3 ms·
That would cause a lot of trouble for many people. Imaging having an ISP that cut of the internet connection for a customer, because "some device" is misbehavin
by mrweasel 10y ago
That would cause a lot of trouble for many people. Imaging having an ISP that cut of the internet connection for a customer, because "some device" is misbehaving. The customer, who may not be that tech savvy, will now be forced to figure out if it's the fridge, TV, AC, wireless router, security system or whatever, that has been compromised.
Even if the customer figures out that which device that's to blame, the manufacturer may not have patches, or even be in business any more. So we end up in a situation where you need to replace devices, which ordinary people expect to have 10+ years lifetime.
I don't think you're wrong though, the ISP should shutdown harmful devices, but the manufacturer also need to be held responsible. It's just extremely complicated to address the manufacturer, because many are just reselling white label solutions, or companies created for that one product.
Honestly many of the IoT devices shouldn't exists to begin with, or be allowed to communicate with the internet.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoAfter this the customer will be much more conscious about device buying and will only buy security certified gear. The customer is the person buying insecure stuff and hooks it up to the internet.
- michaelt 10y agoHere in the UK if my car is a danger to other road users, I'm banned from using it even if the defect isn't my fault, the manufacturer has gone out of business, and the car is only a fraction of the way into its expected lifetime. Caveat emptor. If that makes it hard for new manufacturers to enter the market, they could always form an industry association and, through some combination of source code escrow and insurance, reassure customers their products will be maintained even if the supplier goes out of business. Travel agents, window manufacturers and cavity wall insulators all have such schemes.