10 ms·
An apology...
- enjo 17y agoI completely feel for the guy. I've been trusted with a few prototype phones in my life, in most cases prototypes from companies I didn't directly work for. I once left one behind in a bar in Idaho Springs Colorado (a Sony Ericsson P910 I think)... this at a time that a phone like that was an absolute marvel (particularly in the U.S.). Thankfully in my case whoever found it was a saint. I called, the bar had it and I picked it up. End of story. I'm a pretty responsible guy, I just screwed up that one time. I wish this had all ended the same way for this guy.
- swilliams 17y agoWhat reason did gizmodo have to release the identity of the engineer that lost the phone? To "prove" that their story was more real? Did they even consider what's going to happen to that guy? Every gawker website feels like it is just barely a half step above a tabloid, and in some cases, less than that (cf, Valleywag). Behaving this petulantly is not a very good way to discourage the popular perception of bloggers, it only solidifies it.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoApple knew whose phone it was, this story doesn't harm him there at all. It may even help prevent him from being fired or retaliated against, now that his name is public. It could help or hurt with future employers, but I'd guess on balance it helps. Probably won't be trusted with prototypes again, but that was going to be the case either way. Not to defend gizmodo, they seem pretty borderline in the whole thing.
- staunch 17y agoJust because they added a few sympathetic lines to their post doesn't mean they actually give a shit about what happens to the guy. They had no altruistic motivations in releasing his name. They did it for page views (i.e. money).
- BigZaphod 17y agoI don't see how this helps keep him from getting fired at all. Apple knew it was missing. They knew who lost it. They knew all this at least a week ago since Gizmodo claimed to have had it that long. If they were going to fire him, they already would have. (Maybe they already did?)
- ugh 17y agoI don’t think journalists should drag someone into the public unless it is absolutely necessary.
- cmelbye 17y agoGizmodo isn't the reason that the owner of the phone will be caught. First of all, he lost it, so it's originally his fault. Second of all, it was remotely wiped, which implies that Apple knew what had happened to the device and they knew exactly which device it was so that they could wipe it. Third of all, there were clear shots of the backside of the phone which had several serial numbers, most likely linking it to its owner for Apple's purposes.
- cwilson 17y agoCame here to say this. If Gizmodo truly burned this guy then yes, they are way out of line, but in this case it seems pretty obvious to me that Apple knew who lost their phone a week ago when this all started. The proof is in the first paragraph of almost every article on every site covering this story. The phone was remote wiped the next morning. You can all put down your pitchforks now. Let's wait and see what actually happens before nailing someone to a cross.
- jseifer 17y agoIt would appear they did this in order to get Apple to send them a formal letter getting them to admit the phone was Apple's. And for pageviews.
- flyosity 17y agoGizmodo could have written nearly the same exact article without mentioning his name and without showing his photo. It would have gotten nearly the same amount of pageviews. It was very, very cruel of them to do such a thing when they gained so little by doing so.
- verdant 17y agoI hadn't heard about this incident until I read this link, and had to google Gray Powell. This, at least in my case, caused some more attention to Gizmodo, rather than less.
- junelin 17y agoPress does what press does. It was his fault for being irresponsible.
- techiferous 17y agoIt's probably most accurate to say that the blame is shared.
- eli 17y agoI don't think that's fair. What Gizmodo did would violate the ethics policy of any serious news gathering organization. I don't consider them press.
- albertsun 17y agoCable/TV News fairly regularly pay subjects for stories.
- epochwolf 17y agoBut they don't release the names of people like this. I took a journalism ethics class taught by the news manager of a local ABC affiliate, they would never run a story like this. This is beyond disgusting. Edit: This http://gizmodo.com/5520438/how-apple-lost-the-next-iphone http://gizmodo.com/5520438/how-apple-lost-the-next-iphone is the article I'm referring to. Purchasing the iphone was definitely illegal but it isn't completely out of bounds for journalism.
- eli 17y agoMost TV news programs are also not serious journalism organizations, unfortunately. Also worth noting that when they do checkbook journalism, they're usually quite sneak about it. For example, paying someone under the pretense of buying rights to their photographs or paying their travel expenses. That's because even they know it's wrong to pay sources/subjects outright.
