3 ms·
One serious danger I haven't heard anyone mention mention in regards to the Mars colonization project (though it was considered to some extent in Carl Sagan's "
by pmoriarty 10y ago
One serious danger I haven't heard anyone mention mention in regards to the Mars colonization project (though it was considered to some extent in Carl Sagan's "Contact" and probably some other science fiction) is the possibility of terrorism against either the fragile spacecraft or colony.
Musk has said there will be no screening of the Mars colonists, and that anyone could go. That means someone who's mentally unstable and/or wants to make a name for himself (ala Herostratus[1] or any number of modern publicity-seeking terrorists and murderers) could go and attempt to harm the spacecraft or colony, both of which would be incredibly vulnerable to such intentional attempts at destruction and are guaranteed to get massive publicity were they to be destroyed or even merely attacked.
This could become even more likely if living on Mars long-term actually becomes viable, and people wind up spending decades on there. Some people will likely go stir-crazy and attempt to harm themselves and/or others.
People who are allowed to go live in Antarctica or out in to space are currently screened very carefully to be compatible with each other and able to psychologically withstand the rigors of life there, and the relative isolation. But there will be no such screening for the Mars colonists, according to Musk, and the isolation and danger on Mars will be even worse than it is in Antarctica.
The isolation and danger will be hugely stressful and difficult to deal with over the decades people will live on Mars. I've read that even in Antarctica, people are rotated out within a year or so because of the psychological difficulties of living there, and no one's been in space for much more than a year.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herostratus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herostratus
- judahmeek 10y agoAny claim that there will be no screening of colonists is highly dubious at best. All you need to make some form of screening mandatory is to have more applicants than open positions. Even if all you do is accept applicants as they apply, that immediately biases the selection process to better informed and connected individuals.
- pmoriarty 10y agoIt's one thing to have a fist-come-first-served system, where the more informed, connected, wealthy, or eager individuals get to go first. It's quite another to psychological screening, background checks, and perhaps even rigorous training to make sure they can withstand the great psychological pressure that will be present on the trip and on Mars. There are no plans to use these latter measures, as far as I know. Even if there was such screening or training, that alone won't be enough if despite it someone onboard the spacecraft or in the colony decides to act out anyway. I really hope someone at SpaceX is seriuously thinking about these issues and coming up with practical solutions, as that's the only hope of preventing some unhinged or politically motivated individuals from turning a promising colonization effort in to a tragedy.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat's a great comment. This is why I thought the one-way ticket trips to Mars were the most honest. I thought most or all of them were covertly or accidentally doing the same thing just with longer, life expectancy.
- MrZongle2 10y ago"Musk has said there will be no screening of the Mars colonists, and that anyone could go." I suspect that will go out the door as soon as a major funding partner demands otherwise, to mitigate potential risk to their investment. Eventually, sure, the screening will likely become less and less invasive; but at that point we'll have hundreds of people on Mars and the launch/voyage will be routine. I wouldn't take Musk's word as gospel here.