3 ms·
When the latest Tesla press release came out about performance, I surrendered after about an hour or two of edit warring about how it wasn't actually a verified
by FireBeyond 10y ago
When the latest Tesla press release came out about performance, I surrendered after about an hour or two of edit warring about how it wasn't actually a verified / independent track time, but rather a PR piece about predicted performance.
Pointing out the guidelines on the page themselves didn't matter.
Reverting with comments in the revert itself didn't matter.
Whether new people or established editor, everyone was falling over themselves to get the edit in.
I decided it was futile when they started deciding the solution was instead to rewrite the "guidelines" for what measurements were acceptable, basically "Screw you, we're putting the Tesla in. If it doesn't count based on the rules, we're changing the rules."
So now it's in three categories, "independent/ verified", "manufacturer tested", and "manufacturer claimed" (the latter of which only had the new Tesla).
- greglindahl 10y agoDeleting content is one of Wikipedia's biggest issues right now. I'm not surprised that the stable solution was to include the new content, and add a new way of describing it. Futile? No: inclusive. In a month or two you'll have the verified track time to add.
- FireBeyond 10y agoGreat. And in a month or two, then it should be added. But as a hint, in an area which isn't exactly new - manufacturers have been releasing new cars for a century, some faster than others, have been releasing press releases ever since, too, especially for supercars/ etc., on a list that has been updated for years (and this is one of my first edits on the topic, so I'm hardly claiming ownership)... the fact that you have to add another column that completely defies the "real world" measurements of every other vehicle there in order to get their fandom vehicle in should be indicative that it was a stretch. Here's an example: "List of fastest 100m races" lists the top 20 verified 100m times in history. Along comes an athlete's team and they release a press release saying "Based on our simulations, we predict he will run 9.45s in this race in a few months time" and, rather than do nothing with it, editors fall over each other to add a new column to the list, so it now has "verified times", "independent times", and "team projected times" and based on that states that Athlete is now the third fastest 100m runner in the world. Instead of, as you say, waiting for that event to verify (or prove false) that claim. But yet, to witness sibling posts, my perspective is "wrong".
- greglindahl 10y agoYeah, working together with volunteers is fun, isn't it? You seem to be doing a good job of representing the current "deletionista" faction, which is the source of many complaints from new, existing, and former Wikipedia editors.
- FireBeyond 10y agoEh, I'm not so much a deletionista. I think there's no real reason (to use an old example) of why every Pokemon needs its own page, while other more worthy topics get deleted. But overall? I'm an inclusionist, if there's a consistency. Instead, the practical application is "included if it gels well with certain fads or obsessions, but more more critically considered if not". Out of curiosity, though, I went back. Over a thousand edits to WP and of those, 12 on "Articles for Deletion". Of those I voted keep on 2, delete on 10. Of those ten, five were Biographies of Living People, and three were Original Research - including "List of Problems Solved by MacGyver", "Suggested Reading Order for Discworld Novels", and "Star Trek Vessels by Size". The other two were "WP: Admins Willing To Make Difficult Blocks" and a sub-user page from a now disgraced admin that he used to collect "evidence" on users he disliked. Using a stats tool I can see that on other edits my ratio of "Content Created to Content Removed" is 28.37:1. So I think I'm doing okay there, too.
- Singletoned 10y agoHe hasn't suggested deleting anything. He just suggested waiting before adding it.
- cooper12 10y agoFirst off, you shouldn't be edit warring [0], but rather you should discuss issues on the talk page. [1] As for the situation, it sounds like other editors discussed the issue and came to a consensus on how it should be handled. [2] It sounds to me like Wikipedia was able to adapt to a different kind of situation (instead of stubbornly clinging to the "rule of the law") and that you personally just didn't like how it was handled. For that you could ask the relevant WikiProject for guidance [3] or start an RFC [4]. Instead you just came here to complain about how the system worked, just not in your favor; not really constructive. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Edit_warring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Edit_warring [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:BOLD,_revert,_discuss_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:BOLD,_revert,_discus... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Consensus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Consensus [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Automobiles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Automobi... [4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_comment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_comment Edit: Since HN is saying that I'm "submitting too fast" even though I haven't commented in half an hour, I'll reply to the replies here. (Really stupid that it throttles you just because you went against the hivemind) @basch: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WTF%3F_OMG!_TMD_TLA._ARG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WTF%3F_OMG!_TMD_TLA....! :) Also those are pretty important policies, would you rather Wikipedians just ignore them and cede to whatever demands you have? @FireBeyond Yes I was being optimistic because all I had to go off of was your own description. If people are ignoring you, add a comment and tell them to discuss it until a consensus is reached. If they still edit war, then you can request page protection. And yeah you're right that I assumed you're naive, apologies, it's too bad in this case then. Still, there's nothing stopping you from removing that information and restarting the discussion.
- FireBeyond 10y agoHaha. You're excessively optimistic and assume naivety on my part. 1. Agreed. Except: I discussed my concerns on the Talk page. Nobody paid any attention to it, let alone replied. I discussed that I had removed an edit because by its own statement didn't fit the criteria on the page. 2. No. No other editor discussed anything, on the Talk page, or elsewhere. Just reverted my reverts, or rearranged slightly. So really, your example is more a failing of the system, rather than a complaint of "me just not getting my way". "Use the Talk Page" - works only if all parties also do so. You can see here how well this worked out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_fastest_production_cars_by_acceleration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_fastest_productio... "Don't edit war" - works only if all parties do so, otherwise it's "Victory of the Stubborn" "Assume Good Faith"... like you did here, and assumed the worst, that I'm naive about these things. The reality was that a certain group were hell bent on being the first to add the Tesla as one of the fastest production automobiles and weren't interested in hearing any discussion to the contrary. For full clarity: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?limit=50&title=Special%3AContributions&contribs=user&target=Achromatic&namespace=&tagfilter=&year=2016&month=-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?limit=50&title=Special%...