- eventhough 17y agoI am voting you up because I agree with your comment.
- sunchild 17y agoI actually did the same. I rarely get disgusted enough to resort to censorship, but Denton's craven, smug pageview whoring is just begging for the ban hammer. Also, putting comments down for the day reminded me that Gawker Media is nothing without comments.
- sunchild 17y agoAlso, this ... http://thenextweb.com/apple/2010/04/20/teenager-beat-iphone-4g-scoop-months/ http://thenextweb.com/apple/2010/04/20/teenager-beat-iphone-...
- maxharris 17y agoIf you say to your enemy, "I won't help you say nasty things about me, and I won't permit you to say them on my property", that is completely within your rights. That is not censorship. It's only censorship if the government is doing it, and that's something we cannot allow - it's a violation of individual rights if the government prevents you from speaking your mind to a friend or using your property to communicate with many people.
- zackattack 17y agothe gray powell tweme is pretty funny
- zackattack 17y agohey i don't mean that in a bad way
- khelloworld 17y agoGizmodo not only ruined it for Apple and the engineer, it also ruined the fun for Apple fans like myself anxiously looking forward to the rumored-filled days just before the next device unveiling in June. :-/
- gte910h 17y agoWait, you like accidentally buying stuff that's about to be replaced with a better model?
- Psyonic 17y agoNo, but he likes watching the internet explode with speculation that the new iphone will cure cancer and world hunger, at the same time.
- khelloworld 17y agoI don't even own an iPhone. I hope that answers your question.
- lallysingh 17y agoAll the discussion, rumoring, and conjecturing make the platform fun. A few guys take it seriously, but I think most of us just like to play in it for fun.
- 17y ago
- jsz0 17y agoThey very possibly did the guy a favor exposing his identity not only to insulate him from hasher retribution but also as pretty clear evidence it was an innocent mistake. No one would leave their identity on the device if they had personally conspired to sell it on the black market. I don't think it's that big of a deal. If the device was being field tested Apple was accepting the risk of theft/loss. If it had been an iPad 2 months before it's announcement maybe but it's just an expected refresh of an established product. Not the end of the world. Apple's software folks leaked the existence of the front facing camera in the SDK months ago. Apple's competitors won't gain anything with a 2 month advance knowledge of the 4th generation design.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoI don't see how this does either of those things. On insulating him, it's not like Apple ever cared what public opinion was. They just spent the last week basically pushing back against their own developers. So if they want to fire him they'll do it public opinion be damned. As for proving it was an innocent mistake. I don't think it does that either. If I were an Apple engineer and I just sold the newest iPhone prototype I'd ask the news site that broke the story to claim it was someone else too. Plus, it's gawker media so most believe they would be dishonest enough to lie about their source. I'm not saying that's what he did but if I was already suspicious of him that story wouldn't make any difference.
- Frazzydee 17y agoApple puts in a lot of effort to maintain an air of secrecy. It's part of their pubic image. AFAIK this is the first time there has been a leak this big. It is a big deal to Apple.
- staunch 17y agoThe Gawker network (which includes Gizmodo) is run by well known scumbag Nick Denton. He's a leech and a bottom feeder. Don't hold your breath waiting for anything positive out of him.
- techiferous 17y ago"scumbag, leech, bottom feeder" Describing actions that Nick Denton did that you didn't like would advance this discussion, but I don't see any value in name-calling. I really don't like these sorts of comments on Hacker News.
- staunch 17y agoThose quotation marks don't mean what you think they do. I wrote that he was a "well known scumbag" and (separately) "a leech and bottom feeder". Listing his primary attributes like you did would be totally out of line. Anyway, my comments would stand up in court. Truth is an absolute defense. Nick Denton is infamous. Google him. He runs such gems as Valleywag, Gawker, and Defamer. Self identifies as a "gossip merchant" and the title of his own web site is "Nick Denton: The long and illustrious history of bile", which is entirely accurate.
- tbrooks 17y agoI don't think Denton deserves all the credit for this controversy - although he's an easy target because he's the face of Gawker. The authors and editors of Gizmodo are responsible as well...
