8 ms·
Tesla plunges in Consumer Reports' rankings
- omarforgotpwd 10y ago"Yeah I really wanted a Tesla but then I read Consumer Reports. Yeah it's still around. Anyway, I got a hummer instead." -- Nobody, ever
- otterley 10y agoThe ambiguity in this claim made me chuckle: "The amount of issues we've addressed with Model X has fallen by 92% in the last 12 months..." Does that mean their ability to fix existing issues has fallen by 92%? Or does it mean that the number of outstanding issues has fallen by 92%? Words matter.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoI think it means: "For every 100 issues we had to address each day 12 months ago, we only have to address 8 issues per day, today."
- toomuchtodo 10y agohttp://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability/car-reliability-survey-2016/ http://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability/car-reliabili... Can we get the LA Times clickbait title fixed (I suggest "Consumer Reports Recommends Model S Again Following Reliability Survey; Model X Didn't Fare Well")? And maybe point to the above direct CR source?
- maxerickson 10y agoIf you want the discussion to be about the Consumer Reports report, Tesla probably ain't in the title.
- ceterum_censeo 10y agohttp://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability/car-brands-reliability-how-they-stack-up/ http://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability/car-brands-re... is a better link, since it has the actual table referenced by the article.
- awqrre 10y agoSince they have so few models in production, the title is pretty accurate...
- RodericDay 10y ago> "I think there was some hubris there with the X," [Musk] added, before reiterating that it was "the best car ever." Musk sounds like Trump sometimes. Reminds me of this other line of his: > Musk is a self-described American exceptionalist and nationalist, describing himself as "nauseatingly pro-American". According to Musk, the United States is "[inarguably] the greatest country that has ever existed on Earth", describing it as "the greatest force for good of any country that's ever been". Musk believes outright that there "would not be democracy in the world if not for the United States", arguing there were "three separate occasions in the 20th-century where democracy would have fallen with World War I, World War II and the Cold War, if not for the United States".
- mikeash 10y agoAt least Musk has reviews from reputable organizations to back him up there.
- hourislate 10y agoMaybe it's just me but I don't really find Consumers Reports useful or that reputable. Especially their vehicle reviews. Having several mechanics in the family and being a car enthusiast myself I find their past recommendations of Hyundai and Kia laughable.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe car reviews are awful. They like who they like. I remember one Honda that had a transmission recall, defective radio and a tendency for body trim to fall off (according to the little blurb) and was rated awesome. The equivalent Ford was dinged because the OEM tires were noisy.
- kodis 10y ago> The [CR] car reviews are awful. They like who they like. So do they like Tesla or dislike Tesla? Only a year ago or so they rated the Model S as the best car they had ever reviewed; then there were a few Autopilot failures and some troubles with the Model X -- now the honeymoon seems to be over. It's not that I think CR does a wonderful job with cars -- or with any other product that I'm familiar with -- but I think that their biases are more complex than a simple "they like who they like".
- pfarnsworth 10y agoI'm generally a TSLA bear, I think they're a money pit and will run out of money, especially after that disasterous decision to buy SolarCity. I'm currently short TSLA via puts because I think the SCTY purchase is going to cripple both companies. But there's something to be said about trying shoot for the moon, and trying to build "the best car ever." I, in fact, do admire that all-in, ballsy move, from a techie's perspective. And if it were limited in quantities, I'm sure he could accomplish it, because there are some very amazing features in all of Tesla's cars, however, I don't believe it's possible to mass produce reliably in the timeframe they need, given their track record. I just don't think from the point of view of a business, it's the right thing to do.
- sien 10y agoThe Economist's articles on Tesla this week are remarkable. SolarCity could bring down Tesla. Another SpaceX crash might too. It's all too much risk and the dubious financing strategies coming up with buy/buyback and whatnot look like financial engineering. Between that and depending on a growth rate like Apple or Google at their peak when they were financed it's all too much. http://www.economist.com/news/business/21709061-entrepreneurs-finances-are-jaw-dropping-inventive-and-combustible-his-space http://www.economist.com/news/business/21709061-entrepreneur... Musk is incredible, but it looks like there will be a messy end. Tesla and SpaceX's technology will no doubt survive though.
- beambot 10y agoWhy actively trade against a moonshot -- Would you have done the same against NASA for the moon landings...? My understanding is that short positions are not merely passive; they can have a detrimental effect (in aggregate) on a company's likelihood of success. Are you really interested in harming the company (even if fairly negligibly for you as an individual) in exchange for some modicum of personal financial gain? Sorry, I just don't get it. Assuming NASA's $18.4B budget is split evenly among 300M Americans... I'm paying ~$60/yr for NASA. I would gladly pay that to TSLA even if it didn't have "good business prospects" as a way to push forward humanity -- that it continues to have financial upside is just a bonus. In this world, we so rarely get a chance to "vote with our dollars" in a meaningful way. The fact that some people have grandeur plans and work tirelessly to progress humanity is amazing; that others just want to naysay and profit off their crashes & burns... it boggles my mind.
