3 ms·
The real reason to oppose Basic Income isn't based on moralizing about social programs, but that what it promises is the exact opposite of the net effect it wil
by mindslight 10y ago
The real reason to oppose Basic Income isn't based on moralizing about social programs, but that what it promises is the exact opposite of the net effect it will have!
I too want a world where people are not on a treadmill that forces them into wage slavery. But the first step is recognizing that the primary driver of modern individuals' needing to work is the payment of rent on assets that are becoming ever-less feasible to purchase outright.
This is the direct result of the past few decades of extreme inflationary monetary policy. In a time of such technological process, prices should be steadily dropping at an unprecedented rate. But instead, the Fed actually has an explicit policy of forcing them to rise, with the actual professed goal to keep everybody working full time!!
Since new money is created by loaning against specific assets, the newly created money just ends up bidding up the book-prices of consumer-desired assets, closing the CPI feedback loop when the rent (interest) has finally risen enough to take up consumer surplus.
Basic income is thus just an extension of this ongoing policy that naively adds to this inflationary treadmill - giving everyone in SF $1k/mo will result in housing rent going up by roughly $1k/mo.
The real solution we need is the exact opposite - a return to sane monetary policy where individuals are able to save and able to reasonably purchase assets like houses. The ability to save and build wealth gives people stability (not worrying about being out of work for a few months) and thus economic bargaining power to demand higher real wages and fewer working hours. This is the equilibrium mechanic that will constructively respond to the need for ever-less work, finally letting wider society see the gains from increased productivity.
- taurath 10y agoHow does one save if they don't make money in the first place? There are plenty of affordable places that you can buy a house at near minimum wage, but when that minimum wage job goes away there's nothing left. In my experience, people don't have very much bargaining power even if they are financially stable, own a home and have savings when a force such as globalized trade comes through town - there is no bargaining power big enough to avoid shutting down a plant or a business, or moving it across state or country lines. People need income before being able to save, before being able to purchase assets regardless of their price. Whats more likely is that a factory that previously paid 400 people $10 an hour would rather pay 20 people $30 an hour, and that 380 people have no negotiating power.
- mindslight 10y ago> There are plenty of affordable places that you can buy a house at near minimum wage, but when that minimum wage job goes away there's nothing left. So this aspect is orthogonal to what I addressed in my original comment, hence my example of "$1k/mo to everyone in SF" - ruling out someone still getting $1k/mo after leaving SF. Economic feedback most immediately applies to in-demand housing markets where one can't simply cheaply acquire their own land and put up their own structure. But these type of concentrated areas are where the bulk of our economic activity is now occurring. The flip side of this is that if BI were at a national level, there would be a demand to move to rural areas where land was cheap, to reduce the largest rent. But since, as you point out, the economic opportunities are quite limited there such areas would be entirely reliant on BI. This would further cement the divide between urban "rat racers" and rural poverty, making it harder for those involuntarily caught in the latter to leave. > Whats more likely is that a factory that previously paid 400 people $10 an hour would rather pay 20 people $30 an hour, and that 380 people have no negotiating power BI won't restore those 380 people's negotiating power. Since their labor isn't demanded, they will effectively become wards of the state. With the economics I'm talking about, the 20 (40hr) people that are still employed gain bargaining power as they build liquid wealth. Rather than spending their entire life working, they demand fewer hours per week which actually restores demand for the other 380. This seems less convincing in the context of your extreme example (before all 400 could work 2 hours/week, other factors will start to matter), but the point is that this is the trend that should have already been happening for the prior decade instead of overleveraging encouraging sink-or-swim overworking. I'm actually not categorically ruling out the idea of BI. It's just that current calls for it completely ignore any feedback due to our official economic policy, and are actually just a continuation of the broken policy that has largely put us in this situation to begin with.
- taurath 10y ago> The flip side of this is that if BI were at a national level, there would be a demand to move to rural areas where land was cheap, to reduce the largest rent. But since, as you point out, the economic opportunities are quite limited there such areas would be entirely reliant on BI. This would further cement the divide between urban "rat racers" and rural poverty, making it harder for those involuntarily caught in the latter to leave. I'm not so sure myself - if you have nothing but time to pursue whatever it is that you want to do, would people not spend a lot of that time working on hobbies and interests? The amount of time that potentially highly productive people spend performing and just mentally/physically recovering from menial/dead-end work could be put to much better use. There's no reason with the internet today that that person couldn't become a rocket scientist despite living in a cheap area. Escaping the trap of these cheap rural areas is only difficult for economic reasons - its harder to save money when almost every bit of the low paying job goes to rent - you are spending your time spinning your wheels instead of experimenting, educating yourself or others. > This seems less convincing in the context of your extreme example (before all 400 could work 2 hours/week, other factors will start to matter), but the point is that this is the trend that should have already been happening for the prior decade instead of overleveraging encouraging sink-or-swim overworking. > I'm actually not categorically ruling out the idea of BI. It's just that current calls for it completely ignore any feedback due to our official economic policy, and are actually just a continuation of the broken policy that has largely put us in this situation to begin with. Asset inflation would surely happen in some areas, but we'd at least establish a basic floor. Everything could become higher priced, but it would allow for more fluidity and risk taking, and much more focus on education and learning. I feel like it'd be worthwhile to continue to experiment.
- dllthomas 10y agoI'll preface this with a note that "$1k/mo for SF residents" is not something I'd propose, and possibly not something I'd support. > giving everyone in SF $1k/mo will result in housing rent going up by roughly $1k/mo. It would rise, but there's no reason to expect it to be close to 1/1. Note that this is very different than inflation, where the money they're being asked for is worth less (it might also cause some inflation, but that's a bit of a separate question). It is also very different from loans or grants marked specifically for housing, where recipients can't turn around and spend the money on something else. In this setting, competition remains in full force. And not simply competition of perfect substitutes. Say it rises $500/mo. If I live with parents longer, we save an extra $500/mo. If I take on an extra roommate, we save a collective extra $500/mo. There is plenty of drive to save that money, and those with the flexibility to do so will do so. Some extra cash each month will grant that flexibility to more people than currently have it. That decrease in demand will be reflected in a lower price than your analysis would suggest. (It would also probably mean fewer units bought by investors from outside the city left to sit idle. I've heard mixed reports as to how much of an impact that's had on the present situation.)