11 ms·
After Almost a Century, the 2nd Avenue Subway Is Close to Arriving
- jseliger 10y agoInfrastructure costs in general remain bizarrely high: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/08/27/america_s_sky_high_infrastructure_costs.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/08/27/america_s_sky... or http://www.citylab.com/work/2014/04/7-reasons-us-infrastructure-projects-cost-way-more-they-should/8799/ http://www.citylab.com/work/2014/04/7-reasons-us-infrastruct... or http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2012/09/public-transport-costs http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2012/09/public-trans....
- gopi 10y agoBoth Hillary and Trump says they are going to boost infrastructure spending. I think its better to wait and see how self-driving/mobility as a service develops before spending money on transportation infrastructure
- seibelj 10y agoIn Boston, the presence of a nearby T stop massively boosts property prices, creates businesses, allows people to live without cars, and so on. Nothing improves an area holistically like mass transit improvements.
- massysett 10y agoPeople make the same claim about Washington Metrorail stations, while conveniently ignoring (1) said stations nearly always have excellent road access as well, yet the road gets no credit for the development; and (2) areas around some stations are zoned to develop more densely, so maybe such zoning, not the presence of the station, deserves some credit. I agree that transit can help improve land values, but transit alone does not deserve all the credit when other factors may also be relevant.
- whafro 10y agoI lived in Washington before stops like U Street, Petworth, and others had been built, and the major roads in those neighborhoods were not responsible for the growth they've experienced since the station's openings.
- massysett 10y agoThere has been practically no development by the Cheverly station and it also has great road access, and there has also been a lot of devepment in Trinidad and Ivy City even though they have no stations nearby. People are quick to claim that transit stations are responsible for development activity when even a cursory look reveals that the reality is not nearly this simple.
- technofiend 10y agoWell of course there are always other factors - but citing zoning will get you no traction here, sir. Beyond some very basic limits on things like opening a "vice"-related business of some kind near a church or a school Houston has no zoning laws. I can open a nail salon next to a restaurant and there's nothing anyone can do about it. See the infamous "Ashby Highrise" http://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/real-estate/article/Ashby-casts-long-shadow-over-Houston-land-use-7213635.php http://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/real-estate/article... as an example of residents taking matters into their own hands and suing developers after City of Houston rubber-stamped a traffic study that would have allowed a high rise complex in the middle of a neighborhood. The residents were forced themselves to sue because they had no other remedy. Houston's near town development has a long history unique to our area - everything from a former Freedman's town that left lots of prime real estate in the hands of people who really preferred not to sell for development to local management districts using tax money to buy property outside their taxation area in order to prevent or slow gentrification. The area recently expanded to by the Northline extension was considered a blue collar area at best and frankly too crime-ridden and dangerous at worst for any redevelopment. That has turned around with the rail - and since Houston's is an at grade rail, we actually lose one-two lanes of the thoroughfare when rail goes in. Yet North Houston which was the site of the Moody Park Riots is now the target of development and gentrification and you can track that against the rail's expansion.
- technofiend 10y agoIn Houston, TX we actually had a mayor run and win on an anti-rail platform! As with any construction project delaying it just made it cost more later. And yet when it was finally built the Red Line was a stunning success. Among other things it linked most of the city's major stadiums, creating a relief valve for major event traffic, it linked parking and medical center sites, cutting traffic to and from our congested Medical Center and almost since inception it has carried more people on a daily basis than the combined ridership of our spoke and hub "Park and Ride" system which brings commuters in from the suburbs to downtown. Development along the Red Line has ramped up and the gentrification that comes from it is obvious along its recent Northern expansion. So just like in Boston bringing rail has a net-postive effect on property values once construction is done. Considering those ridership numbers are based on paid rides and ours is an honor system with loose enforcement Metro is putting up some decent ridership numbers! Unfortunately due to Bob Lanier's intentionally blocking such expansion we don't have the desperately needed heavy rail system to cut freeway traffic between Houston's higher density bedroom communities. And more frustratingly we still have only part of the rail plan implemented due to ongoing efforts to block rail funding. The rail line proposed to link our downtown and Galleria commercial district has been blocked for 10+ years by a single Congressman and some vocal business owners in a 1.5 mile stretch of road. If they had just sucked it up the construction would be done and those same businesses would be benefiting from their increased accessibility.
- yolesaber 10y agoWhat a myopic, Valley-centered view. Self driving cars still need to drive on roads and bridges, automated trains still need tracks. Four, even eight years is a lot of time to do infrastructure repair and upgrades, I highly doubt self driving services will take off exponentially in that period.
