4 ms·
What @pjc50 said. Here's a best of Den Beste: https://erbosoft.com/ussclueless/bestof.htm https://erbosoft.com/ussclueless/bestof.htm Very thoughtful, well w
by emmelaich 10y ago
What @pjc50 said. Here's a best of Den Beste:
https://erbosoft.com/ussclueless/bestof.htm https://erbosoft.com/ussclueless/bestof.htm
Very thoughtful, well written, prolific.
Here's one of his posts referencing one of my favourites, on alternate energy: http://chizumatic.mee.nu/ghosts_of_my_past http://chizumatic.mee.nu/ghosts_of_my_past
- pjc50 10y agoIt's important to recognise that he falls into the category of people who are convincing, argue at length with references, but are often wrong. A little example from that link (2008): "I don't expect the photovoltaic manufacturing industry to achieve that kind of production volume any time soon. 250 square kilometers is 250 million square meters. If they're turning out even as much as ten thousand square meters a year now I'd be very surprised. (I'd be a bit surprised if it was even one thousand.)" For some reason solar panel production seems to be quoted in watts rather than area; but if I take 55,000MW from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics and multiply it by the smaller number in https://www.quora.com/To-produce-1-MW-of-solar-power-using-PV-cells-how-much-space-is-required https://www.quora.com/To-produce-1-MW-of-solar-power-using-P... I get about 360 million square meters. His strategising on the middle east hasn't exactly been vindicated by history either.
- phonon 10y agoNot sure "Any time soon" = 8 years later.
- emmelaich 10y ago(edit: often wrong? I don't think it was often) Indeed, I was about to add a footnote to that effect but I was sure that someone else would do it for me :-) It's fine to be wrong, especially about the future. At least he showed his working, and if the figures from photovoltaics and batteries improve then you can redo some of his calculations. That's a very good thing. Most people would say he was wrong to support the war too, but at least you can understand in detail why he had the opinions he had.