4 ms·
That's a ridiculous position. My ownership of my home provides a lot of active investment activity that wouldn't happen otherwise: Examples: - the local nurs
by Spooky23 10y ago
That's a ridiculous position.
My ownership of my home provides a lot of active investment activity that wouldn't happen otherwise:
Examples:
- the local nursery benefits from the plants and growing materials that we buy
- investments in home improvements generate contractor man-hours and local material purchases
- as an active participant in stakeholder in the community, I contribute to the governance of the community
- single family homes are valued at a premium to multi family, so I contribute more to local school and municipal services.
- codemac 10y agoOnly the home improvements is unique to home ownership, the rest happen whether or not you're renting or owning.
- mason240 10y agoWhen I was renting, I had a 30-day investment in the neighborhood/city. Now that I own my house, I have a 150k investment in the neighborhood/city.
- hx87 10y agoEven improvements aren't unique; the last time I moved into an apartment I replaced the wall-to-wall carpet with pine boards, replaced the 50+ year old electric receptacles with GFCI outlets and stripped off the old paint and put on a new coat of primer and paint.
- sosuke 10y agoWoah your renting experience sounds like home ownership to me. I've never heard of that in the US that is a lot to put into a place! The max lease allowed by my last complex was 13 months.
- kgermino 10y agoHow does anything on your list stem from owning vs renting? Presumably if you were renting - you would still garden and you or your landlord would still maintain the lawn - your landlord would still maintain the house - you would still be living in the community and therefore motivated to participate in it's government - I don't understand this one at all. Why would a second family suddenly move in if the house was rented?
- kodablah 10y agoYour points miss both the financial incentive to make things better for your own asset and long term incentive since oftentimes renting makes one more nomadic. Point by point: - You might not garden w/ no equitable return on house value (or at least not build a large gardening setup), and landlords feel the same way in reverse (no benefit to them to do anything beyond the minimum once it's inhabited) - Maintain != improve...BIG difference - Except you may be more nomadic. Also you missed the GP's use of the word "stakeholder" of which you are considerably less of if you don't own land in the community - I too don't understand this point...but I think the GP means "multi-family" as in apartments, thereby single-family (i.e. standalone house) is higher "premium" therefore you contribute more. Again, not sure here.
- Retric 10y agoIncreasing home ownership lowers economic growth. People tend to move jobs less often and have longer commutes both of which reduces economic efficiency. People also tend to rent places which more closely match their needs further reducing waste. AKA, renting and there is no need for a kids room until you have kids, but when buying you may need to plan for your needs in 5+ years out. Further, people really do rent the same place for 30+ years when their job and family situation is stable, which incentives similar levels of improvement.
- Spooky23 10y agoSource? Housing has driven US GDP growth since WW2 or earlier, so that's a pretty big leap.
- Retric 10y agoHousing != home ownership. Anyway, I have read this a few places, but here is the first link I found. "Regions with higher home ownership created fewer new businesses, had longer commute times, and lower rates of labor mobility." http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/05/08/the-deep-downside-of-home-ownership.aspx http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/05/08/the-deep-do... Further, GDP is a very short term view of the economy. Daycare is a classic example where going from an informal to formal system nominally increases GDP much more than the net increase in value.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWhat's this have to do with owning? It's common to rent single family homes too. It's especially common in my part of the country because of the population here.
- zip1234 10y agoAlso, in 99% of rentals I've seen, the landlords put in the bare minimum to keep tenants there and paying high rents. Homeowners tend to spend money on their houses to make them nicer.
- paganel 10y agoI'm now writing this from a rental apartment and it looks quite nice, it's certainly as nice as I would have arranged it had it been my own. Granted, you can't go wrong with Ikea, some nice German white appliances and generally keeping it as simple and functional as possible. I'm also living in Europe.
- ygra 10y agoOne thing you usually can't do, though, is rearrange walls. While very much a proponent of renting vs. buying (I'm in Germany), sometimes the layout of flats is atrocious. We have a tiny kitchen with barely enough space for a single person to work in, a gigantic living room with mostly windows and no walls to put shelves against, and despite it being 90 m² it's only three rooms which will likely prove problematic once we have kids above a certain age. Sometimes I wonder how such layouts are created. Presumably by people who don't have to live there. Or live a very different life (eating out vs. cooking, maybe). That's one thing you can do better when building a house, although when buying one you could probably change it at great expenses as well.