9 ms·
Elon Musk SpaceX AMA
- kilroy123 10y agoOdd. So far he hasn't answered a thing. https://www.reddit.com/user/ElonMuskOfficial https://www.reddit.com/user/ElonMuskOfficial
- drakonka 10y agoIt has been 15 minutes since the AMA officially started (he tweeted that it was starting at 3pm), so it's not that odd.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- javiramos 10y agoElon has a fantastic image. He is just an amazing PR machine.
- matt4077 10y agoHe has also, you know, achieved stuff. Actual rockets, actually going up. There's a tendency of people to devalue the successes of others by attributing it to marketing. But for the life of me I can't find a way that would work to sell rockets to governments. Musk has also started at least three somewhat successful businesses, and at this point I don't think either marketing or luck are sufficient explanations. It reminds me of someone else. I hope Musk gets his pancreas checked often enough.
- pugworthy 10y agoYou can keep yourself sane and find his replies by looking at his profile page at https://www.reddit.com/user/ElonMuskOfficial https://www.reddit.com/user/ElonMuskOfficial
- samuelb 10y agoYou can sort the comments by Question & Answer to have not only the answer https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_musk_ask_me_anything_about_becoming_a/?sort=qa https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu...
- pugworthy 10y agoAh nice, didn't know that!
- Davesjoshin 10y agoOr you can use the browser find feature and use 'ElonMuskOfficial' to find the responses.
- 0majors 10y agoThe leaders of the most powerful nations on Earth are barely starting to talk about some small human missions to Mars and then there is Elon, casually discussing glass domes and tunneling drones creating underground networks on Mars. Truly incredible.
- guelo 10y agoAre you suggesting that the scientists and engineers at NASA have never drawn up detailed plans for these kind of ideas?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marcofloriano 10y agoRight!? Like, i have tons of respect for the guy, but the amount of press and attention that they get just by saying "we are going to mars" are crazy! Nothing practical to show, i would be more interested in a mission to build up a base at moon first. But hey! This is show business, what we losers can possible know!?
- ranman 10y ago"Nothing practical to show" ... I think you may be misinformed. There are a great deal of practical advancements (raptor engine, carbon fiber tanks, software and sensor suites that enable autonomous landing). There's tons of room for discussion around the mars architecture but to discount it because there's "nothing practical to show" is incorrect. If you're not an expert in the field it might be worth it to do some research before immediately discounting an idea.
- thelambentonion 10y agoI would say that the leaders of the most powerful nations on Earth are a little more grounded in reality than Musk in this regard. Glass domes and underground Martian tunnels make for some very interesting science fiction, but I'm concerned about the engineering challenges that he seems to be ignoring in favor of his grand statements of intent. To pick a specific example, he seems to have very little concern for radiation shielding both during the trip to Mars or on the Martian surface. Both of these present incredibly harsh radiation environments for humans, and we need to develop solutions before we even consider sending explorers, let alone colonists.
- thelambentonion 10y agoI'd encourage everyone reading the AMA to take a lot of what Musk is saying with a grain of salt. The Interplanetary Transport System (ITS) is a wildly ambitious project that is attempting to accomplish more things in a shorter period of time than the Apollo program (and on a substantially smaller budget to boot). Check out Robert Zubrin's article, which presents a much more salient critique of SpaceX's current plans than I could [0]. [0] http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/colonizing-mars http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/colonizing-mars
- M_Grey 10y agoIt's good to see that the initial nearly religious fervor has worn off, and comments like yours can survive the voting process here. There are a number of issues with the "colony" concept, even beyond that excellent article, but until recently such a point was met with some version of fury. The general theme seems to have been that getting people excited, even with empty promises, was somehow virtuous and might lead to something good (for parties other than Musk's and SpaceX's bottom line).
- pm 10y agoI think people getting excited about space and space travel again is a good thing. It's the first step to getting people involved again, even if only to remember what we're capable of as a species, despite all our flaws and all the other problems we've yet to solve. Whether you agree with Musk's methods or not, I enjoy living in a time where we dream about the possibilities of new worlds, rather than reminiscing about a golden age of space travel long past.
- M_Grey 10y agoI think that's a little sad, because it implicitly gives up on the notion of real progress in favor of PR and imagination. I'm excited about SpaceX, but not because of their "Mars Colony" PR. I don't think the situation is so dire that we need to suspend our skepticism and become mindless cheerleaders in the name of "dreams".
- 4ad 10y agoI am sure Elon Musk won't get the chance to answer my reddit question, since apparently the reddit mob downvoted me to death, so I am asking here, perhaps anyone knows. 1) What RTOS does SpaceX use for the embedded hardware on board? I know they use a lot of Linux, but not for hard real time stuff. What are they running on their microcontrollers? 2) Is it programmed in C, or some other language? 3) Is the embedded equipment on board running on a switched network? If so, does it use TCP/IP or some other protocol?
