8 ms·
".. the measure of a healthy organization is probably the degree to which negative thoughts are allowed. In places where great work is being done, the attitud
by nabla9 10y ago
".. the measure of a healthy organization is probably the degree to which
negative thoughts are allowed. In places where great work is being
done, the attitude always seems to be critical and sarcastic, not
"positive" and "supportive". The people I know who do great work
think that they suck, but that everyone else sucks even more."
-- Paul Graham
- zazen 10y agoThis may very well be true in organizations where the sarcasm exists in an established context of mutual respect (or at least, the knowledge that you'll have to keep working with the other person). But it's very different when total strangers communicate by text over the internet: sarcastic comments breed aggressive replies, and threads degenerate into arguments very rapidly. I think good conversations online need more restraint and empathic effort than good conversations IRL.
- nabla9 10y agoI have noticed in HN that well justified critical comments without hostile tone are faced with aggressive tone if the subject is some new hot technology. The underdone seems to be "say positive things", not say intelligent or insightful things.
- eximius 10y agoI've noticed that too. However, since any criticisms I might have usually do not entirely detract from the... whatever, you can just preface it with something positive. "This is great! But, I wonder about X..." You get your criticism, they get their happy feelings.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI followed by doing it even more on more topics containing bullshit. I had a steady following of people that respected that I continued counterpoints to fads while linking to evidence justifying it. I have opponents, too, that prefer I cancel my Internet service or end my unrelenting, evidence-driven "attacks" on certain things. Anyway, the trend exists but can just be ignored. There is a huge crowd of people here that appreciate thoughtful, civil counterpoints. I'll add that quite a few are also professionals in industry worth having in one's network for people that use HN that way.
- wpietri 10y agoThe first bit is true, but the second is pretty much the opposite of what Google found: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/magazine/what-google-learned-from-its-quest-to-build-the-perfect-team.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/magazine/what-google-learn... In particular, Google found that psychological safety is a key component of successful teams. Indeed, I think in an environment where rudeness is the norm, it's much harder to get people to share negative thoughts. Sure, you'll have a few alpha-dicks who will say whatever shitty thing that comes to mind. But most other people will just keep their lips buttoned because they don't want to deal with critical, sarcastic comments. If you want real, long-term organizational improvement, you have to create an environment were people are willing to share problems and concerns without fear that they'll get insulted or blamed. One great example is Toyota's culture of continuous improvement, which helped them go from post-WWII decimation of Japan to the world's dominant carmaker. They're explicit that "respect for people" is foundational. A good book here is Rother's "Toyota Kata", which goes into Toyota's culture and people-management practices. Another is airplane safety. For its ubiquity and technological complexity, flight is amazingly safe. But this requires a culture of deep, thoughtful honesty. Sidney Dekker's "Field Guide to Human Error" explains how much this depends on creating blame-free contexts, how much it requires a deep respect for people. Without that, people will a) blame others, and b) cover their own asses in an effort to avoid getting blame. That muddies the waters enough that you can never find and fix the systemic problems that caused bad outcomes. TL;DR: If you really want people to share negative thoughts, you need positive, supportive environments.
- hiou 10y agoNope. Seen both many times. The positive enforcement causes no one to share any negative thoughts after a while and the company smiles it's way out of business. Unfortunately people who will not speak up out of fear are toxic to company culture. The creative process is immediately destroyed when people need to second guess everything they say or do since it is impossible to know if you are about to say the wrong thing. If someone can not tolerate cynical and sarcastic comments they need to be removed quickly. This is very different from mean spirited put downs and intentionally hurtful comments. Stuff like "idk that button looks like it was mad in 2002" or "I swear we have the shittiest parser ever right here". Is good and fine. "You talk to much", "why did you write it like that? It doesn't make any sense" Are bad. Notice how the first like says "we" or talks about a specific feature and the others talk about specific people.
- edmccard 10y ago>In places where great work is being done, the attitude always seems to be critical and sarcastic It can be tricky, though, to be critical and sarcastic without using a jeering tone.[1] [1]https://twitter.com/paulg/status/789066303566929920 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/789066303566929920
- ghaff 10y agoCritical and sarcastic seem to be two rather different things to me. Constructive criticism is certainly important in all sorts of contexts. You don't want to be all "Oh that's perfect" when in fact it's fundamentally flawed in some way. Sarcastic is more a matter of style than substance. "That's the stupidest idea I've ever heard." Which doesn't seem necessary or necessarily positive.
- mratzloff 10y agoThat's not sarcasm.
- ghaff 10y agoSarcasm does not need to be ironic. From Wikipedia: Sarcasm is "a sharp, bitter, or cutting expression or remark; a bitter gibe or taunt. Sarcasm may employ ambivalence, although sarcasm is not necessarily ironic. In any case, saying instead: "Oh yeah, that's a fucking brilliant idea" doesn't seem clearly better in my book.
- acqq 10y agoAnd this is where the "Gospel of Paul" fails, as some commenters here recognized: while being able to nurture healthy criticism is fundamental for quality, sarcasm shouldn't be recognized as necessary, even if it makes some positive effect in some specific situations.