7 ms·
In most political topics on Wikipedia, you have a consensus because those who do not agree with it are quickly booted. It works like this. Most of the time mos
by bjourne 10y ago
In most political topics on Wikipedia, you have a consensus because those who do not agree with it are quickly booted.
It works like this. Most of the time most editors are polite, but sometimes you get frustrated and are not. You might not write "fuck you fucking nazi-lover!" or something extreme, but something like "your opinion is idiotic!" or "you don't know what you're talking about here..." It happens everyone. However, if you don't agree with the "consensus" every little outburst will cost you much more. A newbie will be banned for much smaller infractions than a regular.
So, if you are having an argument with someone who is a "respectable editor" or "valuable contributor" in the community, they can and will be quite rude to you but you must not pay back in kind because you will be banned.
There are also intricate rules governing "reverting". Reverting means you are undoing someones changes and I can say from experience that having your edits reverted can be frustrating. I don't know exactly what the rules are but they seem to be effectively that the more "respectable" you are, the more you can revert your opponents edits.
This power imbalance can be seen all over Wikipedia if you look for it. Many articles have editors that consider themselves the "owner" of that article. The way they have written the article is the best way and they don't see their own NPOV violations (Wikipedia term for writing biased texts). Sometimes the talk pages and their archives contain dozens of comments from anonymous ip users raising issues with the article and they are all refuted by the owner. They don't have the endurance or enough standing in the Wikipedia community to fight so they give up and find more constructive things to spend their time on.
- daveguy 10y agoNPOV == Neutral Point of View for those wondering. Wikipedia strives for "just the facts", but as you point out they don't have it everywhere. Most of the articles are very good or at least acknowledge where there is bias that should be resolved.
- Lawtonfogle 10y agoEven 'just the facts' Is broken because one cannot tell if all facts were given or if only certain facts were given designed to create some view. For example, given two studies that find opposing results, I can then list all the criticisms of the study I don't like while listing only the least significant criticisms of the study I do like. As long as I don't claim to have listed all criticisms, I have given 'just the facts' and yet made an quite biased article.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoEven "just the facts" is a fallacy. Wikipedia has simply outsourced its fact-checking to the news media, which is... well, how to put this... not very interested in facts.
- shard972 10y agoI think that's the most damning thing about the truth on Wikipedia, not that any article can be edited by anyone but their policy of second hand sources over primary sources. There is reasons for doing it but when you get into certain fields it just becomes a cluster F.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoPresumably they don't want to put themselves in the business of determining if a primary source is legitimate or if some random pseudonymous writer's original research is accurate. Not an unreasonable desire! Except instead they've put themselves in the business of determining if a secondary source is legitimate, which isn't fundamentally better. Wikipedia has to come to terms with the fact that if you claim you're making an encyclopedia that comes with certain expectations, namely, that you've verified the facts you are printing. They try to obfuscate this with endless layers of rules and procedure, but that no more eliminates the need to check facts than credit default swaps eliminated the need to pay back debt.
- posterboy 10y agoI think the N stands for No as in NOR="no original research"
- PDoyle 10y agoWhy post your opinion without even doing the simplest of google searches? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Neutral_point_of_view https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Neutral_point_of_vie...
- posterboy 10y agoThe comment was stupid, and worded badly at that. Past tense would have been accurate. Maybe I should take these guidelines for forum comments as well, sometimes. My POV wasn't important, sorry.
- dilap 10y agoOpinions will differ, but I'd say something like the page on Alicia Machado is written from a clearly partisan point of view, and does an impressive job of omitting inconvenient parts of her bio. A brief stroll through the page history seems to show something like what you describe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kfrz 10y agoSo it's like S03E01 of Black Mirror.... or what's happening in China with their social scoring system
- norikki 10y agoIn other words, when the powerful people get to tell all the plebs to sit down and shut up everything is much better. Thaaaaaaaaaaaaaanks WaPo. What would we do without you?