3 ms·
I agree in general but why would you use Windows/SQLSrv for internet-based products? I'm fine with it on the desktop, but the extra costs and time devoted to t
by mixmastamyk 10y ago
I agree in general but why would you use Windows/SQLSrv for internet-based products? I'm fine with it on the desktop, but the extra costs and time devoted to things like activation are a non-starter as far as I'm concerned. I believe they finally have ssh and package mgrs available, but don't you still have to install them manually?
There's plenty of boring stacks on Unix that are free, in both senses of the word.
- smacktoward 10y agoBecause it's what you already know? Teaching yourself *nix from scratch isn't free. Because there's some other piece of software you want to use that requires it? (Lots of people seem to like MS SQL Server, for example.)
- wvenable 10y agoActivation? I do development in both stacks, and there are pros and cons to each. For Windows, the biggest con is really cost. If you're comfortable with both stacks the difference in setup/maintenance isn't very different. However, the author makes a good argument about boring stacks in general. Your boring Linux stack will be much easier to maintain than something on bleeding edge.
- rpeden 10y agoBecause it performs well, and the cost of Windows licenses ends up being a rounding error if you have paying users. I've administered Linux boxes for years, and while I enjoy it I find Windows Server more enjoyable to work with in many cases. SQL Server licensing is another story. It is expensive, but I've also seen it handle heavy workloads on modest hardware without complaining. Though I don't doubt the same is true for Postgres and MySQL/MariaDB/Percona. From what I've seen, the constellation of reporting and BI tools around SQL Server are what make it appealing to enterprises regardless of cost.
- bad_user 10y agoWindows being a rounding error is kind of a myth perpetuated by people that haven't been in the position to buy Windows licenses for a company. First of all most software developers are not working in the consumer space. And for B2B you often get asked to have an on-premises option, either because the company doesn't trust you with their data, or because non-stop Internet connectivity can be a problem. And when deploying on-premises, the cost of the Windows licenses do matter a lot. If the clients are just web browsers then you can save the company a lot of money, since the clients can be just terminals powered by whatever you can get your hands on. But if you assume Windows clients, well, the costs can be huge. And on the server side, remote maintenance is way cheaper with Linux boxes, because well, you can control anything on a remote Linux machine, securely, reliably and for free. Add to that the licensing cost of Windows, which isn't cheap because you can't run a server on Home edition. Basically if your solution assumes Windows in any way on the customer's side, you're just adding unwanted cost that could have been your profit. And SQL Server is simply unjustifiable.
- UK-AL 10y agoConsidering most boring corporates run windows as their main server OS, I think it be an easier sell to run windows for on premise applications.
- bad_user 10y agoIn my experience dealing with boring corporations, that's another myth. Yes, they run Exchange. But all new developments I've seen happen on Linux boxes, precisely because it's easier to outsource IT.
- rpeden 10y agoPerhaps it depends on how boring/conservative the corporation is. At a past job where we worked with big banks, they'd sometimes look at you suspiciously if your application didn't run on Windows Server. That's just anecdotal, though. Maybe we were just unlucky and worked with odd customers.
- Sanddancer 10y agoIn activation, if you're dealing with more than a couple servers, you've almost certainly got volume licensing and a multiple activation key, which means that your install scripts will automatically update for you. Likewise, installing features like ssh and packaging can be automated as well. A lot of the things that people criticize windows for haven't been true for a long time, especially in the enterprise/service area -- there are a lot of tools out there for making things just as easy, if not easier, than *nix.
- mixmastamyk 10y ago"Easy" is never having to even think about those issues ever again.