3 ms·
Making cars drive themselves addresses only one aspect of personal automobile inefficiency: parking. Road congestion (and with it land use which is excessive, g
by eyelidlessness 10y ago
Making cars drive themselves addresses only one aspect of personal automobile inefficiency: parking. Road congestion (and with it land use which is excessive, growing, intrusive and dangerous when interspersed with human activity) will continue to be a problem. Energy usage will continue to be hilariously inefficient.
The benefit you point out is right: cars are convenient. But their convenience has serious costs.
Given a choice of two hypothetical futures:
1. I can get in a vehicle within minutes from anywhere, provided I live in a dense urban area. A third of said area is consumed by automobile infrastructure. All of that infrastructure is dirty and dangerous. I pay tremendous amounts of money out of pocket to travel anywhere more than a mile, but I get to spend that time alone.
2. I can get on a mass transit system anywhere within a mile. Two thirds of the road infrastructure is reclaimed for public usage (pedestrians, cyclists, public life); all but a tiny sliver of the rest (mostly highways which are unsuitable for public life) is either intentionally converted into parks or allowed to be reclaimed naturally. Society treats mobility as a public good, and we all pay a pittance to travel more than a mile as a result. I have to sit next to someone man-spreading.
I know which one I'd choose.
- CamperBob2 10y agoRoad congestion (and with it land use which is excessive, growing, intrusive and dangerous when interspersed with human activity) will continue to be a problem. This is your opinion, not a fact. A third of said area is consumed by automobile infrastructure. Yep. So why build fixed rail? The infrastructure that future mass transit systems will need is already there. Let's spend the money maintaining it, upgrading it, and generally taking better care of it. All of that infrastructure is dirty Do you think cars will still be burning gasoline and diesel fuel by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? and dangerous. Hard to respond to that. What's dangerous, in your view? Do you think pedestrians will still be hit by cars and trucks by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that?
- eyelidlessness 10y ago> This is your opinion, not a fact. What? It's basic math. Personal automobile space, plus stopping distance, times passengers. > Yep. So why build fixed rail? Because: - Fixed rail is far more space efficient. - That space could be used for far better things (which I enumerated in the post your responded to). - Fixed rail is far more energy efficient. > Do you think cars will still be burning gasoline and diesel fuel by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? Probably a whole lot of them, lots of old cars on the road. But that's not the only thing I meant by dirty. Automobile infrastructure is incredibly intrusive to public life. The grime is a part of that. > Hard to respond to that. What's dangerous, in your view? Do you think pedestrians will still be hit by cars and trucks by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? Of course they will. The danger of automobiles to pedestrians (and cyclists!) is that they all share the same space. Light rail (and cyclists!) will likely also continue to strike pedestrians, but far less frequently (and cyclists are substantially less harmful in a collision).
- CamperBob2 10y agoWhat? It's basic math. Personal automobile space, plus stopping distance, times passengers. Huh? That's not responsive to what I said. You realize we're talking 30 years from now, right? How much do you know about what's already working in autonomous-vehicle pilot programs today? Look, I get it. You don't like cars. And I don't like trains. But I genuinely think I'm right about what needs to be done to serve public transportation needs over the next several decades. Why? Because like a lot of people I know, I'll seldom ride a public bus, streetcar or light rail system, but I'll take an Uber any day of the week.
- eyelidlessness 10y ago> You realize we're talking 30 years from now, right? How much do you know about what's already working in autonomous-vehicle pilot programs today? Nothing at all that addresses their space or energy efficiency. Nothing on the horizon either. Those physical constraints are fundamental to that mode of transportation. > Look, I get it. You don't like cars. Actually I quite like cars. You don't seem to be responding to the points I wrote. > Why? Because like a lot of people I know, I won't ride a public bus, streetcar or light rail system, but I'll take an Uber any day of the week. Why is that?
- seattle_native 10y ago>> I have to sit next to someone man-spreading. If there were actual accountability, there would be bigger seats. Funny how the attitude changes when one thinks about a real business vs expectations of the government. And if OP actually lived in Seattle, they would know that our virtue-signaling obsessed mayor+city council would give free passes to all homeless people and the trains would promptly smell of urine+sweat and you would have to watch for syringes rolling around on the floor.
- CamperBob2 10y agoAnd if OP actually lived in Seattle, they would know that our virtue-signaling obsessed mayor+city council would give free passes to all homeless people and the trains would promptly smell of urine+sweat and you would have to watch for syringes rolling around on the floor. I used to live in Seattle, but I'm now in an unincorporated area on the eastside. You can't imagine how grateful I am that I don't have a dog in this particular fight. Or how often I pat myself on the back for G'ing TFO of King County in general and Seattle in particular. It's probably getting to be an unhealthy habit.
- oasisbob 10y ago> If there were actual accountability, there would be bigger seats. I expect the professionals running a transit system to make informed decisions to maximize the efficiency and capacity of the system. By extension, your argument is that publicly-traded airlines aren't accountable for their actions, because accountability would mean they reverse the trend of smaller seat pitch for passenger comfort?