6 ms·
There are a shocking amount of units in NYC that are full-time Airbnbs. As a New Yorker, I am in favor of legislation that tries to ensure that New York's rent
by busterarm 10y ago
There are a shocking amount of units in NYC that are full-time Airbnbs. As a New Yorker, I am in favor of legislation that tries to ensure that New York's rental units are occupied by actual residents.
- sbarre 10y agoI read somewhere that Amsterdam has a rule that states you can only use your lodging for short-term rental for up to 60 days a year. This seems like it maintains the sharing spirit of something like AirBnB (rent your place out occasionally when you're away) while preventing the problems that come from people essentially running unregulated hotels..
- bradleyjg 10y agoThe problem is enforcement. As it is this law is all about tractability of enforcement, it doesn't change what apartments are or are not allowed to be let/sublet but rather adds a provision that makes it illegal to advertise an illegal unit. This is because the existing law is very difficult to enforce and AirBnB moguls are blatantly flaunting it. This is the same problem with those that suggest that we don't need state laws because condos and co-ops can just enforce their contractual rules. (Also, that argument neglects rental buildings.) Relaxing the law in the manner you suggest would make it even more difficult to enforce than the law as it stood prior to this addition.
- threeseed 10y agoEnforcement could be simple. Just like governments demand companies hand over financial information they could demand that AirBnb hands over the list of users and the total stay length.
- jonknee 10y agoBut you have to do that for every similar service and try and match up records. It would be a nightmare. Landlords would also create different companies/accounts to rent out the max nights per year. It's just not enforceable.
- threeseed 10y agoThe tax office does this for tens of thousands of companies. It can easily handle at most a dozen sharing sites. And it's trivial to prevent landlords from registering multiple accounts i.e. make sure no two landlords advertise the same address.
- smackfu 10y agoIn some of these cities, you also have the issue where people are renting out their state subsidized housing as unregulated hotels. So they aren't even paying market rent for the place in the first place.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dwightgunning 10y agoThat's correct. In a nutshell: 60 days max, fire safety equipment is mandatory, and the building home owner's association (body corporate) need to agree to it. The city produced a one-pager to spell it out: https://www.amsterdam.nl/publish/pages/707219/infographic_holiday_letting_in_amsterdam.pdf https://www.amsterdam.nl/publish/pages/707219/infographic_ho...
- ng12 10y agoNYC has an incredible dearth of affordable short-term housing. I'm honestly not sure how I would have been able to afford moving there without AirBnB.
- busterarm 10y ago> NYC has an incredible dearth of affordable housing. I fixed that for you. The thing is, in most cases what is being done with these units was already illegal.
- ng12 10y agoYou mean Manhattan has a dearth of affordable housing. Nobody's complaining about AirBnB's in Coney Island.
- busterarm 10y agoMost of Brooklyn, Queens and at least 2/3 of the Bronx has an affordable housing crisis as well. Picking out the one or two unattractive neighborhoods to live in doesn't really do anyone any good.
- ng12 10y agoAnd you think AirBnB has anything to do with the rental prices in the Bronx or Queens? I'm just saying I don't really feel bad about a unit in Lower Manhattan somewhere being off the market because it's rented to tourists.
- mtalantikite 10y agoWhen I moved here 9 or so years ago I signed a lease on a studio without seeing it first. Honestly, it wasn't so hard.
- ng12 10y agoHard? No, but that's an undeniably worse process.
- kopfdsd8049 10y agoWhy not just leave the rules up to the property owners? For example, residents can move to properties where landlords have banned Airbnb customers. Wouldn't this be a win/win situation for everyone?
- busterarm 10y agoNew York is a strong Tenant Rights state for good reason... https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20151127/hells-kitchen-clinton/long-vacant-building-included-on-letita-james-worst-landlord-list https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20151127/hells-kitchen-clin... Edit: Nice throwaway. Tell us about your Airbnb unit!
- Broken_Hippo 10y ago> For example, residents can move to properties where landlords have banned Airbnb customers. The main problem with this sort of thing is that while it is easy to say that, it isn't actually always an option for folks. This is part of the reason why folks don't always just "move to where jobs are available." Moving costs money and takes quite an effort. Minimally, for cost you have first month's rent and a deposit, usually equal. Sometimes last month's rent. There are fees for utilities, and sometimes deposits for them if you change companies. Collect boxes: Secure moving vehicles if you don't have something to move large stuff. Heck, you might not even be able to move for months if the landlord starting allowing it after you signed your lease. Your lease might be against it, but the neighbor's doesn't. This is truly only a win/win if you have the finances and time to be able to move.
- eternalban 10y agoAs a New Yorker I agree with you completely. We the "people" who are not the "powerful" are getting pushed further away from the center each year chasing afforadable housing. Pretty soon we'll end up in Jersey or Long Island.
- mahyarm 10y agoWhat are the numbers? When the numbers were released for SF, it was a number around ~6000. While SF rent laws cause over 30'000 units to stay off the market because landlords don't want to deal with the risk and hassle. And even more potential units are 'off the market' because of building restrictions.