6 ms·
Fix the fucking educational system and stop wasting people's time.
by adamnemecek 10y ago
Fix the fucking educational system and stop wasting people's time.
- busterarm 10y agoAs a jumping off point, undo the damage Ronald Reagan did to it.
- refurb 10y agoReagan was last president almost 30 years ago. Time to blame someone else.
- jowiar 10y agoSam Brownback?
- ethanbond 10y agoYeah, everyone knows that causality has a hard limit of 25 years! It's a ruse to imply that Reagan's policies don't play a role in this. GP didn't claim that he's exclusively responsible, just that correcting those mistakes would be a good place to start. Do you think that kids aren't thrown in jail every single day for war-on-drug offenses simply because Reagan was president almost 30 years ago?
- refurb 10y agojust that correcting those mistakes would be a good place to start That's my point. Regan has been dead for a while, he can't fix things now. If you don't like how things are going, blame the current people in power.
- ethanbond 10y agoNobody asked a dead man to fix things. GP asked us/the govt to fix the problems the dead man created.
- busterarm 10y agoWho said anything about him being President? Look at what he did to the university system in California as Governor. That was the model for the disaster that followed. Gotta love the kneejerk downvotes I'm getting from people who likely don't have a clue what happened. http://www.newfoundations.com/Clabaugh/CuttingEdge/Reagan.html http://www.newfoundations.com/Clabaugh/CuttingEdge/Reagan.ht... http://www.nytimes.com/1982/12/28/science/california-weighs-end-of-free-college-education.html http://www.nytimes.com/1982/12/28/science/california-weighs-... https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/from-master-plan-to-no-plan-the-slow-death-of-public-higher-education https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/from-master-plan-to-... http://www.salon.com/2014/07/05/ronald_reagan_stuck_it_to_millennials_a_college_debt_history_lesson_no_one_tells/ http://www.salon.com/2014/07/05/ronald_reagan_stuck_it_to_mi... http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Ronald_Reagan_Education.htm http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Ronald_Reagan_Education.htm
- dudul 10y agoHow would you do that?
- adamnemecek 10y agoFundamentally I think that we have to get rid of the concept of a teacher and replace it with person who helps you when you get stuck. I think that fundamentally, the school should just teach you to read as soon as possible and from there on it should just give you things to read. You should also have much more freedom in what you want to study, e.g. if you want to check out idk, optical engineering in high school (even if for the reason that it sounds cool), the high school should be able to somehow assemble a path for you. I think that just about everyone has dreams that can be solved with more knowledge and skill. The path to achieving these isn't always very clear though. The school should be the organization that gives you that clarity and supports you.
- kbenson 10y ago> I think that fundamentally, the school should just teach you to read as soon as possible and from there on it should just give you things to read. I fail to see how this won't devolve into parents that have more time to devote to their children's education through encouragement, steering, tutoring, or paying for the same having a better outcome. And since I think having more money is causal for having more time, I think that's just a way to make the problem worse, not better.
- adamnemecek 10y agoYou replace teachers with tutors. You encourage study group work. You use better educational tools. In Mindstorms, Papert talks about how the computer is fundamentally the best educational tool. This reflects my experience but for some reason computers are barely used in education and if they are, they are used in all the wrong ways. On some level, I think that if the kids need tutors, the system is broken.
- kbenson 10y ago
- harryh 10y agoThe educational system is a scapegoat for far bigger and more entrenched problems.
- jowiar 10y ago"Scapegoat" is probably less accurate than "symptom". In that, in many states (i.e. Kansas), the education system has been deliberately hamstrung by people empowered by the "entrenched problems".
- adamnemecek 10y agoI'm not sure I really want to argue about this but fundamentally I think that you might be thinking that fixing the educational system means making the schools on the wrong side of tracks perform as well as the schools on the other side. It's definitely not that simple, the system as a whole is somewhat flawed.
