5 ms·
It's worth nothing the new user-image-before-password-input for Google is an anti-phishing feature. Of course, most people won't think that deeply when prompted
by minimaxir 10y ago
It's worth nothing the new user-image-before-password-input for Google is an anti-phishing feature. Of course, most people won't think that deeply when prompted with a password request and a similar UI.
- agwa 10y agoHow does it help? Can't the attacker make a query to Google for the user image and display it on the phishing page?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- minimaxir 10y agoNo. There is no email-to-profile-pic mapping endpoint for unauthenticated users, to my knowledge.
- agwa 10y agoThen how does the image consistently display before the password has been provided? No matter what the answer is, I don't see how it could be an anti-phishing feature.
- minimaxir 10y agoGoogle naturally has their own private APIs which will only show the profile image for legitimate logins.
- lucb1e 10y agoAnd no phisher has ever copied anything from the original site before.
- gog 10y agoBecause the image location is stored in a cookie from before the attack and this cookie will not be sent by a browser to a phishing site. Try from the incognito windows in your browser the image should not show up since no cookies are being sent in the incognito window.
- zaroth 10y agoI use fresh incognito tabs constantly. So I guess I'll never see the image, and never know something is amiss. By I also never click an email link to login unless it's a plain text password reset. I receive authentic looking and topical Dropbox share requests from actual contacts (who have been hacked) trying to phish my Dropbox credentials maybe 4-5 times a year so I'm always on the lookout for it. This is a classic attack. Always check the URL!
- ejcx 10y agoI've seen targeted gmail phishing emails, within the last week, that contain the correct email picture. They are getting images from somewhere...so...no, this isn't a security feature.
- emodendroket 10y agoBut it's also the default behavior if you sign on from a computer Google doesn't recognize, so it's not really strange to see the grey icon instead.
- minimaxir 10y agoWhen you first go to a Google sign-on, it asks for your email. Once you input your email, it then shows you the profile picture corresponding to the account, and asks you to input the password. If the account has no profile picture, the icon is blue instead of gray. (Tested in Incognito mode)
- emodendroket 10y agoThat's not correct. If you sign on from an unrecognized computer, it doesn't show your photo. Using incognito mode doesn't make you "unrecognized;" you need to have a different IP.
- lucb1e 10y ago> a computer Google doesn't recognize If Google can recognize your computer without being logged in, it's time to up your privacy settings.
- emodendroket 10y agoUnless you connect from a different IP every time, Google can recognize your computer.
- lucb1e 10y agoWell there's NAT and dynamic addresses.
- emodendroket 10y agoYes, and I suppose you change your IP so frequently that you never visit the same page from the same IP twice.
- NeutronBoy 10y agoIt's partially because you can sign in with custom domains. By putting your email address in first, Google can figure out what signin mechanism to use prior to you inputting your password (or not, if you don't need one). For example, we use Google Apps at work with our custom domain, with an internal SSO server providing authentication services. You enter your email address, the Google page directs you to the internal SSO server, you get a token, take that back to Google, and you get logged in - no password required.