3 ms·
> when people make comments that aren’t just reasonable sounding but are actually correct, those comments tend to get upvoted For a while, I found that on page
by cronjobber 10y ago
> when people make comments that aren’t just reasonable sounding but are actually correct, those comments tend to get upvoted
For a while, I found that on pages with lots of comments the most interesting ones were to be found at the top––and, buried between actual dross, at the bottom.
That might have changed, I don't see it that much anymore. But that could be a side effect of something even less desirable. I think some people may have started flagging whole articles when the discussion has "too many" comments they dislike. I can't prove this, of course.
- zzzcpan 10y agoI have the opposite experience. I never found the most interesting comments at the top on popular posts. They usually just reflect a public opinion or come from "famous" HNers. I even reconsider my opinions, when my comments are upvoted too much. Because it means that public shares the same opinion and it is likely to be influenced by PR/marketing/politics.