- harryh 10y agoI certainly understand the desire to not argue with strangers on the internet. :)
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoExactly. I strongly suggest to speak with some actual teachers, instead of blindly relying on ridiculous propaganda. The problem is not the system, the problem is social mobility. Poor kids don't do well in school because their families and their environment don't value education. They perceive (correctly, BTW, from a statistical perspective) that if you're born poor, there isn't much you can do. You're gonna die poor anyway. So why worry about school? Families don't care (exceptions do exist, of course), peers look down upon you if you're "bookish", it's a vicious cycle. There's a lack of hope among those at the bottom. No amount of educational reform will fix that. People know they're in a social straightjacket from birth. Fix whatever systemic problems keep America's social mobility so low, and the aforementioned issues will get a lot better.
- peller 10y ago
- tetraodonpuffer 10y agoeven if the educational system is fixed, it doesn't change the fact that if you're poor you first have to find a job, and entry level jobs in careers are hard to find, so you might end up getting something you're overqualified for just to pay the bills, something unrelated, then maybe while you work at something unrelated life happens, you maybe get married, or have kids, and now leaving your underqualified but paying unrelated job becomes impossible, and by the time you can you've lost 10-15 years and your opportunities will be minimal. If you're rich, you start working in your parents' business, you're also likely to intern in it, and/or in your parents' peers' companies, and if you're any decent you're likely going to be groomed for an exec position, a position the poor college grad will never be able to aspire to, and if you're not decent you're probably going to get some sort of face-saving "consultancy" position, paying again way more than the poor graduate can ever hope to get. This is unrelated to the education system, and it's not something you can ever fix, because people will always try to make sure their family has an advantage, which means that as soon as a family reaches a position of influence it will use it to perpetuate its position. Meritocracy is nice in theory, but humans as a species are wired a lot more for tribalism than for meritocracy, hence why to get some semblance of it you need a culture/government that fosters it, and those are in short supply.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> entry level jobs in careers are hard to find Jobs aren't hard to find if you are one of the few people in the world who can do the job. I know, these aren't entry level jobs but given the right education, you can skip those I think. > This is unrelated to the education system, Fundamentally, I think that few things in society aren't fundamentally related to the educational system. Or more precisely, quite a bit of society can be explained by looking at the educational system 10 years ago.
- csallen 10y agoI, too, think the educational system is the place to turn to help fix lots of society's problems. We have kids "captive" for 8 hours a day for 13 years, so it's an amazing opportunity to do some good. The problem is that everyone has different opinions about what "good" is. I tried a little experiment a couple months ago: I asked 5 of my highly educated friends from MIT how they would improve the educational system. And I got back five very different answers, most of which I found pretty unimpressive. For example, my material scientist friend immediately launched into a tirade about how we should teach kids how subatomic particles actually work rather than the simplified model of the atom, about about how history is a useless subject that should be removed from school altogether. I couldn't have disagreed more. Personally, I'd like to see tons of changes, including: - vastly more funding, so we can attract more skilled and experienced teachers and have smaller class sizes - year round school programs, so poorer children don't fall so behind during summer break - more emphasis and encouragement around reading, which much fewer restrictions on what we consider "acceptable" to read (my high school did everything in its power to get kids to hate reading) - systematic experimentation around different teaching styles and educational systems, so we can learn what works and doesn't - history classes more focused on storytelling and distilling lessons from historical events, and less focused on pro-America propaganda and remembering random disconnected facts and dates - more focus on practical psychology, rhetoric, debate, logic, and/or research in the curriculum (how can people become productive citizens and informed voters when they can't dissect an argument or perform research?) - more emphasis on the benefits of the scientific method compared to alternatives - practical education around business, finance, etc, so that poor kids aren't left behind in that arena I could go on forever.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> my material scientist friend immediately launched into a tirade about how we should teach kids how subatomic particles actually work rather than the simplified model of the atom, That's the problem, we have to get rid of the idea that there's a set of ideas that kids "have" to know. Why don't you let the kid decide what he wants to study. Like there will be limitations but fuck it, if s/he is interested in something weird, encourage it instead of killing it. > vastly more funding, so we can attract more skilled and experienced teachers and have smaller class sizes I think that the teacher model doesn't scale. Develop MOOCs and like online communities. School will be the bridge from real world to these communities. Teachers will help you when you get stuck. > more emphasis and encouragement around reading, which much fewer restrictions on what we consider "acceptable" to read (my high school did everything in its power to get kids to hate reading) Exactly. Also remove the idea that reading means reading fiction. Make sure that the kid is doing something somewhat productive and that s/he's engaged. Engagement is key. >systematic experimentation around different teaching styles and educational systems, so we can learn what works and doesn't I actually think that Barbara Oakley really hit the nail on the head. She describes it e.g. in this article http://nautil.us/issue/40/learning/how-i-rewired-my-brain-to-become-fluent-in-math-rp http://nautil.us/issue/40/learning/how-i-rewired-my-brain-to... > - more focus on practical psychology, rhetoric, debate, logic, and/or research in the curriculum (how can people become productive citizens and informed voters when they can't dissect an argument or perform research?) Exactly. But also fundamentally just make sure the kids can explore whatever area of human endeavor they want to.
