7 ms·
Yes, I touch-type function keys. And having used the X1 Carbon 2nd generation, I hated the "touch-strip" function keys, both because they have no boundaries be
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
Yes, I touch-type function keys. And having used the X1 Carbon 2nd generation, I hated the "touch-strip" function keys, both because they have no boundaries between keys and because they have no tactile feedback when pressing.
The "context bar" seems like a huge win for people who look at the keyboard (who do comprise a huge fraction of the market), and a huge loss for touch-typists.
That said, I also don't use that many function keys, and I've slowly started remapping the keys I care about to other key combinations. In practice, I care about a few sets of function keys, most notably F11/F12 (commonly used for fullscreen, which I've now remapped to Super-F), and F4 (Alt-F4 to close applications, for which I've now trained my fingers to use Ctrl-W or Ctrl-Q and report bugs on the occasional application that doesn't accept those).
- st3v3r 10y ago"I hated the "touch-strip" function keys, both because they have no boundaries between keys and because they have no tactile feedback when pressing." I don't know about the boundary between keys thing, but for tactile feedback: Force Touch? "The "context bar" seems like a huge win for people who look at the keyboard (who do comprise a huge fraction of the market), and a huge loss for touch-typists." I don't think so. I touch-type, but I hardly ever touch-type the function bar. Doubly so on a Mac, because the function bar is, by default, used for brightness and media controls.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> I don't know about the boundary between keys thing, but for tactile feedback: Force Touch? I've (briefly) used a device with Force Touch. It doesn't come anywhere close to replacing the depress-and-release of a physical key. It's better than nothing, barely. But I don't want to use a tablet with an on-screen keyboard as my primary productivity device; I want to use a laptop with a physical keyboard. > I don't think so. I touch-type, but I hardly ever touch-type the function bar. Doubly so on a Mac, because the function bar is, by default, used for brightness and media controls. That seems like a self-fulfilling prophecy. I also know many Mac users who don't know why anyone would need a right mouse button, let alone a middle mouse button. If you design your interface to not need it, and you know people will never run third-party applications that do, then sure.
- ghostly_s 10y agoNobody does need a second or third mouse button. I spend hours a day in Mac, Linux, and Windows desktops and the pointing experience with a trackpad on a Macbook blows away what you get on any of the others, no matter what hardware is plugged in.
- serge2k 10y agoYes, but you have to configure it. You setup your gestures, fix their backwards idiotic "[un]natural-scrolling", and make sure you have your right mouse button setup.
- foldr 10y agoThe right mouse button is set up by default.
- vacri 10y agoYou'll get my highlight-buffer-paste-on-middle-click only if you pry it from my cold, dead hands. If you've trained yourself to only need one button, then yes, you only need one button. But look how well that's worked out on the iPhone, with a heavily-overloaded one button, with hard-to-discover functionality.
- eth0up 10y agoRunning Debian on an old Macbook 4,1 (2008) on my first ever Mac and am not thrilled with the trackpad, or the keyboard layout. The best configuration I've yet mustered is: #!/bin/bash synclient TapButton1=1 synclient TapButton2=3 synclient TapButton3=2 This gives a minimally usable touchpad, with two-finger-tap right-click, side-scroll and tap-select. I am still scratching my head at the absence of right-click and the key layout. I have no actual Mac OS experience to compare to, but Imagine they've done it all well when it's used as intended. Otherwise, it's working great and the build quality is solid. I am already fantasizing about Linux on a newer model, maybe with a PC mouse or external touchpad though.
- muninn_ 10y ago
- hn_user2 10y agoJust an aside you can change the configuration to default to function keys and require th fn key for the system functions like brightness and volume. It's the first thing I swap. Hate having to debug with one finger on the Fn key.
- st3v3r 10y agoI'm glad you can do that, but I'm not going to. The only time I really use those keys is for the brightness/media controls.
- jamestnz 10y agoYou can even change this on a key-by-key basis using a neat tool called FunctionFlip. This enables you to have certain F Keys work natively, while other F Keys require you to hold down Fn... http://kevingessner.com/software/functionflip/ http://kevingessner.com/software/functionflip/
- sliverstorm 10y agoThere's a big middle group, people who generally touch-type with the best of them, but couldn't touch-type an Fn key to save Manhattan. They just aren't that useful for many people, and so the muscle memory never forms. (They are also really far from home row on some keyboards)
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> They just aren't that useful for many people, and so the muscle memory never forms. I'd be surprised if the majority of touch-typists on Windows don't have muscle-memory for Alt-F4, at a minimum. > They are also really far from home row on some keyboards Fair enough; helps that I exclusively use and prefer laptop keyboards, to the point of having a USB ThinkPad keyboard/mouse combo on my desk.