- razerbeans 17y agoSeeing the name-drop of the Apple engineer on Gizmodo made my jaw drop. I couldn't believe that they would do such a thing. This no doubt casts a shadow on his career and life. It's a reckless attempt by what appears to be a subpar site to make itself somewhat legitimate. In this respect, they've failed miserably.
- fairramone 17y agoNot entirely true. I ask EVERYONE I interview what their biggest screw up has been career wise. If they don't have anything interesting to share, I don't want them working for me. This guy has a great story to tell and a real lesson learned.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoAs much as I hate to defend Gawker I don't think you can blame them for the negative impact on his career. Say what you will he is guilty of what they claim he did. I would hope future employers would be willing to look past it and realize it was an innocent mistake but they have a right to know. In the end this incident is relevant to how much you trust him with prototypes in the future. Beyond that Gawker is a news source. It's their job to report on stories. So while it was dishonest to buy the stolen prototype this post is just reporting the story and I'm not sure it's out of the bounds of what a news organization should do.
- gr366 17y agoAfter this event, I'll bet you can trust him with future prototypes more than anyone else on this planet.
- winterlightning 17y agoYet no one ever would want to
- rrhyne 17y agoOnly a boss who is not worth working for would think this guy is incapable of learning this lesson after all that.
- barlo 17y agoThe article states the phone was lost on the April 18th, but Engadget had the same bar story and pictures on April 17th. http://www.engadget.com/2010/04/17/iphone-4g-is-this-it http://www.engadget.com/2010/04/17/iphone-4g-is-this-it Does this not add up, or am I missing something?
- robosox 17y agoYou're missing something :-) the phone was lost on March 18th, not April.
- albertsun 17y agoThis outrage is misplaced and the example he uses comparing the iPhone to a naked picture is ludicrous. Of all the attacks we have against people's personal character by blogs and the old and new media, attaching this guy's name to the phone he lost is practically nothing. It's just business, not some attack on his character. As an employee of Apple, Gray Powell represents Apple. His name is part of the story. Due to a mistake of his Gizmodo scored a huge coup and got their hands on an unreleased iPhone and a big story. Good for them.
- prasen 17y agoif gizmodo had not outed him, it could have been successfully sued for theft. Apple considers the phone stolen - an excuse given by powell to obviously save his ass - and had giz not explained the events as to how they got the phone - they would have got screwed. So yeah, everyone makes mistakes - but you've got to learn from them :)
- BigZaphod 17y agoSo you're saying that because Gizmodo published some text on a blog that their version of the story is now more true than Gary's may have been? You're assuming Gary didn't simply tell Apple the truth when he lost it. Why?
- ahoyhere 17y agoIn the state of CA, you're breaking the law if you don't turn found property into the police. You're also breaking the law in every state if you purchase or otherwise receive stolen goods. You can't get around the law by smearing somebody on your blog.
- qeorge 17y agoThe engineer in question is a good friend of several of us here at HN. We sincerely appreciate the support he's being shown here and elsewhere around the internet. So there is no doubt: Gray is one of the smartest engineers I've ever had the pleasure of knowing, and I'm sure he feels terrible about this. Although I'm sure this is going to be one of the worst weeks of his life, he will land on his feet, wherever that may be. If he becomes available for hire, I highly recommend him to any startup in the SF area. Its rare to find such a combination of raw talent and work ethic in one engineer.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ryanisinallofus 17y agoHis job was to make stuff at Apple, their job is to report stuff about Apple. No moral outrage please.
- maxharris 17y agoWhen their "job" comes into conflict with state laws concerning theft, moral outrage is appropriate. Gizmodo traded in property they knew was stolen (according to California state law), and that alone is enough for anyone to be angry with them. The way they treated Gray is awful and immoral (if not illegal). I won't visit their site again, and I don't think anyone else should, either (morally speaking).