- turval 10y agoI didn't personally downvote (or see this question), but it probably get downvoted for not being laser-focused on ITS/Mars. Anyway, you might find some of your answers in this AMA that the SpaceX software devs did a while back. https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1853ap/we_are_spacex_software_engineers_we_launch https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1853ap/we_are_spacex_...
- planteen 10y agoAs far as the RTOS, it sounds like they use Linux: > Linux is used for everything at SpaceX. The Falcon, Dragon, and Grasshopper vehicles use it for flight control, the ground stations run Linux, as do the developers' desktops. SpaceX is "Linux, Linux, Linux", he said. http://lwn.net/Articles/540368/ http://lwn.net/Articles/540368/
- 1457389 10y agoI'm sorry but dozens, maybe hundreds of other questions were more deserving - this ama is about sending a rocket to mars not about their IT stack... We are all a bit scarred after the IAC debacle, perhaps that explains the downvotes.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThe IT stack was the cause of over a billion dollars of lost missions from leaving Earth all the way to Mars missions. It also is what will or won't get the rocket to Mars. So, it was worth an answer given that by itself has killed so many missions with the Moon missions themselves taking a huge team & cost to do right despite failures [which showed up].
- 1457389 10y agoI am so glad /r/spacex had the chance to host the AMA. Even this thread shows a pretty depressing lack of understanding (so far) of what Elon has claimed and what SpaceX has actually demonstrated. A bunch of tilting at windmills, virtue signalling and strawman construction efforts while the people who have a clue have a real discussion elsewhere.
- thelambentonion 10y agoI personally don't think that I have a lack of understanding of what Musk has claimed or SpaceX has demonstrated, and I'm incredibly skeptical of their ability to safely deliver on their promises within his proposed timeline. I'd quite like to be proven wrong, spaceflight is an area very near and dear to my heart, but from my point of view Musk's reach appears to vastly exceed his grasp. EDIT: I did enjoy the AMA though, as it provided some interesting insight into their plans for all of this.
- 1457389 10y agoTotally fair to be skeptical; not very impressive though unless you have detailed cause. Not quite as fair, or impressive to make comments like these with no effort or backing: >Glass domes and underground Martian tunnels make for some very interesting science fiction, but I'm concerned about the engineering challenges that he seems to be ignoring in favor of his grand statements of intent. The AMA, and even that specific question was all about the engineering challenges... >but the amount of press and attention that they get just by saying "we are going to mars" are crazy! Nothing practical to show, i would be more interested in a mission to build up a base at moon first. But hey! This is show business, what we losers can possible know!? He literally showed images and video of fuel tank and rocket tech that represent novel advances. He has also spilled gallons of ink justifying why Mars is the place to go next. EDIT: To be clear, I don't think I am quoting lambentonion here, just giving examples of the stuff that made me comment initially
- thelambentonion 10y ago> The AMA, and even that specific question was all about the engineering challenges... Re: that specific question, I may just have a different view of what constitutes a question on engineering challenges. That AMA is of exceptional caliber, however, and there are definitely some gems to be found (see [0] and [1], in particular). The fuel tank and rocket tech represent novel advances in rocket tech that are as-yet untested, afaik. A scaled-down test stand prototype and a prototype of a composite tank are certainly worthy of praise, but they still require an enormous amount of work to turn into a functioning product. I'd also like to qualify some of my statements here: I don't think _any_ of these challenges are insurmountable. However I think that it would be impossible for all of them to be addressed on the time scale that Musk proposes, for the amount of money he has stated, with the manpower that SpaceX possesses. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_musk_ask_me_anything_about_becoming_a/d94tbej/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu... [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_musk_ask_me_anything_about_becoming_a/d94u6zk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu...
- marktangotango 10y agoI missed the AMA but I'll ask this here since people seem to be in the know. In the beginning, Spacex and the original merlin seemed to be all low tech, get it done (ie the merlin was ablative cooled chamber and nozzle). Now the ITS engine is super advanced. I always wondered, why the turn around, and has Musk ever written or said anything about Truax's Sea Dragon[1] concept? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Dragon_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_Dragon_(rocket)
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoCurious, is reddit penalized by the hackernews algorithm (I don't see reddit links here often); this post is quite a bit lower on the main-page than older posts with fewer votes?