- dawnerd 10y agoI disagree. We can't rely on self-driving cars as the solution to our transportation problems. Roads can only handle so many cars no matter how automated it is. Light rail is also a lot more efficient I'd imagine than a ton of cars using gas / batteries. I'd rather take the 2.50 rail fare than the way more expensive lyft/uber/whatever.
- vtlynch 10y agoAmerica's ultimate idiocy is to think the "transportation revolution" is autonomous cars.
- barney54 10y agoWell, autonomous cars have real advantages in terms of transportation flexibility and comfort. Those are two factors that are very important in people's transportation decisions.
- rhizome 10y agoOn comfort, it's not going to be a robotic BMW that is used for autonomous traffic, it's going to be a robotic subcompact with fiberglass seats and can't be ruined by vomit. Think: carnival ride with a better seatbelts and airbags.
- inimino 10y agoThink: Uber without the driver. Do you think the market for more comfortable transportation is just going to disappear or something?
- rhizome 10y agoI think the profit motive will increase margins.
- inimino 10y agoI think the profit motive would lead to somebody serving the top end of the market. People aren't going to give up their BMWs unless the experience is better.
- lmm 10y agoPeople will pick based on cost. Look at air travel: everyone bitches about the low-cost airlines with their narrow seats and $5 sandwiches, but they fly with them anyway.
- thesmallestcat 10y agoC-C-C-C-Corruption!
- bunderbunder 10y agoThe articles linked in the grandparent post suggest the opposite: That all the procedural barriers the US sets up in an effort to prevent corruption tend to run up the costs. For example, lowest-price bidding rules tend to result in more expensive projects overall because the agencies feel the need to do a whole bunch of up-front micro-planning in order to try and prevent the contract awardee - who, as we already know ahead of time, will be the lowest bidder - from cutting too many corners. Or to put it more simply, we've essentially mandated that public projects have to be the waterfalliest of waterfally waterfall projects. Our "starve the beast" approach to funding public agencies, also inspired by our hysterical attitude about government corruption, comes into play, too. Since agencies end up with limited resources for permanent staffing, they don't necessarily have in-house resources available for project planning. But they can use funding set aside for projects to hire consultants, who are naturally expensive and less worried about what happens to the project 5 years down the line. They'll be long gone by that point.
- Spooky23 10y agoYou nailed it. There's a whole crazy litany of procurement rules procedures and other nonsense that you have to do. A project like this will have monitory and women owned business goals, which usually translate into somebody's wife forming a shell company fronting money and skimming a profit. There are various labor agreements,which include quotas for various groups. Plus dozens of other crazy legal requirements. I worked in government for many years. The work was great and rewarding, but the absurdity of the procurement process and the waste associated with it was really disheartening to me personally. Re: starve the beast, you're 100% correct. Out of hundreds of projects, I can think of 5 (all huge rollout type things that had to be down quick) where using consultants to run the project was a best value. But probably 70% were done that way, and usually redone by government staff.
- wtbob 10y ago
- honkhonkpants 10y agoThe NYT article inadvertently addresses the problem: dozens of workers were at the site. Dozens. Not hundreds or thousands. Dozens. With all that capital equipment laying around and all the opportunity costs being ignored. There's a road project near my home that's been going on for more than 90 days now. Many days nobody is on the site at all, even though all the cranes and other equipment are left on site at all times. When the site is being worked it's by at most half a dozen people, five of whom are watching the sixth guy work. You'd think that lowest-bid contracting would have fixed this but for some reason it hasn't.
- bwilliams18 10y agoLabor while cheap is still hard to find, especially on public-works projects where everyones papers need to be in tip top shape. The work is hard, the pay is shit, nobody wants to do it if they have even a slightly better option.
- rhizome 10y agoWell since it's not cheap, don't let projects go any slower than necessary or can be predicted (supply chain, equipment, bureaucracy).
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThe pay legally cannot be shit. If it was allowed to be shit, contractors would lower wages and hire more people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davis%E2%80%93Bacon_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davis%E2%80%93Bacon_Act (Back in the day, contractors were hiring black workers and bypassing the more expensive white-only unions. Davis Bacon was passed to fix the "problem" of free markets overcoming racism.)
- tedmiston 10y agoFrom the CityLab link above: > Thus it has, according to a study from the conservative Heartland Institute, calculated prevailing wages at 22 percent above BLS figures, forcing higher prices. Well shit is relative, I guess.
- m0llusk 10y agoThat may be true, but the NYC Second Avenue subway is a bad example for comparison. The main reason that it took so long to complete was a number of extreme challenges in construction. Subway construction is rarely simple or cheap, but using one of the most complex and expensive subway lines as a point of reference might not be realistic.
