3 ms·
I'm failing to see how this is superior to the hundreds of altcoins already available. What makes this better than Bitcoin, Dogecoin, or Kanyecoin? Why should
by jandrese 10y ago
I'm failing to see how this is superior to the hundreds of altcoins already available. What makes this better than Bitcoin, Dogecoin, or Kanyecoin? Why should I choose it over the competition?
- Torgo 10y agoThe answer is in the title of the submission.
- wmf 10y agoAs it says in the title, it's more anonymous. So ZCash and Monero are competing for the darknet payment market.
- raverbashing 10y agotl;dr transactions are encrypted so proof of funds work with zero-knowledge proofs
- jandrese 10y agoBut it can't really be truly anonymous, not if you want people to actually use it. At the end of the day you need at least some assurance that you're sending the money to the right person in exchange for their good or service. They also need to be able to verify that they have been paid for their work and by whom.
- 45h34jh53k4j 10y agoanonymous in the sense that no tx can be attributed to a particular party. it still uses strong cryptography to authenticate the transaction. the sender and the receiver can always verify that the transaction has occurred. it wouldn't be much of a currency if it relied on anonymous rumours of payment!
- schoen 10y agoImagine that you went to a restaurant and the restaurant told you where to send a payment. Then they could confirm that you had done so. Now imagine that the restaurant didn't possess any information that it could use to identify you as a result of the payment, and that no payment intermediary possessed information that could be used to identify the parties to the transaction, and that when the restaurant later spent the money, the source of the funds couldn't be associated with your payment transaction (perhaps even by you as the customer). Those are some properties that we could wish for in an anonymous payment system. It doesn't mean that the payee can't tell that a payment was made in response to a particular request, though it might not know "by whom" in any other sense.
- warkdarrior 10y agoSo there is no way for the restaurant to know who paid if multiple concurrent payments happen? What if 5 different tables are done and ready to pay, but the restaurant sees only four payments? Who do they go after?
- schoen 10y agoThe restaurant could give each table a different "address" to pay, and then see which ones have received payments (which can already be done with Bitcoin, despite the lack of some of the other anonymity properties).
- jandrese 10y agoThis is no different than Bitcoin.
- schoen 10y agoIn Bitcoin, the payer can see when the coins involved in a payment are spent, and see the recipient address, and see what other transactions were sources of coins that were spent in the same subsequent transaction. Also, anyone who gets paid by the restaurant can learn the transactions that were the origins of the coins that they were paid with. These are properties that Bitcoin has that I believe ZCash doesn't.
- empath75 10y agoI'm sort of annoyed at the whole concept of 'alt-coin' as if bitcoin is the one, true cryptocurrency and everything else are mere pretenders. Bitcoin has flaws: Transactions aren't really anonymous, mining has become centralized, it's nearly impossible to earn money as an independent miner, it's incredibly inefficient for transmitting small sums of money, etc... There are going to be other coins that try to solve those problems in different ways. They aren't 'altcoins'. They're just cryptocurrencies, and they'll rise and fall on the merits just like any other cryptocurrency. There's a whole lot of fud and hype and just plain misinformation in the cryptocurrency space because a lot of people treat them like penny stocks to run pump and dump scams on, but that doesn't mean they're all just that.