5 ms·
Something that I'm seeing more and more these days are companies that are actually not trying to fill the positions they are posting. I've seen companies fully
by busterarm 10y ago
Something that I'm seeing more and more these days are companies that are actually not trying to fill the positions they are posting.
I've seen companies fully-contained within 4-person WeWork spaces showing pictures of their non-existant 20+ person team and listing as many or more open positions that don't exist. I've seen companies that list positions that aren't actively looking to hire but want to keep the funnel open in case that 'special snowflake' comes along.
I don't know if it's 'wishful thinking' or something else, but it's fairly poisonous.
- wayn3 10y agoIf you aren't "actively looking" but would bite if "that special snowflake" came in, aren't you actively hiring? Maybe you're more like passively hiring, but I'd still consider them hiring.
- busterarm 10y agoI didn't want to be obviously derisive in my post. The two companies in question were obviously stroking their own egos. They didn't have an actual need for someone and it was all about how many/what type of degrees someone had and from where before they'd even consider looking at a candidate. In one of the cases, when the company did actually hire a person, that person had no work to do -- it was purely a means to justify their ask to investors for more money. We hire the best people!
- wayn3 10y agoDoes that make you angry? They'll soon fail anyway. Some people don't internalize that this is a sellers market. There are orders of magnitude more open jobs out there than there are qualified people to fill them. You shouldn't concern yourself with a bunch of toxic idiots trying to milk VC for a while.
- busterarm 10y agoNot really, actually. I get it. It's the waste/needless entropy and it makes me more sad than mad anyway. I have to consider that some of the effort I spend chasing what looks like a great job might actually be a complete waste of time with no chance whatsoever. I've been pretty vocal about my experiences, good and bad, job searching. I usually even like to name and shame and strangely enough it has paid off for me in connecting with the kinds of people I want to work with. I've been happily employed for a year now and have a good network of opportunities available to me.
- ryandrake 10y ago> Some people don't internalize that this is a sellers market. There are orders of magnitude more open jobs out there than there are qualified people to fill them. The "shortage of engineers" meme that just won't die. If this were actually true, one or more of the following would be happening: 1. Qualified people would not be having difficulty finding work 2. Salaries would be increasing and low-paying open jobs would decrease in response to short supply until the market went into equilibrium
- wayn3 10y agoThe market is in equilibrium. Physics and Math graduate unemployment rates are virtually zero, and practically all of us work in software. That a lot of CS graduates actually can't do the job may be a pity, but its not our problem. Qualified people don't have difficulty finding work (by definition - if they're qualified, they will get hired). Shortage of engineers is a meme? "If you gave us another 100k great engineers we would only hire about 15k of those" - said none of the big 4 ever. They are perpetually hiring and they will absorb any capable engineer who comes their way. You know that. Don't pretend there's a shortage of jobs for qualified software engineers. That's just silly.
- bulatb 10y ago> by definition - if they're qualified, they will get hired It sounds like you're explicitly committing the No True Scotsman fallacy. It's also an example of Goodhart's law: the people getting hired are demonstrably most qualified at getting hired, but the correlation between being good and being hired is quite clearly less than 1.0.
- ryandrake 10y agoMaybe we need a different word for it then, because they're not hiring. They're "looking" and maybe "interviewing". A lot of companies who say they're hiring are really just trawling for deals.
- skookum 10y agoI have a hard time believing that companies trying to pretend they are significantly larger than they are in hopes of snagging some super-special hire is a common thing. It seems like the sort of thing that would backfire quickly. I would quit on the first day if I arrived to discover a scenario like you've described - but to be honest I'd probably detect much earlier in the process and never arrive in the first place. It's also worth noting that the reverse direction of this false-hope scenario does occur frequently: It's extremely common in our industry for candidates to take interviews with companies they would never accept an offer from just to practice their interview skills for later interviews with companies they actually do want to work at.
- busterarm 10y agoThey're trying to appear larger because they think that it either makes them look better to investors or to customers. I think it always backfires in any case, but most of these people don't have very much, if any, experience running a successful business.
- wott 10y agoWhen a visitor would come, my boss would arrange fake working stations, with piles of files which were in fact white paper, and he would pretend the ghost-employees were on vacation, or on an outside mission. I have also applied to many job offers I am pretty sure were fake, with no actual position behind.