3 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this as someone who knows none of the players involved. On one hand, it does feel the like the author has felt genuine offense to pu
by danso 10y ago
I have mixed feelings about this as someone who knows none of the players involved. On one hand, it does feel the like the author has felt genuine offense to publish such a lengthy attack. On the other hand, other than the main public evidence she offers, this blog post by Cantrill [0], which she describes as a "layer cake of vituperation and braggadocio, frosted with eloquence" -- I guess you just have had to have personal experience with Cantrill to get that vibe, because it seemed like a straightforward blog post to me.
Maybe the author doesn't want to drag Cantrill's name through the mud by posting private correspondence ("I watched him shame and insult hundreds of people, in public and in private, over email and in person, in papers and talks")...but for the author to end the essay as combatively as she does ("Come at me, Bryan"), I would've guessed that there would be damning material in Cantrill's other public correspondence, such as tweets.
It seems like Cantrill's personality, according to the author, is so irredeemable that the rest of the organizers and board for "Systems We Love" can't mitigate the effect. Is SWL organized in such a way that this is the case?
[0] https://www.joyent.com/blog/systems-we-love https://www.joyent.com/blog/systems-we-love
edit: OK, this from 20 years ago rings a bell (the HN discussion at least): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9039884 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9039884
edit 2: This definitely rings a bell, though in this case, it's Cantrill being a jerk in arguing for non-gendered pronouns, something that I'm sure he got some criticism for: https://www.joyent.com/blog/the-power-of-a-pronoun https://www.joyent.com/blog/the-power-of-a-pronoun
- lets-tryagain 10y agoThe world is full of jerks. What most adults do is ignore them. Valerie's post is unacceptable cyber-bullying in every sense. Are you are reasonable person? Assume so. Do you go around writing blog posts tearing down people who have wronged you in the past? I presume not. Valerie should be ashamed of her post...and what is more shameful is the brigading in her comments section.
- rbanffy 10y agoI thought long and hard before posting this here for debate. Two people I deeply respect echoed the opinions in the post. In the end, I decided so because I am guilty of such behavior and I police myself to avoid it in settings where I feel a more careful approach is required.