- Robin_Message 17y agoI have to disagree with this conflation of laws and morals. Journalists certainly break laws; and this may have happened in this case; but I don't see how that makes them immoral. For example, the theft and sale to a newspaper of UK MPs expenses details was illegal but not widely considered immoral. I'd like to quote from [1] before continuing: "Last year, an employee at Foxconn, the Taiwanese company that is one of Apple's biggest suppliers, committed suicide after being accused of stealing a prototype for the iPhone. Sun Danyong, 25, was a university graduate working in the logistics department when the prototype went missing. An investigation revealed that the factory's security staff had beaten him, and he subsequently jumped to his death from the 12th floor of his apartment building." If you want to talk about the legality and morality of Apple trying its damnedest to keep trade secrets, then what is your opinion of Apple using a supplier which beats an employee suspected of theft/loss and pushes him to suicide? Because, (morally speaking) that is far more reprehensible than a journalist getting a scoop by acquiring a trade secret through theft. As to the way Gizmodo treated Gary, well, it sucks that he lost it but that's life, Apple should accept that in-field testing will lead to some losses. Gizmodo couldn't have hidden his identity since presumably only one iPhone 4G has been lost. [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/apple/7330986/Apple-admits-using-child-labour.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/apple/7330986/Apple-ad...
- mahmud 17y agoI will celebrate the day when HN front-page is not filled with Apple drama and gossip.
- barnaby 17y agoAmen Brother!
- pg 17y agoThe reason the frontpage has the stories it does is because they're the ones users have voted for. If you want different stories, the solution starts with you: try voting for some. You haven't voted on any of the stories currently on the frontpage.
- johnswamps 17y agoI think a lot of people don't realize how few users are needed to get a story to the front page. A story often only needs 3-5 votes to do so, giving your one vote a large amount of power. Voting a story from 100 to 101 doesn't really matter, but voting from 3 to 4 is often the difference between the story dying and staying on the front page for several hours.
- jacquesm 17y ago> You haven't voted on any of the stories currently on the frontpage. You do realize you're effective saying here that you monitor the personal voting record of users, and that you're willing to disclose that record without their permission? Also, his whole point was that he didn't vote for those stories. There may be others that he did vote for but that didn't make it to the front page because of all the apple drama.
- profquail 17y agoThere's a big difference between 'monitoring' the personal voting record of users and being able to look it up in the server logs to back up a claim. I doubt that pg would carelessly disclose the voting records of users without their permission (or even with it).
- mjgoins 17y agoMight be better to use an ip address that won't actually point to a machine. Pointing arbitrary names to localhost is probably 99.999 percent safe... but better fully safe than sorry. rfc3330 mentions example ip addresses that are reserved for documentation purposes. Might be able to use those.
- dotBen 17y agoAside from whether Gawker was right or not to name Gray, it's reasons like this why I will never work in such a secretive environment like Apple. It's not that I can't keep a secret, of course I can. But I think it is asking a lot of someone to take a development/unreleased phone into the wild that could be worth $millions to Apple and make sure it doesn't get lost. Before someone says "Well he didn't have to take it to the bar" - well hold on. As a product manager myself, I know first hand how important it is to spend a large amount of time test-driving your product and eating your own dog food. To get really good ideas and feedback on a device like an iPhone, it probably is required to take it outside of the office and actually use it "in the wild". I just don't think I would want to shoulder such responsibility, esp as we can now see the public fallout from loosing it. You can imagine the private fallout that is also occurring right now for Gray. Some jobs are just not worth having, and maybe this is Apple asking too much of its engineers and product people.
- tomwans 17y agoGizmodo's attitude is making me sick. All of these articles have such a "haha, gotcha!" attitude towards Apple (and especially Gray) for no reason at all. Apple is secretive about their products, so what? You got the prototype. Take the photos and report on it. There's no reason to divulge all this information about Gray. Apple knew who lost the phone already, since they were able to wipe it remotely. Their snide remarks and attitude in both http://gizmodo.com/5520479/a-letter-apple-wants-its-secret-iphone-back http://gizmodo.com/5520479/a-letter-apple-wants-its-secret-i... and http://gizmodo.com/5520438/how-apple-lost-the-next-iphone http://gizmodo.com/5520438/how-apple-lost-the-next-iphone make me feel as if the Gizmodo writing staff consists entirely of 8th graders.
- Glide 17y agoI would worry far more about the editors that allow this behavior and the higher ups that gave the ok on publishing the guy's name.
- tomwans 17y ago... http://gizmodo.com/5520669/it-was-gray-powells-birthday http://gizmodo.com/5520669/it-was-gray-powells-birthday ... really? did you kick him enough while he was down? It's just unethical to exploit someone this much just for your ad clicks.
