4 ms·
In the context of user points, #1 has to be the biggest issue, which highlights a big problem with voting in the HN community. Downvoting is a feature given to
by andrewmcwatters 10y ago
In the context of user points, #1 has to be the biggest issue, which highlights a big problem with voting in the HN community. Downvoting is a feature given to people with favorable stances in the community, thus shunning others with alternative views.
While some say downvotes should be used to deter comments that do not add to the discussion, this isn't realistic. Interestingly, this places those who hold popular opinion in control of the discussion, effectively keeping others' opinions less visible, and status quo strong until tipping points occur in positions where a majority of the community conversely agrees.
- grzm 10y agoYeah, watching what's been down voted and flagged has been interesting. I've seen examples of both civil, substantive comments and abusive/empty comments down voted. And sometimes the former don't even appear controversial. Being new to the community, I've tried to pay attention to what is acceptable behavior. Thanks for the feedback!