4 ms·
Quick aside to the fact that in Aleppo, Damascus, Kirkuk, and Daraa, and Mosul and that many other places in Syria and Iraq are horrible places to be. The situ
by jwtadvice 10y ago
Quick aside to the fact that in Aleppo, Damascus, Kirkuk, and Daraa, and Mosul and that many other places in Syria and Iraq are horrible places to be.
The situation in Syria as it stands today is complicated, sure. But it's also pretty easy to summarize why Aleppo and its outcome is important in the proxy war.
Aleppo is a major population center and a "hub" in the spoke-and-hub network of cities and towns in Syria. When - and if - there is a political transition for the government of Syria, the forces that stand in Aleppo will have an outsized influence in the outcome.
In this manner Aleppo has been an important battleground for the current administration in Damascus and the Russians who have national security interests in the secular government of Syria. For the same reasons the opposition - the rebel and terrorist forces in Syria - have been trying to take and hold Aleppo.
The United States and Russia had been trying to broker a ceasefire, but ultimately the city's value to proxy forces and foreign backers proved too much and the mutual trust between great powers too little for a negotiation to be reached.
Now that the ceasefire is off the table, the United States does not have a legal option for intervening. It has not ruled out - and may be engaged today in - covert illegal activity with respect to attacks on Syrian Government forces and infrastructure. On the other hand Russia was invited in by a government that is still internationally recognized and can intervene in Aleppo on a legal international basis.
One option open to the United States is to try to intervene in Aleppo on account of a humanitarian basis, in which case it needs public opinion and material support to bolster a legal argument.
This is the reason that the United States and its media companies have been focusing so much on the situation in Aleppo, narrating it as a particularly horrible instance of the civil war.
The same sort of narrative campaign, it is easy to notice, is absent from reporting on Sanaa (Yemen), on the current operations in Mosul, of the Turkish (illegal?) military invasions of Greece and Iraq, of US bombing in Northern Syria, of Kabul and of military operations in Afghanistan, or of the mass innocent casualties in a number of places around the world from the Predator Drone mass assassination programme.
Aleppo is a tragedy. Truly. The proxy war in Syria - and all of the regional and foreign power who have made it worse by pumping weapons and funding into it (including the US) - is a horror, and an acknowledgement that we still aren't at a place with our civilization where we can resolve tensions of competing international interest with rules, peace, diplomacy, and mutual benefit.
- BurningFrog 10y ago> invasions of Greece What?
- jwtadvice 10y agoSaid Greek islands that Turkey (under Attaturk) lost when it settled a peace treaty (Treaty of Lausanne) after WWI and which Turkey has had a habit of violations and military interventions of since that time (which has continued to this day). Know that the invasion of Iraq is of course much more serious, as the are all of the others in the list. The inclusion of the Greek islands was just verbosity from yours truly, and not intended to imply more than a touchpoint for those familiar with Turkey's illegal incursions. Please don't let that distract you from the more important general topic written above. If you want ignore the aside about Greece - it's not important to the overall message.
- low_battery 10y agoI presume you are a young Greek. Only that could explain your perception of events.
- seizethecheese 10y agoAs if one's views are enough to presuppose one's identity.
- low_battery 10y agoBelieve me, sometimes it is, I am 99% sure in this case.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI am an American with no close contacts to Greeks in my family, business or otherwise.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoGreat comment, and it's so refreshing to find someone who really understands what is going on (in contrast, my Facebook feed is filled with people wailing about every new photo of a bloodied Syrian child). Still, I'm afraid that it won't be enough. The war drum is already beating towards Syria, and I wouldn't be surprised if the US mounted an offensive shortly after HRC is crowned--to stop some imminent genocide or other humanitarian crisis, no doubt.