4 ms·
I follow many people on twitter who dislike HN. Reason for this is opinions here are alsmost entirely from white males with money.
by k__ 10y ago
I follow many people on twitter who dislike HN. Reason for this is opinions here are alsmost entirely from white males with money.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf this were true, it would merit study. How can a forum that is open to all and used in mostly anonymous fashion, so effectively police the race of users? And how could other less open less anonymous activities hope to succeed in diversity?
- maxerickson 10y agoIt probably works like strong acid, destroying anything unfortunate enough to not be strong acid on contact.
- coldtea 10y ago>How can a forum that is open to all and used in mostly anonymous fashion, so effectively police the race of users? By being targeted at programmers and startup founders, that is, two predominantly white (ok, and asian) fields? It's not that HN does anything special, it's the actual world that does. Most programmers are middle class (so could afford university in the first place), most founders are upper middle class, and most of both groups are white. There are of course exceptions, but not enough to skew the majority. The most open and diverse "forum" in the world is YouTube -- you can find everybody there under a cat video or some such (which is also why it has the nastier comments, but that's life outside an echo bubble).
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWith regards to the gender aspect, see any of the threads related to 'women in computing' and the horrible posts therein.
- tnones 10y agoOnly if you assume women cannot be successful in technology without needing a special interest group mooching off the entire enterprise. It's a vicious cycle based on a kafkatrap. If you don't agree that women are discriminated against in tech, you're discriminating against women. Culture committees, diversity consultants and women-only groups are set up to "address" this problem, yet all they do is create more division and alienation, holding up the most stereotypical fragile princess as representative for every woman on the planet. They keep throwing all sorts of accusations and aspersions on every single guy in the field, shriek and pearl clutch when they receive blowback, and have the gall to call this empathy, in a field where the average worker is an undersocialized and overworked code janitor. Whose preferred communication styles, hobbies and accomplishments are fair game to ignore or bulldoze over. Pointing this out gets you labeled as "horrible". Fine, then. Yet another word to add to the pile that has lost all meaning. Misogyny used to mean "hatred of women", now it just means "something a woman hates". Which appears to include the average mid-rung nerd.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoA perfect example of my point.
- c_c_c 10y agoThis is certainly true. The "race of users" isn't being "police[d]". It is just a reflection of the subject matter of HN and a reflection of the tech field in general.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoBecause that's the demographic that dominates tech. If you go to any other tech forum that's not a SIG for some other demographic, you'll find the same thing.
- imjustsaying 10y agoI don't understand what's dislikeable about opinions from people who are white with money.
- c_c_c 10y agoNothing, but it certainly limits perspectives.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoIf that is an issue you find, why not comment and offer views from other walks of life? I certainly do at times. I'm legally white - but depending on the amount of sun I have, am not always viewed as such in the common world. I'm female, not exactly rich, and have blue hair. Naturally, my viewpoints can be different. There are others like me - folks from other countries, not rich, not male. At the same time, knowing that the crowd has that bias should help you vet out some of the comments.
- fernandotakai 10y agosame with me, legally white latino from a 3rd world country that works remotely. i would say i'm different from the usual hn user and i'm happy to share my opinions (sometimes)