- tomwans 17y agoAgreed: http://www.tuaw.com/2010/04/20/apple-we-want-device-back/ http://www.tuaw.com/2010/04/20/apple-we-want-device-back/ this is more concise and well said than I could ever be.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- agranig 17y agoyou are aware of the fact that 'accidantely' leaking secret information is and has always been part of Steve's game, aren't you?
- statictype 17y agoNo. I'm pretty sure Apple doesn't do very many planned leaks and certainly not to Gizmodo.
- kgermino 17y agoApple has been known to do planned leaks when it suited them. (The iPad leak during CES is an excellent example) but its usually just letting a friendly reporter know a few details from the specs, not 'accidentally' leaving a phone at a bar or anything like that.
- dasht 17y agoThere are two big problems with all this fretting over Gray: 1) Um, he was allowed to leave the Infinite Loop campus (or wherever he works) with the phone -- indeed, was presumably supposed to. The risks of accidental lossage are a calculated risk that Apple took a long time ago. 2) Is there any indication whatsoever that his mojo at Apple has been harmed? If it has, that speaks far worse of Apple than it does of him.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- abronte 17y agoHas anyone heard if Gray is going to continue working at Apple?
- lyudmil 17y agoI'm not sure Mr. Powell is paying attention to the continued coverage. If he is, I'd like to offer a couple of words of encouragement. I think Mr. Powell is the only one in this story who stands on firm moral ground. He made a simple, honest mistake. All indicators point that he behaved courageously, presumably coming forward and admitting the device is missing since Apple shut it down remotely the next day. Yes, Apple management will be upset and may decide to let Mr. Powell go, but he has fulfilled his professional obligations to Apple and shown considerable courage in doing so. Future employers hiring intelligently should realize that their employers will make costly mistakes and someone who has demonstrated he openly takes responsibility and is willing to work to fix the damage they've done should be a valuable asset. The actions of the person who found the phone are morally dubious. I don't see how you could possibly justify "playing around" with a phone you have just found while presumably waiting to return it to its owner. If this person is interested in defending their actions I'd like some proof that they did not shy away from contact with Mr. Powell (I assume he tried calling his own phone when he found out it was missing) and that they did in fact call Apple trying to get through to someone. I would also like an argument justifying their disclosure of Mr. Powell's personal details to Gizmodo when handing over the device. Something in the whole story seems a little fishy. Gizmodo has clearly overstepped their bounds by publishing personal details about Mr. Powell. It is clear they are getting traffic and therefore benefitting from doing so at the expense of Mr. Powell. It is also clear that this is mere gossip and therefore of no journalistic value. Apple is a large, public technology company. Applying moral or ethical principles in their case is nonsensical. What I can say for sure is that the leaked content may not have as huge of an adverse effect as perhaps anticipated. I already know a number of people who are committed to buying the new device when it comes out. I know, Steve Jobs doesn't get to announce it and blow everyone's minds at the keynote, but apart from that there may not be much harm. Last thing. Let's have a little bit of perspective here. We're talking about a phone. And yet we have a person possibly stealing personal property, violating someone's privacy by looking at content on the phone, selling the device and the personal information to a media outlet, who then publishes both publicly, undermining Mr. Powell's career. All of this so that we get to find out about a new phone a little bit earlier. I haven't fleshed out a lot of the ethical details in my head yet, but this seems like a lot of tech geek douchebaggery.
- 17y ago
- buster 17y agoOk, i agree that the name shouldn't have been mentioned. But that's a lot fuzz. It's not like Apple doesn't know he lost his phone. So, if he is to face consequences, than it's with or without the article. Seeing that Gizmodo called him, they probably even asked for the permission? I can even imagine that companies are contacting him now, in case he loses his job (who doesn't want to hire an engineer who works on the next gen iphone).
- ryanisinallofus 17y agoI wonder if Gawker get moral outrage over news about Paris Hilton?
- papachito 17y agoYou must be new to the internet, the phone leaked, the story of how it happened leaked, it was only a matter of time before the name of the guy leaked, gizmodo or not, it's obvious that many people knew who it was.
