2 ms·
> For all the complaints I see about the relative toxicity of HN and its comments, it seems vastly less insane than Reddit. Well, of course. In the subs I subs
by Semaphor 10y ago
> For all the complaints I see about the relative toxicity of HN and its comments, it seems vastly less insane than Reddit.
Well, of course. In the subs I subscribe to every once in a while an HN discussion gets linked because of the quality of the comments.
The defaults on Reddit have a ton of SRS/SJWs vs. MensRights/Red Pillers. Also memes and general herd behavior.
But there are also subs for pretty much every TV show and game out there. Frameworks and programming languages have subs devoted to them. In general many, many interests have their own subreddits.
That's where you can often have intelligent discussions with mostly sensible people.
And of course, let's not forget heavily moderated places like the shining star /r/AskHistorians
What I mean to say is, you can't compare Reddit to HN, comparing HN to a specific subreddit would be more appropriate.
- detaro 10y agoEven in smaller subs, there often is a quite bad signal-noise ratio, with common posts repeated all the times, meme/joke comments, ... HN isn't perfect on the first point (especially political discussions get repeated over and over as well), but still better. That is something traditional forums often do a lot better, since a hot topic stays active for a long time instead of falling off and being replaced with a new one that discusses all the same points over again. Especially for common questions or product discussions, traditional boards tend to point people to search and existing topics instead of repeating them.