- mafribe 10y agoBy way of comparison: Shanghai's subway was started in the 1980s and according to [1] is now "the world's largest rapid transit system by route length and second largest by number of stations [...] It also ranks second in the world by annual ridership." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Metro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Metro
- venomsnake 10y agoChina has no NIMBY problem. They can convince anyone with ease. Same with financing.
- ghaff 10y agoIt would be so much easier without that pesky democracy thing. /s
- ptk 10y agoNot everyone sells. Nail Houses are a real thing. Although, they certainly don't make it easy to stay. http://io9.gizmodo.com/unbelievable-nail-houses-around-the-world-892781747 http://io9.gizmodo.com/unbelievable-nail-houses-around-the-w...
- ethanbond 10y agoMost of the NYC transit system is also operating 24/7, which makes expansion and maintenance pretty difficult.
- ant6n 10y ago
- donretag 10y agoGood for them to open up new subway stops in rich white neighborhoods, while cutting bus service in the poorer ones.
- foota 10y agoAnyone have some insight into why this is getting down voted? Is it not true?
- mzw_mzw 10y agoIt's the lowest-effort of low-effort virtue signaling, that's why. Look at me, I'm so not racist, unlike all you racisty racists who have the gall to talk about a subway line instead of something I care about.
- yolesaber 10y agoIt's actually a very pertinent issue to NYC subway lines, as many of the severely congested ones (such as the J/M/Z line) run through minority neighborhoods but they don't receive very much maintenance, upgrade, or fanfare in the way of these three new stops which, in all fairness, will do little to alleviate the growing capacity problems facing the MTA. Furthermore the comment never once referred to anyone externally as a racist. It simply highlighted a problematic disparity. Projecting much?
- donretag 10y agoWhile I meant no "racism" my original comment, I did use the "rich white" adjectives. Race has nothing to do with it, my apologies, but classism still remains. I remember when the last subway extension was completed in the late '80s (E/F extension into Queens). That truly did serve marginalized neighborhoods. Back then, the income disparity was far less.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> the comment never once referred to anyone externally as a racist. "X didn't explicitly say Y" is the online commentary version of holding a hand an inch away from a sibling's face in the car, saying "I'm not touching you".
- melling 10y agoNext we extend the 7 Subway to NJ? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_Subway_Extension#Proposed_New_Jersey_extension https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_Subway_Extension#Proposed_... The Path stops about 2 miles from the airport. That would be a good project to finish. http://www.nj.com/traffic/index.ssf/2016/05/push_to_expand_the_path_network_gains_more_support.html http://www.nj.com/traffic/index.ssf/2016/05/push_to_expand_t...
- L_Rahman 10y agoHong Kong Airport made me realize how idiotic it is that we don't have these rail links: - PATH to EWR - 7 to LGA Not only does Hong Kong have a subway terminating inside the main terminal, it runs separate from their MTR line, takes 30 mins to get into Central and makes a handful of stops at major MTR junctions along the way. It felt like public transit working exactly as it should.
- enobrev 10y agoChicago as well. The blue line goes from downtown to inside ORD within 45 minutes, and the orange line goes to MDW. Not sure how long as haven't flown to / from MDW in years. I generally ask visitors to take the CTA instead of a cab because it's much faster during the day. Getting to any airport in NYC via public transportation is a pain, including JFK. Which is strange because the MTA is otherwise very impressive.
- inferiorhuman 10y agoSFO-OAK is pretty easy (despite that ridiculous, overpriced cable car at OAK). Tokyo's great too even if you don't understand Japanese. Haneda is in a great location and has tons of connections. Haneda to Narita is also pretty easy (bonus: monorail). Airports are, by design, generally out in the middle of nowhere and their connectivity suffers as a result. You get things like London where Heathrow and London City are reasonably accessible, but things like Stansted are out in the middle of bloody nowhere.
- 10y ago
- stomato 10y agoPaywalled so I can't read it.
- shmerl 10y agoNYC is missing a lot of connecting lines for instance in Brooklyn. Most of them run in parallel, and something like circular or orthogonal connecting lines could be have been really useful.
- dankohn1 10y agoThat's why we need the Triborough RX. http://ny.curbed.com/2016/6/1/11830816/the-triboro-regional-plan-association-proposal http://ny.curbed.com/2016/6/1/11830816/the-triboro-regional-... But MTA funding is controlled by the state, meaning that all subway funding needs to be balanced by upstate highway funding, meaning that super high return projects like this (which could probably justify themselves based on the improvements in real estate values as Hong Kong does) are not happening.
- shmerl 10y agoThey should be building more railroads upstate. In general, trains feel severely lacking in comparison with Europe for example.
- dankohn1 10y agoThere's not enough density to justify trains in upstate New York. But we should be spending tens of billions to upgrade the Acela corridor (which runs east of upstate NY) to something comparable to Europe's high speed trains.