8 ms·
Sound Transit 3, the light rail initative, can bring mobility to Seattle
- CamperBob2 10y agoI'm sure we'll all be very proud of our shiny new fixed-rail tracks in 2046, when cars are self-driving, operated as a coordinated fleet, and available for hire in less than a minute in any street, driveway, or parking lot in the area.
- plandis 10y agoWhy not have both? The density of a train car can be much greater than a car in terms of people carried. Also the last portion of light rail will be completed in 2039 with a large majority of it completed by 2031 [1] [1] https://st32.blob.core.windows.net/media/Default/Document%20Library%20Featured/June_2016/2016_0610_Factsheet_project%20phasing.pdf https://st32.blob.core.windows.net/media/Default/Document%20...
- eyelidlessness 10y agoMaking cars drive themselves addresses only one aspect of personal automobile inefficiency: parking. Road congestion (and with it land use which is excessive, growing, intrusive and dangerous when interspersed with human activity) will continue to be a problem. Energy usage will continue to be hilariously inefficient. The benefit you point out is right: cars are convenient. But their convenience has serious costs. Given a choice of two hypothetical futures: 1. I can get in a vehicle within minutes from anywhere, provided I live in a dense urban area. A third of said area is consumed by automobile infrastructure. All of that infrastructure is dirty and dangerous. I pay tremendous amounts of money out of pocket to travel anywhere more than a mile, but I get to spend that time alone. 2. I can get on a mass transit system anywhere within a mile. Two thirds of the road infrastructure is reclaimed for public usage (pedestrians, cyclists, public life); all but a tiny sliver of the rest (mostly highways which are unsuitable for public life) is either intentionally converted into parks or allowed to be reclaimed naturally. Society treats mobility as a public good, and we all pay a pittance to travel more than a mile as a result. I have to sit next to someone man-spreading. I know which one I'd choose.
- CamperBob2 10y agoRoad congestion (and with it land use which is excessive, growing, intrusive and dangerous when interspersed with human activity) will continue to be a problem. This is your opinion, not a fact. A third of said area is consumed by automobile infrastructure. Yep. So why build fixed rail? The infrastructure that future mass transit systems will need is already there. Let's spend the money maintaining it, upgrading it, and generally taking better care of it. All of that infrastructure is dirty Do you think cars will still be burning gasoline and diesel fuel by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? and dangerous. Hard to respond to that. What's dangerous, in your view? Do you think pedestrians will still be hit by cars and trucks by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that?
- eyelidlessness 10y ago> This is your opinion, not a fact. What? It's basic math. Personal automobile space, plus stopping distance, times passengers. > Yep. So why build fixed rail? Because: - Fixed rail is far more space efficient. - That space could be used for far better things (which I enumerated in the post your responded to). - Fixed rail is far more energy efficient. > Do you think cars will still be burning gasoline and diesel fuel by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? Probably a whole lot of them, lots of old cars on the road. But that's not the only thing I meant by dirty. Automobile infrastructure is incredibly intrusive to public life. The grime is a part of that. > Hard to respond to that. What's dangerous, in your view? Do you think pedestrians will still be hit by cars and trucks by the time ST3 is complete? If so, why do you think that? Of course they will. The danger of automobiles to pedestrians (and cyclists!) is that they all share the same space. Light rail (and cyclists!) will likely also continue to strike pedestrians, but far less frequently (and cyclists are substantially less harmful in a collision).
- CamperBob2 10y agoWhat? It's basic math. Personal automobile space, plus stopping distance, times passengers. Huh? That's not responsive to what I said. You realize we're talking 30 years from now, right? How much do you know about what's already working in autonomous-vehicle pilot programs today? Look, I get it. You don't like cars. And I don't like trains. But I genuinely think I'm right about what needs to be done to serve public transportation needs over the next several decades. Why? Because like a lot of people I know, I'll seldom ride a public bus, streetcar or light rail system, but I'll take an Uber any day of the week.
- lhopki01 10y agoHow do self-driving cars deal with capacity? Even with self driving cars there isn't enough capacity on the roads for everyone. Highways are terrible at traffic throughput. To give you an example Crossrail in London has the capacity for 1 million passengers per hour while on two lines of track. An 8 lane highway struggles to manage more than 150,000 per hour. In terms of land use efficiency highways are terrible.
- CamperBob2 10y agoYes, light rail is much better at getting people from one place where they don't want to be, to another place where they don't want to be. You wouldn't judge an entire rail system based on the throughput of a single track, would you? Why judge the throughput of a networked surface vehicle system by the throughput of a single highway populated by human drivers? The other person I'm conversing with in this thread makes the valid point that vast swaths of urban land are taken up by streets. What I'm saying is that this is a feature of an effective transit system, not a bug. Nobody really wants to go from one light-rail terminal to another, but streets go everywhere.
