3 ms·
> Go look at supreme court cases The supreme courts are democratically determined and justified. For ISDS courts, half of the judges are appointed by the comp
by kuschku 10y ago
> Go look at supreme court cases
The supreme courts are democratically determined and justified.
For ISDS courts, half of the judges are appointed by the company that is suing.
For ICS courts, all the judges are appointed by the nations taking part.
That’s why ICS is acceptable, but ISDS is not.
> Democratically elected governments can act in ways just as abhorrent as any other entity
Correct, but democratically elected governments are put under checks and balances to prevent them from doing so, foreign companies are not.
- cperciva 10y agoFor ISDS courts, half of the judges are appointed by the company that is suing. The ISDS provision in NAFTA uses a panel of three arbitrators; one appointed by each of the nations involved, and one which is appointed either by consensus or from the third NAFTA nation if consensus cannot be reached. Investors don't get to appoint any arbitrators.
- kuschku 10y agoThat's then closer to CETAs solution, too. Classical ISDS trials have 1 determined by the suing company, 1 by the nation sued, and one both have to agree on.