3 ms·
There isn't an a priori reason to assume all parties are going to commit offsetting amounts of fraud. Parties have differences between them (ideological, levels
by jerf 10y ago
There isn't an a priori reason to assume all parties are going to commit offsetting amounts of fraud. Parties have differences between them (ideological, levels of control over the system, the individuals in charge at given locations, and so on) and it's not hard to imagine there would be correlations between those differences and ability and desire to commit fraud, especially considered on a per-location basis.
(I'm keeping it generic here because this goes beyond US politics and is true for any democracy that has a party-like system.)
Further, even if by some miracle all the fraudulent parties completely cancelled each other out, it would still have a corrosive effect on the ability of the population to trust the outcome of the voting. First of all, how exactly does one go about proving to the populace that all parties committed offsetting amounts of fraud, when all parties are obviously motivated to hide what they've done? And second, it is rational of the voting population to be concerned that even though by some miracle it cancelled this time, and by some miracle they've been satisfied about that fact, it doesn't mean that will happen next time. If fraud is permitted, it doesn't take much playing with the game theory to discover that fraud is almost inevitably cheaper and more effective than anything else, and over time, the incentives inevitably align to encourage fraud to completely crowd out real voting.
And the recent chatter that corroding confidence in the voting system is bad is correct. Where that chatter goes wrong is in somehow thinking that is a primary goal, when in fact it must be built on the foundation of having a reasonably fair voting system in the first place. Having a fraudulent voting system but convincing the population it is valid is taking out debt with an catastrophic and random interest rate; it works until it without warning explosively doesn't work.