3 ms·
Certainly the existing auto makers are developing new cars. But one of the major differentiators of the Tesla is the user interface - the navigation screen, the
by stickfigure 10y ago
Certainly the existing auto makers are developing new cars. But one of the major differentiators of the Tesla is the user interface - the navigation screen, the experience around calculating routes including charge stations, etc. On one hand it seems like developing good UX should be easier than building cars - it's mostly just software right? - but based on everyday experience with electronic goods it seems to be the hardest thing for companies that do not have a long pedigree of UI development. We all have iphones and androids is because of UX, not because of hardware.
For most of the history of the automobile, the UX was standard and very simple. Now there's a major expectation-resetting going on. The UX of a Tesla is not something that just can be bought from a third-party supplier and bolted on like a fuel injector or axle or radio. At best, the software departments of big automakers are accustomed to building embedded systems. Making the transition to will not be easy.
- johansch 10y agoVolvo seems to have caught up, more or less: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HM1-Yh5fwB8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HM1-Yh5fwB8 Building a good embedded touchscreen UI is not so much rocket science as it was just 5-7 years ago. There are a lot more people with the knowledge nowadays - because of the mobile app revolution.
- WalterBright 10y ago> We all have iphones and androids is because of UX, not because of hardware. The iphone appeared as soon as the hardware shrunk enough to be able to support it. Earlier tablets failed mainly because the hardware just wasn't capable enough.
- mmahemoff 10y agoI'll add that they are building much more than car UI. They are building platforms. The car itself is a complicated platform with many components. How they communicate will affect how easy it is for the developers to build reliable, secure, components. (e.g. braking systems preferably shouldn't be open to everyone https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/ https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...). Then you have the cloud aspect, which allows users to access car data and functionality from apps, allows the car manufacturer to do analytics, etc. Now you have a car company that's responsible for running safety-critical servers in the cloud. Again, this leads to huge variation in reliability, developer experience, and security (e.g. your car's climate control is best left to yourself and not everyone else https://www.troyhunt.com/controlling-vehicle-features-of-nissan/ https://www.troyhunt.com/controlling-vehicle-features-of-nis...). TLDR Software is eating cars.
- ams6110 10y agoI for one don't want a UX in my car. I have a phone, and I use that for navigation. I don't need that duplicated in my car. I want tactile controls (knobs and levers and pushbuttons) I can use by feel without taking my eyes off the road. And, of course the UX of a Tesla is something that just can be bought from a third-party supplier and bolted on like a fuel injector or axle or radio. It's just a matter of hiring some smart developers. Many readers here could probably do it in a weekend ;-).
- saiya-jin 10y agoexactly this. i have older car without any fancy big screen. what for? all the necessary info is displayed anyway, for navigation i use offline maps which are superior to anything embedded i've seen (and free to update via wifi - this is due to my particular data limits in europe). to adjust heating/volume/switch song/etc i don't need to lose focus on road, i just know which knob to turn or which button to press. I know by experience that when i look at central panel, nuke can blow in front of my car and my eyes would barely register it since it's not in my direct focus - very, very dangerous. it feels much more premium to have dedicated physical controls for all required tasks. fuck tablets in cars, it's horrible idea that should be put only into cheapest cars, or straight forbidden.
- blahi 10y agoThis is exactly the argument AGAINST Tesla. I saw the luxury tesla model. It is so crude compared to the corresponding Benz. Daimler, BMW, Audi and other manufacturers have been making cars for a hundred years. They know how to do it. I'm afraid Tesla does not still.