- DubiousPusher 10y agoHonestly with how much simpler Tesla's cars should be their position on Consumer Reports' round ups has always troubled me. It's the main reason I'd lean away from buying one even if I could justify it financially. As a side note. I switched from BMW to Lexus a year ago and have been a much happier car owner. Edit: I'm going to retract this. Looking into Tesla guts a bit and some things I thought would be much simpler actually get more complex like the cooling system.
- jhulla 10y agoWhat makes you happier? Easier to drive, better mileage, maintenance costs?
- DubiousPusher 10y agoI was spending a lot of weekends fixing little things here and there. The only reason it wasn't costing an arm and a leg is because I was doing the work myself but the parts were crazy expensive. Also, removing some components that should've been easy was painfully time consuming.
- etimberg 10y agoYes, overall, it is simpler but a lot of the complex electronics have to be replaced if they break. None of it is really end user serviceable.
- DubiousPusher 10y agoYeah, reading up and this was an ignorant thought on my part.
- solotronics 10y agoMy extended family has a large percentage of Lexus cars. They have amazing reliability, fair resale values, cheap parts if something does break. Yes some BMW and Audi might be more fun to drive in some ways but I trust my Lexus to get around with rock steady dependability.
- Animats 10y agoWell, there's this little problem... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJ7vqAUJdbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJ7vqAUJdbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoSNw_n1Xgk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoSNw_n1Xgk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQkx-4pFjus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQkx-4pFjus Note that those are all the same design flaw.
- cheriot 10y ago"In retrospect, it would've been a better decision to do fewer things with the first version of Model X," Musk said in February. "I think there was some hubris there with the X," Says the guy that wants to fly a rocket to mars next? Musk is the news story that I can't stop watching. Thankfully he's using that power for better ends than Trump!
- WhitneyLand 10y agoHow many Tesla insiders knew reliability would be poor before the first customer picked up a Model X? Certainly it was known by many of the key engineers, possibly some in management, but the interesting question is did Musk himself know? It's hard to believe he would knowingly tarnish the brand by delivering the least reliable SUV in America to customers. On the other hand, it was already 18 months late - the pressure from all sides to deliver must have been enormous, with people on the edge of burnout. As a purist, it's easy to say hold out as long as needed and don't compromise, but at some point it could have become a duke nukem forever scenario. Pick your poison.
- Shivetya 10y agohe stated he was camping the production line, if this is true then how could he not know. maybe they were counting on buyers of the X to be so enthralled they would over look the issues? I know reading the forums you do get some rabid sycophants who defend about anything, get off the forums into the wild and it can be sillier. I was simply shocked someone actually defended having their axles replaced. The only X at work has misaligned door handles, front to passenger are so off its just odd looking.
- vgt 10y agoI think we're seeing Elon Musk's strategy of hitting the market early play out here. Same thing is happening with "autopilot" - the aggressive marketing has clearly cost lives, but it helps Tesla in their future endeavors (for now, at least). By contrast, Google's self-driving tech is years and years ahead of Tesla's. Google is not interested in going to market with this technology until it's 100% ready.
- LordHumungous 10y agoElon seems to think that innovation means vastly over promising, and then expecting it all to work out via the triumph of his will, or something. It's an attitude that reeks more than a little of arrogance, as if he's started to believe his own bullshit a little too much.
- amluto 10y agoThis isn't quite what the article is talking about, but the Model S itself is decreasing in usability, too, in my opinion. One critical component of car design is that all of the functions intended for use by the driver should be operable with minimum distraction. On the Model S, most functionality is on the touch screen, and, with the latest firmware update, almost all the touchscreen controls auto-hide. So now, to access the controls, you have to tap the screen to brig the controls back, wait a second or two, and then use the (already fairly attentions intensive) controls. Of course, Tesla seems to think that the driver doesn't actually need to pay attention to the road... Frankly, I miss the experience of driving my old Lexus. It wasn't fancy, but you could control basically everything by feel without looking away from the road.
- greglindahl 10y agoI find that almost everything I want to do is (still) on the steering wheel. If I want to use the touch screen, I tap it without looking to bring up the controls, wait a second, and then they're in basically in the same place they've always been.
- asenna 10y ago> If I want to use the touch screen, I tap it without looking to bring up the controls, wait a second, and then they're in basically in the same place they've always been. I've never sat in a Tesla but that sounds crazy. Why would they want to hide everything away? Aesthetics?
- greglindahl 10y agoA bigger map is the main benefit that I see.
- Lightbody 10y agoYES!!! I'm mostly a Tesla fan, but between the 8.0 software usability issues and the ongoing (minor) fit and finish problems with my 2013 S, I'm reluctant to buy anything else from them until they can prove they've figured this stuff out.