- deno 17y agoNo, it's not obvious. Who knew? Do you know the guy that sold them the phone for $10K? It's Gizmodo that we hate — they are suppose to be journalists of some sorts, not bunch of kids on 4chan to which the poor standards you described indeed apply.
- jacquesm 17y agoSuggestion: add gizmodo to the HN banned domains list.
- sree_nair 17y agoYes, Can we do this till they apologise publically and withdrew all links to this story please?. Let's do something than just talking.
- derwiki 17y agoThis seems sort of absurd -- I don't think HN should ban any domains. If people want to read something, it gets voted up. If they don't, it gets flagged or not upvoted. Why should the subset of users who care about this thread (I almost missed it) censor an entire domain for everyone else? If it really bothers you, write a Greasemonkey script to mask certain domains.
- jacquesm 17y agoThere is an extensive list of domains banned on HN. For the most part they're for different reasons though, but it's not like HN does not ban certain domains. In fact, pg explicitly banned the blog of vaksel for naming someone (and that someone had in fact done something illegal). So if that was a reason for banning a domain then this should be too imo.
- thewileyone 17y agoGet a hold of an Apple prototype - Awesome Tearing it apart to expose new features - Awesome Posting it all online for the world to see - Awesome Exposing the employee who lost the prototype - Major dick move
- cwisecarver 17y agoI can't believe how many of you are so wrong about this. Gizmodo is in business to make money. They just made a lot of it and their article revealing the hardware, which i'm waiting for, will make more. The engineer is newsworthy. He contributes to the facts of the story. If you want to be angry with someone how about the person who found the phone? The person who knew the name of the owner and still sold the phone to the tabloid. The person who had to click two virtual buttons to be talking to someone who knew the owner and and could get the phone back to him. The person who could have Facebook messaged the owner and returned the phone. But he didn't. He sold a piece of obviously lost property to a tabloid. He probably could have gotten a much nicer reward from apple anyway considering their market cap these days.
- enjo 17y agoHe's also going to be going to jail. Watch.
- lenni 17y agoI'm a bit confused. Did the iPhone also have pictures of this guy's girlfriend?
- smutticus 17y agoI'm surprised about some of the comments here. There is no reason they needed to post this guy's name. It simply isn't relevant to the story at all. It's like they thought it was a good idea to kick someone when they were already down. It's just petty.
- petercooper 17y agoDid they change their article? I only saw it a couple of hours ago and it seemed pretty soft towards him.. going as far as to say it wasn't really an onerous fault and that he shouldn't be fired for making a simple mistake. It certainly didn't seem negative enough to create the shitstorm currently going on here and on Twitter..
- esjr 17y agoI bet that the guy that lost the wallet, the stranger that found it and the guy that put the picture of said girlfriend up on the interwebs, are now having beers in that very same bar payed for by the girlfriend.
- MWinther 17y agoIsn't the only account of exactly what happened based on hearsay from some guy who sold lost/stolen property to Gawker for $5,000?
- brown9-2 17y agoWhat I find even more amazing than Gizmodo publishing the guy's name is Gizmodo feeling free to post pictures they found on his phone. What's privacy?
- mkyc 17y agoAll else aside, calling the person who turned the phone over to Gizmodo a thief might amount to slander, so Craig should be careful. This would be something for a court to decide: e.g. http://data.opi.mt.gov/bills/mca/45/6/45-6-302.htm http://data.opi.mt.gov/bills/mca/45/6/45-6-302.htm . Note "permanently".
- danieldon 17y agoWhy are you looking at Montana law when this incident occurred in California? http://www.citmedialaw.org/blog/2010/lost-and-found-california-law-and-next-generation-iphone http://www.citmedialaw.org/blog/2010/lost-and-found-californ... It's not a secret that when you find lost property you either leave it with the establishment in case the owner comes back looking for it, contact the owner directly or, failing that, take it to the police. Instead of doing that, he took it home, took it apart and sold it to gizmodo.
