higher return on investment -- that has led to me be very conservative in terms of public expenditures because I feel that the government is not a good steward of our hard-earned tax dollars. For example, the famous 'rubber rooms' for NYC teachers -- teachers and education always ask for more money but they find a way to waste it in salaries for people who quite literally do nothing all day due to the influence of union special interests and labor board rulings that favor the special interest over the greater public. Henry Hazlit (and Bastiat before him,) explained these issues very well. I am not opposed to taxes or public spending, but when I see our money being pissed away with blantant and obvious inefficiencies, I get very stingy with my political will. Construction contractors (and boards of education members,) would never spend their personal money this way, yet they happily spend public money like it's from an unlimited fountain.
- lmm 10y ago> This is a great example. However mining is typically a private endeavor where the mining company and thus the customers of its production (and shareholders) bear the cost (typically.) What gets me is when it involves taxpayer money. Why would we expect public organizations to be any more efficient than private organizations? All large organizations have this kind of inefficiency, just like in the mining example. It's unreasonable to demand perfection just because it's the government doing it. > For example, the famous 'rubber rooms' for NYC teachers -- teachers and education always ask for more money but they find a way to waste it in salaries for people who quite literally do nothing all day due to the influence of union special interests and labor board rulings that favor the special interest over the greater public. Weren't the "rubber rooms" due to the school administration not paying their agreed portion of arbitration fees? I can't imagine anyone in those rooms wanted to be there (they sound incredibly depressing), but if you have a false complaint against you what else can you do? It'd be very hard to get another teaching job with that complaint on your record, and you don't want to let whoever filed it win by giving in; all you can do is wait to make your case to the arbitrator.
- keithpeter 10y agoJust under 40 years ago, I worked along with half a dozen other people (all on overtime) until 8pm on Christmas Eve so that a ship could leave Liverpool on the last tide before Xmas deadline, thus saving significant charter costs. We got free takeways and naughty beer afterwards. Swings and roundabouts.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Total cost for the little plastic dinghy and crew was $25000. The mining company was fine with this. Because if they piled a couple of guys into the dinghy, and it happened to capsize, they'd end up paying out seven figures at minimum to the dead technicians' families.
- beachstartup 10y agoequipment is leased, and the leasing companies finance it and make earnings on the margin of rent and payments. a $100k truck or $250k crane costs shockingly little on a monthly basis. construction finance companies are getting into the technology finance industry, by the way -- they have reached out to me many times - to them there is no difference between a tractor rig and a Xeon/GPU/SSD/40G compute rig. in fact you could argue that tech is more resilient than construction, from a financial point of view. anyway, i digress... as per usual, the people are what is expense, even 'cheap' construction workers. likely those people are being sent around to multiple jobs because the crew+foreman are experienced and reliable and unlikely to cause general fuckups or financial liabilities.
- GFischer 10y agoI might be jaded, but that doesn't sound like such an awful example at all. There is some excessive overhead, but that's par for the course. And they did do the job :) Some of the other examples mentioned (with costly machinery just sitting there) probably cost millions per day.