- VintageCool 10y agoLight rail and self-driving cars will operate in tandem. The backbone will be light rail and the "last mile" will be self driving cars. A self-driving Uber car will pick up me in north Greenwood, then it will pick up another passenger, and we'll ride to Northgate Station. I'll take Light Rail to Downtown, and then walk the rest of the way to the office.
- lhopki01 10y agoHonestly a city with a well designed public transport system doesn't really need cars for the last mile. Walking and cycling covers almost everyone. Rural areas will always need cars but well cities shouldn't.
- CamperBob2 10y ago
- pcwalton 10y agoIt's a real shame if self-driving cars (which, right now, are vaporware) are having an Osborne effect [1] that stifles willingness to spend money on solutions like rail that are known to work. I think there's a very real possibility that people like rayiner are correct and self-driving cars are 50 years off. Of course, I hope that's wrong and that self-driving cars get here sooner, and I think companies like Uber are doing the right thing by heavily developing the idea. But is it wise to assume that self-driving cars will arrive soon and live up to expectations instead of ensuring that we have scalable infrastructure regardless? (For what it's worth, I rode Sound Transit last month when I was in Seattle and was very pleased with the service.) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect
- CamperBob2 10y agoIt's a real shame if self-driving cars (which, right now, are vaporware) are having an Osborne effect that stifles willingness to spend money on solutions like rail that are known to work. But the Osborne Effect is a good thing for consumers (read: taxpayers.) It's only a bad thing if you're selling soon-to-be-obsolete junk. I think there's a very real possibility that people like rayiner are correct and self-driving cars are 50 years off. He's probably making the same mistake that I did for a long time, which is to continue to chuckle under my breath at machine learning as if it were still the 1980s or 1990s. In my case, Alpha Go was what finally made realize that huge advances in computing were being made that I didn't know about and didn't understand. Rayiner has a similar epiphany on the way, if he really thinks it will be 50 years before human drivers are history.
- saosebastiao 10y ago> He's probably making the same mistake that I did for a long time, which is to continue to chuckle under my breath at machine learning as if it were still the 1980s or 1990s. Anyone could come up with a similar list of technological advances that were forecasted and either realized extremely late or not at all. Flying cars had been a decade away for the last 60 years. AGI was a decade away in the 1950's, 70's, and 90's, and it's a decade away today too.
- erispoe 10y agoSelf-driving cars will make cars more efficient, but not nearly as space-efficient as we need in dense urban environment. Even if you multiply the efficiency of cars by 2 (ambitious considering you still need to share the road with pedestrians, cycles...), you are still an order of magnitude or two less space-efficient than mass transit.
- CamperBob2 10y ago$50 billion will buy a helluva lot of overpasses and underpasses for bike and pedestrian traffic. Get rid of traffic signals on the streets themselves, and a 2x multiplier in efficiency is a gross underestimate of what can be achieved. One of the biggest challenges, of course, will be to avoid what we've done in the past, which is allowing limited-access highways to act like impassable walls.
- seattle_native 10y agoThis article completely fails to mention how much of this initiative is mired in corruption and inefficiency. A portion of ST3 is to pay for ST2 and ST1, which both went over budget. In those cases, union and industry donated massive amounts to work on the initiative to get even bigger contracts after. It is projected that ST3 will carry less than 3% of the local traffic capacityou, at a huge cost. We need VC thinking here, and more proposals with a clear eye on the ROI. If my city dropped 5.4 billion on buses (a tenth of cost of ST3), we could have much more capacity that could be provisioned in a more dynamic way. That could be ready in a few years. Instead we get rail in 25+ years at a massive cost now. Having spent the last week in DC and been stuck on the Red Line for a trip that took 3x as long as normal, I am not convinced a rail line with it'so single points of failure is the best solution. Transit is cool, but I am firmly of the opinion that this train wreck of an initiative is NOT the way forward and will vote NO.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 10y ago> A portion of ST3 is to pay for ST2 and ST1, which both went over budget. Completely false. ST2 (which isn't even complete; I'm not sure why you're referring to it in the past tense) is $100 million under budget and 6 months ahead of schedule (source: http://www.masstransitmag.com/article/12171636/ahead-of-schedule-under-budget-sound-transit-expansion http://www.masstransitmag.com/article/12171636/ahead-of-sche...). > mired in corruption and inefficiency. Again, false. One of the reasons why ST2 is under budget is that Sound Transit got a lower interest rate than they expected on the bonds they issued, specifically because they're one of the best-run, most efficient mass transit agencies in the country (source: http://www.soundtransit.org/About-Sound-Transit/News-and-events/News-releases/News-release-archive/423-million-bond-issuance-takes-advantage-of-low-interest-rates http://www.soundtransit.org/About-Sound-Transit/News-and-eve...) > We need VC thinking here, and more proposals with a clear eye on the ROI. Ah, the hallmark of the uninformed public transit opponent. Lots of handwaving with "we need innovation and outside-the-box thinking!" with very few concrete proposals. The ST3 planning process went on for years specifically so people could propose alternative ideas- they weren't taken up because none of them were any good. > If my city dropped 5.4 billion on buses (a tenth of cost of ST3), we could have much more capacity that could be provisioned in a more dynamic way. That could be ready in a few years. Buses where? The roads (both the highways and the surface streets downtown) are already jammed. Nobody is going to take buses if it doesn't offer any decrease in transit time over just taking their car. > Instead we get rail in 25+ years Yup, construction takes time. I will only mention that we could've had this all today if your spiritual forerunners hadn't killed Seattle's transit plans in the 70's and 80's making basically the same arguments you're making now. We can either continue to make their mistakes or try to fix it. > at a massive cost now. No, the cost is spread out over the same multi-decade time span as the construction. Do you know how taxes and bonds work? Behold the usual ST3 opponent: vague proposals that reek of concern trolling, combined with empirical falsehoods. Please vote Yes; Seattle is getting choked to death in traffic and we can't repeat the mistakes of the 80's by doing nothing.