- jamesbressi 17y agoI am embarrassed to ask, but what does this do? (regarding this from the link) "Until Gizmodo publicly apologizes to Gray Powell, this is going to be in my /etc/hosts and in all of the DNS servers under my control: 127.0.0.1 gizmodo.com 127.0.0.1 www.gizmodo.com 127.0.0.1 m.gizmodo.com 127.0.0.1 gawker.com 127.0.0.1 www.gawker.com 127.0.0.1 m.gawker.com "
- dazmax 17y agoIt redirects those urls so you can't access them from your computer. It's the simplest way to block a site.
- jamesbressi 17y agoDuh! Thank you for wasting your time to answer me. I have no idea why that didn't register. So now anything on his network will fail to load those URL's; rather I was thinking there was something larger at play that was going to be disruptive beyond his local. Don't ask why I was assuming this.
- kapitti 17y agohttp://www.bradcolbow.com/archive.php/?p=225 http://www.bradcolbow.com/archive.php/?p=225
- betageek 17y agoMuch as it's not cool of Gizmodo to drag this guys name on to the front pages I think everyone engaged in the Apple rumour mill is culpable in this, especially Apple themselves. Gruber over at Daring Fireball basically called Gizomodo out by implying the phone was stolen. Apple love taunting the fan boys with the secrecy and ratcheting up the tension - this is the result. It's all very funny until someone gets hurt.
- mattmaroon 17y agoThis is absurd. Gizmodo owes no apology. They're journalists (however loosely) and a journalist's job is to report the W's, including the who. It's a relevant fact, and one of great interest, how an iPhone prototype wound up lost at a bar. They've been pretty clear the whole time that it was an honest mistake on the guy's part. Could happen to anyone. They most certainly did not smear the guy at all. I don't think they were rude about it at all, they were reporting the facts. In fact I'd say they were overly generous. Why the hell was he carrying a top secret iPhone prototype to a place that exists solely to get you drunk? He was careless, and it was his fault. If I were Apple, I wouldn't fire him, as I'm sure he won't do that again, and I generally don't believe in firing people for making mistakes. That's how you learn, and we all do it. But he'd not be taking any prototypes off-campus for a long time. I mean, the guy left an iPhone prototype at a bar. That's like a CIA agent leaving a map to Osama Bin Laden's hideout at a McDonalds. A large part of his job is to not lose the prototype iPhone, and he failed. To blame it on a bar-goer is absolutely ridiculous. The guy who found the thing allegedly tried to give it back. He's a better guy than me, I would have called up Microsoft, Engadget, and PC Magazine and had an auction. Apple's institutionalized dickishness (further proof that corporate culture comes directly from it's leaders' personalities) actually prevented him from being honest. They deserved what they got on this one.
- ubernostrum 17y agoThey're journalists (however loosely) If by "loosely" you mean "not at all", then I'd agree. and a journalist's job is to report the W's, including the who. It's a relevant fact, and one of great interest, how an iPhone prototype wound up lost at a bar. It's a relevant fact that it was lost at a bar. Publicly shaming the individual, though? Doesn't add a damn thing to the story. In fact I'd say they were overly generous. I'd say they ought to be reading up on laws governing receipt of stolen property. They deserved what they got on this one. Yes, as we all know: two wrongs will always make a right.
- mattmaroon 17y agoGizmodo is much closer to journalism than anything else in the Gawker network, though that's obviously a "skinniest kid at fat camp" compliment. I won't say I'm a fan, but they do some good work on occasion. Sometimes solid reporting causes shaming, such as when someone does something wrong. It's unavoidable, if occasionally regrettable. Shaming is not unethical in that respect, it's simply exposition of facts. It's no less relevant who dropped the iPhone than who leaked Valerie Plame's name. They didn't go out of their way to shame him. They didn't say "he check out what this donkey did, I sure hope he gets fired for it". They in fact mentioned many times that it could happen to anyone. It's quite relevant who did it because it gives you a picture of how it happened. It's also a great look into Apple's closely-guarded secrecy. Who would have suspected that engineers are taking next-gen phones to bars? It's also standard operating procedure in journalism to name who. The reaction against this is nothing more than "there but for the grace of God go I" which is not a valid reason to call for an apology. It's not that Gizmodo did anything wrong, which they clearly didn't, at least not in naming him. (Perhaps buying the phone crossed a legal or ethical line, but that was clearly not OP's problem.)