- pmoriarty 10y agoOne serious danger I haven't heard anyone mention mention in regards to the Mars colonization project (though it was considered to some extent in Carl Sagan's "Contact" and probably some other science fiction) is the possibility of terrorism against either the fragile spacecraft or colony. Musk has said there will be no screening of the Mars colonists, and that anyone could go. That means someone who's mentally unstable and/or wants to make a name for himself (ala Herostratus[1] or any number of modern publicity-seeking terrorists and murderers) could go and attempt to harm the spacecraft or colony, both of which would be incredibly vulnerable to such intentional attempts at destruction and are guaranteed to get massive publicity were they to be destroyed or even merely attacked. This could become even more likely if living on Mars long-term actually becomes viable, and people wind up spending decades on there. Some people will likely go stir-crazy and attempt to harm themselves and/or others. People who are allowed to go live in Antarctica or out in to space are currently screened very carefully to be compatible with each other and able to psychologically withstand the rigors of life there, and the relative isolation. But there will be no such screening for the Mars colonists, according to Musk, and the isolation and danger on Mars will be even worse than it is in Antarctica. The isolation and danger will be hugely stressful and difficult to deal with over the decades people will live on Mars. I've read that even in Antarctica, people are rotated out within a year or so because of the psychological difficulties of living there, and no one's been in space for much more than a year. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herostratus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herostratus
- judahmeek 10y agoAny claim that there will be no screening of colonists is highly dubious at best. All you need to make some form of screening mandatory is to have more applicants than open positions. Even if all you do is accept applicants as they apply, that immediately biases the selection process to better informed and connected individuals.
- pmoriarty 10y agoIt's one thing to have a fist-come-first-served system, where the more informed, connected, wealthy, or eager individuals get to go first. It's quite another to psychological screening, background checks, and perhaps even rigorous training to make sure they can withstand the great psychological pressure that will be present on the trip and on Mars. There are no plans to use these latter measures, as far as I know. Even if there was such screening or training, that alone won't be enough if despite it someone onboard the spacecraft or in the colony decides to act out anyway. I really hope someone at SpaceX is seriuously thinking about these issues and coming up with practical solutions, as that's the only hope of preventing some unhinged or politically motivated individuals from turning a promising colonization effort in to a tragedy.
- paulsutter 10y agoAre Elon's mining/tunneling droids discussed anywhere? He's said in the past the Earth cities need to "go 3D", putting cars in tunnels underground. Something needs to be done to cut the cost of tunneling, so I'm interested to learn more. > Initially, glass panes with carbon fiber frames to build geodesic domes on the surface, plus a lot of miner/tunneling droids. With the latter, you can build out a huge amount of pressurized space for industrial operations and leave the glass domes for green living space From: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_musk_ask_me_anything_about_becoming_a/d94t2bv/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/590wi9/i_am_elon_mu...
- andygates 10y agoFor me, mining robots were the biggest handwave of the session. They'd need to operate on Mars, at least semi-autonomously, and the current state of the art needs a fair bit of nursemaiding (and a local machine shop) to keep running. Still, nothing spurs development like the prospect of a juicy colony contract!
- mspradley 10y agoI can't believe no one asked about the status of the Atmos 6 investigation.
- Tempest1981 10y agoRight now, it still feels like the "brainstorming" phase of the project. I guess it's OK to criticize various ideas, but it would be more interesting if alternatives were offered, then have a discussion of pros and cons. That is, assuming the goal is to make it happen, vs. prove it's infeasible. Since it's such a blue-sky project, I'm hoping more to enjoy the design process -- the discussion of science and ideas. I wonder if that process will bring engineers together... or drive them apart?
- nickik 10y agoThey have showed actual prototypes of multiple different aspects. Usually you start rocket design with a engine, and build the rocket on top. The engine in testing already and they seem to have nailed down the basic specs and all the important parts. That's more then brainstorming, thats actually prototype testing of specific sub-components.
- Animats 10y agoThere's a lot of hand-waving about how a base on Mars would operate. Remember the Biosphere II debacle, an attempt to build a closed ecosystem in a big dome. That was intended partly as a test for a Mars colony. They had a terrible time trying to stabilize their little ecosystem. They had far more resources at start than a Mars mission could carry, and were only trying to support eight people.
- Loic 10y agoThe one difference is that for Biosphere II they tried to be cut out of the Earth atmosphere. They tried to be totally autonomous. For Mars, they will mine the local resources so they will not be "sustainable" at first.
- Animats 10y agoMining will be tough. Water, if it can be found, will be in the form of brine ice mixed with perchlorate. It's going to take a lot of energy and equipment to get usable water out of that. Reverse osmosis and ion-exchange resins will work, but they have consumables which must be brought from Earth. The atmosphere of Mars, such as it is, is mostly CO2. It takes a lot of effort to get oxygen out of that. Sunlight intensity on Mars is about a quarter of what it is on Earth, so solar panels and plants will have about a quarter of the effectiveness. There are no easily exploitable resources on Mars. It's going to be more like an Arctic base - you have to bring almost everything.
- andygates 10y agoThey had a terrible setup and bonkers people, too - lessons very much learned.