- barney54 10y agoNow is a strange time to commit to spending billions on light rail. In multiple cities ridership is down even as more money has been spent on rail. Two examples are LA and DC. https://www.google.com/amp/www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ridership-slump-20160127-story,amp.html?client=safari https://www.google.com/amp/www.latimes.com/local/california/... https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/metro-fourth-quarter-ridership-plunges-11-percent/2016/09/06/b94a2fa6-744c-11e6-b786-19d0cb1ed06c_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/met... Transportation options are becoming more personalized with Uber, Lyft, and autonomous cars around the corner, but rail is and inflexible technology. Without new ideas on how to make light rail more flexible and personal, these investments lock people it to inflexible transportation infrastructure and that is troublesome.
- Analemma_ 10y ago> In multiple cities ridership is down even as more money has been spent on rail. In other cities maybe, but not in Seattle. Ridership on the Link Light Rail has gone way up since the UW extension opened. > Transportation options are becoming more personalized with Uber, Lyft, and autonomous cars around the corner, Uber and Lyft exist in Seattle today, and they clearly aren't enough to solve the problem, since commute times are still increasing (2x since 2010). Autonomous cars can't fix it either - the only way autonomous cars can actually decrease congestion is if ALL the cars on the road are networked and there can be a computer somewhere doing birds-eye planning on the whole fleet. That scenario is many decades away if it happens at all. Also, as another commenter pointed out, Sound Transit is specifically investigating how to incorporate autonomous vehicles into their planning as part of this proposal.
- seattle_native 10y ago>> the only way autonomous cars can actually decrease congestion is if ALL the cars on the road are networked and there can be a computer somewhere doing birds-eye planning on the whole fleet. That scenario is many decades away if it happens at all. Did you know the UW has a big transit lab and actually has the equipment the track cars around the city. Same with SPD. That future is coming quikcly!
- gotthemwmds 10y agoWA's current Gov. Jay Inslee's opponent in this fall's election is running a great ad of him sitting in a car, stuck in traffic on what looks like the eastside of Seattle (aka Bellevue), promising that get "gets it" and that he will end gridlock, without offering a single solution. He is against ST-3. I chuckle every time it comes on.
- saosebastiao 10y agoI do too. Quite possibly the most vapid ad I've seen on actual traffic solutions, all the while opposing the best measure he could possibly support to mitigate the coming traffic disaster that accompanies growth.
- erispoe 10y agoGridlock is a feature, not a bug. We know there is a strong induced demand with individual transportation. Building more capacity will attract more car drivers. The same effect is true for mass transit, once the network is strong enough. But induced demand is usually a positive effect for mass transit.
- oasisbob 10y agoTo clarify (in case anyone misreads this the same way I did) Inslee supports ST3. His Republican challenger Bill Bryant does not.
- chrismcb 10y agoSt3 doesn't really do much to solve the issue with 405. It week help a little as some people will take the train over the lake instead of driving around it. But otherwise it doesn't tackle the 405 issue
- nodamage 10y agoI'm really surprised by the responses here. It makes me wonder if any of the people opposed to this have ever lived in cities with good public transit systems (e.g. London, Tokyo, Hong Kong).
- lostmsu 10y agoI like the idea, despite enormous time we were promised for implementation. However, I am worried, that the plan does not allow any kind of back out. Considering very high price and 10+ years execution time, I'd like a clear strategy for cancelling that if situation on the road changes significantly due to self-driving.