- rayiner 10y agoBut there is no commonly used Mac shortcut that uses the function keys.
- ghshephard 10y agoescape key being the one exception. That is in my muscle memory.
- bobsil1 10y agoEsc, play/pause, mute, volume down, volume up, Cmd+option+eject (sleep)
- fourthark 10y agoShow desktop.
- kriro 10y agoI pretty much only use ESC, F11 (show desktop) and F5 to reload the browser + the occasional f6 to jump to the browser address bar. I've also reversed the standard mapping so F11 is triggered without the fn-key.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoTouch vs. Visual is only one spectrum of change here. I remap function keys for global purposes like window tiling with Divvy. Seems like context-sensitivity will delete what I consider to be key functionality.
- etrautmann 10y agopresumably you could override a context-sensitivity with global parameters just like you could remap the keys?
- duckfruit 10y agoI have an X1 Carbon from work. Overall an OK windows laptop, but man does the eink(?) touch strip thing suck. While I think that the Macbook version will be far superior, I hope they manage to solve its glaring shortcomings. Some observations: 1. Questionable utility. Sure, there's an icon for 'copy' and 'paste', but I cannot imagine it being easier for anyone to hunt along a non tactile touch surface located in an awkward position to hit that icon rather than just using Ctrl + C (or the mouse, which you've just made your selection with). That's a shortcut almost everyone knows. 2. Poor/Non-existent third party software support. Basically works for IE and Windows Explorer and that's it. 3. Software that drives the screen is poorly made and crashes occasionally. 4. The strip is a 2 bit/pixel B&W screen that is hard to read and is not backlit.
- vacri 10y agoThat X1 touch strip sucked enough that they took it out of the very next model I was holding off buying my X1 until I confirmed it didn't have that strip. Not being able to tell where the keys are without looking is bad for professional users - it splits your attention from the screen where your work is, and the tool you use to do your work. Function-key shennanigans reminds me of an apple laptop from years and years ago, well before the unibodies came out, where the function keys were hard up against the screen - hit a function key, and you bang your fingers against the screen (well, most of the time).
- bitwize 10y agoWith Apple's version you're bound to wonder how you ever got by with a mere keyboard and mouse. Every personal computing device is either a) a rough prototype for some Apple product or b) a shameless knockoff of one. The Carbon touchstrip was the former.
- michaelmrose 10y agoIt seems likely that the sort of thing you would put on such a key would be better served by either a spot on a tool bar preferably with an actual textual label not a cute icon or a physical button . The former is visible without looking down at your hands the latter is easy to press. I believe this combines the worst of both worlds. I don't know how to address your last sentence it sounds clever but it means virtually nothing. If apple does it first its a knockoff if someone else does it first its a rough prototype of something apple will ultimately do better. Heads I win tails you lose?
- ams6110 10y agoI haven't used a function key since WordPerfect 5 for DOS.
- marpstar 10y agonot even F5 to refresh?
- kctess5 10y agoCmd-r
- infectoid 10y agoCmd-Shift-r for me.
- midgetjones 10y agoTo hell with caching!
- majewsky 10y agoJust R in Vimperator.
- rasz_pl 10y agohow about Escape?
- jxy 10y agoI was really worried about Esc, then I realized, you know, there's gotta be a way to remap the whole touch bar to be Esc.
- jakobegger 10y agoRemap Caps Lock to Esc?
- lathiat 10y agoI have the same keyboard and same problem. I am desperately hoping that Apple is (a) using some taptic magic to make it easy to feel the edges between keys (this is possible from the original haptic/taptic research) and (b) requires a CLICK instead of a TOUCH to reduce accidental touches. A physical escape key wouldn't have gone astray either, as a power terminal user particularly with vim -- different escape keys (no matter how good or bad, simply being different in tactility) also drive me a bit batty.
- dijit 10y ago^C and C-[ is escape in vim too, so it's not /as/ painful if you change your habits.
- qb45 10y agoActually ^C and ESC aren't exactly equivalent. CTRL-C Quit insert mode, go back to Normal mode. Do not check for abbreviations. Does not trigger the |InsertLeave| autocommand event. ^[ however is. Personally, I use ^[ to avoid reaching to actual ESC and ^C to exit any weird states entered by misclicks.
- nothrabannosir 10y agoNotably, ctrl-c doesn't apply your changes from ctrl-v mode across all other lines. Minor, but still.
- egeozcan 10y agoMaybe you move your finger on the bar and see where you are real-time and release to execute? That'd be great - especially if combined with tactile feedback.