2 ms·
Yes, and? Should we turn credit into a market for lemons? Just ratchet everyone's access to credit down to what's now granted to those with bad credit? Go back
by closeparen 10y ago
Yes, and?
Should we turn credit into a market for lemons? Just ratchet everyone's access to credit down to what's now granted to those with bad credit? Go back to the days of "how respectable do you look walking into the bank?"
Should the IRS spend its finite resources looking for fraud where it's less likely to be?
Should middle-aged people with clean records in Accords pay the same premiums as people 19-year-olds with DUI convictions in WRXes?
Should the state assign friends/spouses by RNG and enforce that you spend equal time with each?
People are different. They have different personalities, different behaviors, different risk profiles. It makes no sense to ignore these things. In the organization examples you've given, at least, it's much better to use data-driven, evidence-based models kicking out scores than to rely on the prejudices and informal gossip networks of gatekeepers - like we did before we were sophisticated enough for records.
Even where scores aren't appropriate, you're going to allocate your resources - like attention - to people you enjoy over people you don't.
China's system is problematic because it's assessing something we think should not be assessed or considered anywhere - loyalty to the Party. But they were likely already doing that anyway, with informal gossip networks among Party officials. Executed correctly, the "social credit score" system should serve that end more accurately, with less corruption and ultimately more egalitarianism. We just don't think the end should be served.