5 ms·
Who owns your home? If government can tell you who can stay with you The government can do all manner of proscriptions for your residence. For instance, no, yo
by mikestew 10y ago
Who owns your home? If government can tell you who can stay with you
The government can do all manner of proscriptions for your residence. For instance, no, you cannot run a brothel from your house. You cannot turn it into a bouncy house park. And you cannot have short-term rentals in an area that the community has decided to use for permanent housing.
It's called "zoning", and collectively we've agreed to the allowed uses of our property. You live in a community of others, and your property lines do not define "The Independent Republic of JJordan", so yeah, the government does have some authority over your use of your property. You might not like it, but you'll be going against the flow. Because, personally, I'd rather not have the house next to me used for short-term rentals "shared" with those that don't give two shits about the community they'll be leaving on Sunday afternoon.
You also don't get to just decide not to follow the rules after the fact. One moved to a community, and directly or indirectly agreed to abide by the community standards. If one decides that's just not really working for them anymore, well, move to a community that has standards more to your liking. There do exist places that will have no problem with you throwing all the loud parties you like, and renting to college students on spring break. Those places are not in SV, however, so good luck in your search for remote work.
- nilved 10y agoThis post does a good job of describing why governments are old news that have no place in our fast-paced innovative future.
- mikestew 10y agoIf the "fast-paced, innovative future" includes petulant children stomping around mad because the big, bad government won't let them do whatever they want no matter the consequences to those around them, I'd say governments are more relevant than ever.
- nilved 10y agoOkay, but let's see if the governments or the petulant children win. You know which thread you're in, right?
- dragonwriter 10y agoHistorically, either the government wins or the petulant children win and then become the power center that directs government that the next set of petulant children complain about. Either way, governments are part of the future. There no real reason to expect this iteration to work any differently than all the others since humans gathered in structured societies.
- alexmat 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Poverty_of_Historicism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Poverty_of_Historicism
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marketanarchist 10y agoNo need to get butthurt just because someone questions your deity. Not everyone shares your slave morality after all.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sctb 10y agoWe've already asked you to comment civilly and substantively, so we're banning this account. We're glad to unban accounts if you email hn@ycombinator.com and we believe that you won't do this any more.
- adrusi 10y agoIts not the government imposing these restrictions, its your neighbors. If there were no government for them to impose them through, they'd use other institutions, or else just the threat of violence. You can imagine a government-free future all you want, but you're talking about a non-collectivist future, which is absurd.
- padolsey 10y agoWhat exactly would that future look like? Where there is no government, one will appear. People seem to have this incurable efficiency whereby we create rules, regulations, and eventually bureaucracies. Rules, implicit and explicit, manifest whether you like it or not. Authority manifests.
- marketanarchist 10y agoNo government != No rules. I doubt the poster above is against rules, but like me wants to decentralize that authority and enforcement. My answer: you want to have a market for law and enforcement. Read "the machinery of freedom" by David Friedman if interested.
- DominikR 10y agoThe sad thing is that the US government had much less influence on its citizens 120 years ago than it has today. It is possible (I believe it's even likely) that humanity will never see such freedom again.
- kopfdsd8049 10y agoIsn't "zoning" the primary reason why NYC real estate is so expensive in the first place? Controls that restrict the supply of housing is probably not a good thing if you're looking to make NYC real estate more affordable.
- fowkswe 10y agoHave a look at a map. Geographic boundaries surrounding an 8 million person population is why NYC real estate is so expensive.
- skywhopper 10y agoActually it's mostly because NYC is a very very popular place to live. It's also because a lot of people with too much money are buying condos in NYC as an investment. Removing zoning laws will not change these things.
- visarga 10y ago> a lot of people with too much money are buying condos in NYC as an investment That would be OK, but renting for short term should be illegal? If AirBnb residents are noisy and disrespect the laws, call the cops on them. If owners don't pay their due taxes, call IRS on them. It's no reason to make it illegal to rent for short term. I have used AirBnb in many cities on 4 continents and was always respectful to the locals and even tried my best to follow the specific recycling rules and such. What I enjoy the most is the organic feeling of being in a real apartment vs being in a hotel room. Hotel rooms all feel the same, wherever you go. What I want is to experience the same perspective as a local, well, at least to attempt to do that, and that is because I appreciate the different cultures. Banning short term apartment rentals would send a bad message to people who just want to appreciate your culture.
- davidf18 10y agoPeople don't want transients living in their apartment buildings for safety and other reasons. Unlike hotels in NYC, we lack the necessary security and also lacking is stringent check-in procedures that hotels have. We have doormen but they are not security guards.
- psyc 10y agoJesus, guy. Heap on another few solar masses worth of condescension.
- braveo 10y ago> short-term rentals in an area that the community has decided to use for permanent housing It shouldn't be legal to tell someone who owns a home that they cannot rent it out. We're not talking about someone running a business out of their home, where the zoning laws actually apply. > I'd rather not have the house next to me used for short-term rentals "shared" with those that don't give two shits about the community they'll be leaving on Sunday afternoon. How about the ones who let that druggie sister down on her luck move in, she's ok because it's for over 30 days? This is just whiny bullcrap from someone who wants to be able to control their neighbors. > You also don't get to just decide not to follow the rules after the fact. One moved to a community, and directly or indirectly agreed to abide by the community standards. We're not discussing a housing authority here. If you and your neighbors get together and decide the community cannot abide someone allowing another person to use their house for less than ... what 6 months? a year ... you write that into the bylaws, set out the financial penalty, and then you enforce it. And that's your right. But when these kinds of things become illegal across an entire state, there's a problem. This law should have never been on the books in its current form to begin with.
- kafkaesq 10y agoIt shouldn't be legal to tell someone who owns a home that they cannot rent it out. That's not what relevant the laws say ("You can't rent your property, period!"). Just that you can't use a residential property as a de-facto hotel. If you and your neighbors get together and decide the community cannot abide someone allowing another person to use their house for less than ... what 6 months? 30 days. The point is that short-term rentals have a very different character (in terms of impact on neighbors, and impact on property values) than long-term rentals. This is just whiny bullcrap from someone who wants to be able to control their neighbors. No, it's just life the big city. Though I agree that whether these issues should be of interest of the state (as opposed to municipalities) is very much open to question. Then again, the Empire State is known to be messed up (and to have lopsided control over) a great many things, in this regard.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- DominikR 10y ago> Because, personally, I'd rather not have the house next to me used for short-term rentals "shared" with those that don't give two shits about the community they'll be leaving on Sunday afternoon. Why do you believe that guests wont give "two shits" about the community. This sounds incredibly xenophobic to me.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThere's houses on Airbnb that are advertised as party houses. This has caused a lot of issues for the neighbors of said "party houses."
- DominikR 10y agoBut you have to admit that these "party houses" are the absolute minority. Most offering are very restrictive in this regard. Anyways, I was being sarcastic by using the tools of a leftie. (declaring the parent to be a xenophobe)
- 1812calif 10y agoDo you perceive that your sarcasm was effective? Did it convey your point clearly and concisely, so that you can share your perspective and point of view? Or did it do more harm to what is otherwise a legitimate viewpoint and possibly deserving of discussion?
- DominikR 10y agoYes, yes and no. I'm btw sure that many Socialists would actually agree that the statement undoubtably displayed hatred and xenophobia. He did argue against allowing people from the outside to come and live in his community because he by default perceives foreigners as not giving "two shits" about the community. This is obviously not true, you can't just declare that all foreigners want to harm your community.
- 10y ago