- wutbrodo 10y agoI'm personally all for fixing the education system, but the idea that this would fix (or even help) income equality is a fantasy. Denmark is often held up as a model of low-inequality, high-income-mobility, high-education-investment countries. But a recent study indicated that these policies' have zero effect on Danish income mobility and education-attainment mobility relative to the US! Their high levels of equality rely entirely on direct transfers. There's nothing wrong with this per se: despite the costs I'd bear, I wish our system was a little more redistributive, including education investment. But the theoretical positive-sum gains from broadening opportunity regardless of your background are simply not supported by the data. And this is in one of the most income-mobile countries (post-taxes and -transfers) in the world! [1] http://voxeu.org/article/intergenerational-mobility-denmark-and-us http://voxeu.org/article/intergenerational-mobility-denmark-... [2] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/the-american-dream-isnt-alive-in-denmark/494141/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/08/the-amer...
- adamnemecek 10y agoOk, I haven't read the study too closely but I can't imagine how having a more educated population would be beneficial for the society. Also note that you can't really measure poverty by just percentage of income alone. The pool people in US are probably doing better than in Somalia. If nothing else, I can't imagine more education not raising the general standard.
- rcafdm 10y ago1: We have very limited ability to change educational outcomes in this country and the differences between schools have little to do with external inputs (systematic differences in per pupil funding, teacher quality, etc). https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2016/05/09/my-response-to-the-nytimes-article-on-school-districts-test-scores-and-income/ https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2016/05/09/my-r... 2: Years of schools have essentially no explanatory power at an international level (even in lesser developed countries that should have much more "low hanging fruit") Other research shows that without improving test scores, which are strongly influenced by genetics, education is basically worthless for economic development. https://pseudoerasmus.com/2015/06/15/education-econ-growth/ https://pseudoerasmus.com/2015/06/15/education-econ-growth/ 3: Poor people in the US, especially net of taxes and transfers, are quite wealthy by broader international standards. US poor vs Somalia? LOL that's not even a question. The poor in some of the more economically successful nordic/northern european countries might have somewhat higher material living conditions, but the differences are much more modest than you might expect and as compared to what you find in other developed countries (especially larger, less homogeneous, less cherry -picked countries), say, France, Italy, Spain, etc it's far from clear cut. The US also has significantly more diversity in multiple dimensions, especially as compared to an extremely (traditionally) homogeneous country like Denmark. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/10/161011131428.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/10/161011131428.h...
- jomamaxx 10y ago"Fix the fucking educational system and stop wasting people's time." America spends more % of it's GDP and more $ / capita than any nation on earth. America graduates far more people from college than any European country. European Americans score better than Europeans on standardized testing. Same for all ethnic groups: Asian Americans do better than Asians, African Americans do better than Africans etc.. The reason America - on average - fares a little lower than Europe has to do with it's ethnic composition. BTW - I'm not saying that some ethnic groups / races are 'smarter' than others, but that literacy, attitudes towards education etc. are multigenerational things, and most Latino Americans and African Americans are only about 1.5 generations fully literate, so it will take some time to fully catch up. In fact - if you account for ethnicity - America has the best schools in the world - wherever they come in from - they do better than they would have from whence they came. I'm not saying American schools are perfect or whatever - but it's worth noting that if you look at the facts, they don't fit the whole 'American schools are crap' narrative. It's more nuanced than that.