3 ms·
I agree. Humanity has been distinguishing between "murder" and "killing" for millennia. It is sophistry to obtain a pre-concluded end result to pretend otherwis
by jerf 10y ago
I agree. Humanity has been distinguishing between "murder" and "killing" for millennia. It is sophistry to obtain a pre-concluded end result to pretend otherwise.
I say this not because I'm pro-death-penalty; I say it because it's a terrible anti-death-penalty argument. There's much better arguments than such word play so simple a child can see through it.
(Cards on the table: My personal position is that, actually, I'm OK with the death penalty in situations where a society can not afford to keep the murderer alive, or the society does not have a reasonably expectation of being able to keep the murderer from murdering again. But I do not merely mean "the society would be inconvenienced", I mean, the normal state through history is that the society literally can not afford to feed a murderer or have a realistic expectation of holding them; a tribe 5,000 years ago of 100 people literally can not afford it. However, in the 21st century, every major civilized society in which we might even be having this debate is very far away from that problem, having both abundant resources to feed and house them, and very realistic expectations that they can indeed keep them away from innocents. Prison breaks today are big news, and still don't happen all that often.)
- vidarh 10y agoIt is intended to make you think about why an execution is different. For starters, if we accept state sanctioned killings, then any argument that a life is inviolable goes out the window. With capital punishment, the state is saying that taking lives can be acceptable. > Humanity has been distinguishing between "murder" and "killing" for millennia Yes, and a major distinguishing factor has tended to be premeditation and intent. An execution is of a nature that would fit in the worst category of murder if it wasn't for the fact that it was ordered by the state. An execution has all the hallmarks of something that would tick every possible mark of a particularly heinous murder otherwise. Yet even when we know that innocent people get executed too, it is tolerated when carried out by a state.
- jerf 10y ago"then any argument that a life is inviolable goes out the window." Very few people argue that. Even fewer people who are pro-capital-punishment would argue that, for obvious reasons. An argument that only convinces those who already agree isn't even an argument. "An execution has all the hallmarks of something that would tick every possible mark of a particularly heinous murder otherwise." No, it doesn't. You're just doubling down on the sophism. Again, let me emphasize that if anything, I'm angry that this is a bad argument against capital punishment, not as a defense of capital punishment. Everyone from philosophers to the man on the street have understood the differences between cold-blooded murder, murder in the heat of passion, execution, warfare, and self-defense for millennia. Nobody who is capable of making those distinctions is going to be convinced to see all killing as equal, when even the man on the street considers it a rather unsophisticated position. See also why the animal rights argument that "if it's wrong to murder people for premeditated reasons it should be wrong to kill animals to eat them" hasn't gotten any significant traction. Appealing to people to deliberately dumb down their morality for that to work isn't a good argument, especially when, again, it's not even that sophisticated a difference we're talking about here. We're not into weird Latin terms, reading 19th century existential philosophy, or even arguing what "begging the question" technically means, we're talking stuff that your average 12 year old could explain.
- HolyHaddock 10y agoSo what is the distinction? I mean that as a genuine question - Vidarh's position seems to be that the death penalty is intentionally taking a life, and shouldn't have a different moral standing to murder. The response seems to be that that's a bad argument, they don't really believe that there's no distinction, and it would be stupid to believe that. If I don't see a distinction of moral significance between the death penalty and, say, the CEO of a company deciding to painlessly execute one of their reports that they discover has gotten away with serious embezzling for multiple years, scorn doesn't help me understand the distinction someone else does see.