5 ms·
Yesterday I saw this video about the G5 Mac, which gives a good baseline comparison https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SqYMU81l8Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=
by raverbashing 10y ago
Yesterday I saw this video about the G5 Mac, which gives a good baseline comparison https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SqYMU81l8Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SqYMU81l8Y
Now we supposedly have an ARM processor "good enough" to compete with x86 (while consuming several times less power)
The G5 was certainly fast (I'd guess things like video playing wasn't that good because of unoptimized software) but it consumed a lot of power
- rcarmo 10y agoI owned an iMac G5, and I agree with the relative comparison. The G5 was fast, but the PPC arch was not that efficient, and moving to Intel at the time gave Apple more headroom while lowering their power consumption and thermal profile.
- kogepathic 10y agoI don't think there's anything fundamentally wrong with the POWER architecture. Just look at IBM today selling POWER8 and POWER9 systems. For example IBM Watson, which was featured of Jeopardy, was built on a POWER system. If you look at performance per watt, I don't think the G5 is that far behind the NetBurst architecture Intel was pursuing at the time. Pentium 4 Mobile laptops were absolute beasts to handle the power and cooling needs of the chip. Pentium M laptops used a completely different CPU design which evolved from the Pentium 3 and later became the basis of the Core/Core 2 series of chips. The main issue for Apple was that IBM couldn't make a processor that could work in a laptop (both for power and cooling reasons), and Motorola/Freescale were seriously behind schedule in shipping a dual core G4. Freescale eventually shipped their dual core in 2007. [1] So the main reason for Apple's switch was an immediate availability of mobile CPUs (which greatly outperformed the single core G4). The first Apple Intel products actually used the Core Duo, which was actually a laptop part. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PowerPC_e600 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PowerPC_e600
- zokier 10y agoIts a shame that he couldn't get Linux installed on it (I'd guess some HW issue, maybe memory failure). Because I would find it quite surprising that the first gen Intel Mac Mini would really be faster on a level playing field. Just the amount of RAM and beefier GPU should tip the scales for G5.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoWhen my wife worked at Apple Canada we got to borrow a G5 tower from the company demo pool for a bit. Noisiest and hottest computer I've ever worked with. In the summer I could have the AC on full blast and the room I was in with it would be hot. And in the winter it was an effective space heater. And a super noisy fan. PowerPC always sounded good on paper. But it was definitely a dead end for Apple. Some rump stump of the Amiga community seems obsessed with PowerPC still for some reason. It is nice to imagine an alternative timeline in which Apple pivoted directly to ARM instead of to x86 when the switch happened. It was only a couple or three years after the Intel switch that the iPhone came out.
- mattkevan 10y agoI had a dual-core G5 tower for a while - thing sounded like a jet when booting up. That's why the laptops never got further than the G4 - the G5s were so hot and power hungry a laptop probably would have melted on the spot. I wish Apple would bring the aluminium Mac Pro form factor back - it was a beast, but looked great and was as expandable as anything.