4 ms·
Of course, any archival strategy that leaves you vulnerable to the problems discussed in the article is defective. You ought to be backing up to multiple physic
by barrkel 10y ago
Of course, any archival strategy that leaves you vulnerable to the problems discussed in the article is defective. You ought to be backing up to multiple physically distant locations if you're really concerned about archival.
The argument makes more sense for the casual user who isn't paying for a professional backup service. But how many of those are using xz? They're more likely to be using zip files; and they'll be in a better place for it.
The zip (concatenation of compressed streams) vs tar.gz (compression of concatenated streams) distinction is useful in an archival context, if one is genuinely worried about bitrot and the risk of needing to recover partial data where the container is damaged. A concatenation of compressed streams will have worse compression especially for lots of small files, but it is far easier to recover from an error.
- akx 10y agoAnother option, should you need better compression than zip with the same damage tolerance, is xz files in an uncompressed tar.
- fbender 10y agoHow does TAR mitigate the issues mentioned in the paper? Sincerely curious, my knowledge is limited. AFAICS, XZ can still "corrupt" the TAR stream and you'll need quite a bit of extra error correction to recover from that.
- nothrabannosir 10y agoOP means xz all individual files, then tar them without compression.
- lathiat 10y agoNot as silly a suggestion as it sounds