4 ms·
>1) The voter can confirm that their vote was recorded as they intended. No, they can't. They can verify that: A) Poll location XYZ (claims to have) received
by SilasX 10y ago
>1) The voter can confirm that their vote was recorded as they intended.
No, they can't. They can verify that:
A) Poll location XYZ (claims to have) received your ballot,
B) The government tabulator included the votes from XYZ in the final count.
That's not the same thing as verifying C) that they actually recorded your vote as intended.
If they can verify that this specific ballot, with this ID number, is yours, that would violate ballot secrecy and existing protocols avoid this. You would need something like homomorphic encryption to achieve C).
Incidentally, I don't get why we're okay with (in California et al) the system of giving a ballot to anyone who claims to be the person on the list. Yes, there are legit arguments against going all the way to photo ID ... but "no authentication whatsoever"? Come now.
- jowiar 10y agoThe basic reason we're okay with it is there is almost no compelling reason for an individual to falsely claim to be other people -- at least none where the risk/reward factor pays off. The reward for casting a false ballot is almost certainly zero, and the risk factor of, say, a friend in the polling place saying "Hi Steve!" when you tell the people you're John is enough to tip the scales. Almost any effort to rig an election involves falsifying hundreds or thousands of ballots (or, as we've started to see, depriving said number of their right to vote).
- SilasX 10y agoIn your model, is there "almost certainly zero reward" to the first (legit) vote?
- jowiar 10y agoYes, but you're not committing a felony, risking jail time and fines. Also, you've identified why GOTV is a big deal in campaigns. That said, rounding up a big group of people together to all vote is a whole lot easier than rounding up a big group of people to commit felonies.
- SilasX 10y ago>Yes, but you're not committing a felony, risking jail time and fines. I'm referring to the "reward" side of the ledger only. Do I understand you correctly, that under your model, there's no benefit to voting in the first place? If so, I don't think you're modeling critical dynamics of the system -- I think you would be worried if e.g. only five people were officially allowed to double-vote, even if that wouldn't affect the outcome.
- tanderson92 10y agoJonathan Katz et al showed that turnout among AAs hasn't noticeably been affected by voter ID laws, although that was almost certainly the intent. See: http://jkatz.caltech.edu/research/files/wp1267R.pdf http://jkatz.caltech.edu/research/files/wp1267R.pdf
- SilasX 10y agoSince I wasn't advocating lower AA vote or voter ID in that post, I'm not sure what you're responding to.
- tanderson92 10y agoI was mentioning some interesting research I read about the supposed legit arguments against photo ID legislation. It wasn't an adversarial point to anything you said, simply something I thought the HN community might find interesting.
- azernik 10y agoThe problem with asking for stronger authentication at the polling place is that we live in a third-world country [1] that does not have a free, mandatory national ID card. Those aren't just cards with photos - they're tokens of a national system for authenticating citizens' identities, which they must use in order to participate in daily economic life (get a cell phone, open a bank account, sign a lease, etc.) Since in a sane country everyone has one of these (usually on their person), requiring people to present it doesn't present an extra burden. Whereas in the US, in which a shockingly large fraction of the population goes about their daily lives without any such government-authenticated identity, forcing people to obtain such an identity just in order to vote is more likely to disenfranchise them than to get them to go get an ID. Case in point - under the Help America Vote Act, you do have to present identification on the first time you register (or in practice, the first time you vote after you register by mail)... but in order to avoid the disenfranchisement issue the list of allowed forms of identification is so enormous as to be meaningless. [1] I exaggerate. A little.
- SilasX 10y agoThose are (well trod) arguments against Voter ID, which I took care to specify I was not making. They are not arguments against e.g. voter cards, requiring the person to know their address in addition to their name, etc. Are you okay with them giving me your ballot simply because I claimed to be you? (It will be too late to take it back once I've cast.) If not, you agree with me, and "we're just haggling over the price" as the saying goes. Btw, you need to authenticate yourself to open a bank account in the US.
- azernik 10y agoIn California, at least, you do need to know your address... at least, the address they registered with, because there is no database of people's actual addresses. Which comes back to a chicken-and-egg problem - when someone registers, how do you verify that their information is correct? The point I really want to address is that having good voter authentication is more or less equivalent to the project of having a national or state ID card. Which no one in the US seems to be willing to undertake. I am not okay with the lack of authentication, but I'm more okay with that than with disenfranchising people who happen not to be integrated into our ramshackle systems of identification. Ideally, I'd like to have a state or national ID card possessed by at least, say, 98% of the population, and use that to authenticate - but we're not there, and empirically disenfranchisement is a bigger problem in the United States than voter fraud. (Also, WRT it being too late to take back ballots - this is the point of provisional ballots. If you show up for your first vote and can't fulfill the (laughable) HAVA ID requirements or are for some reason not on the rolls, you cast a provisional ballot in a sealed envelope, and over the next month the registrar of voters tries to decide whether it's actually you and whether to count your vote.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- voxic11 10y agoWhy would giving a ballot to anyone on the list be a huge issue? If people try to vote as other people they will quickly get caught which is enough deterrent I think. What is the scenario you are imagining?
- Sniffnoy 10y agoDo you really need full homomorphic encryption? I expect there must exist a more specialized method for this sort of thing.