6 ms·
>The shares surged as much as 5.6 percent to a record $60.45. The last time Microsoft was trading near that level was in 1999. Using share price is suboptimal
by hollerith 10y ago
>The shares surged as much as 5.6 percent to a record $60.45. The last time Microsoft was trading near that level was in 1999.
Using share price is suboptimal because the number of shares outstanding has decreased significantly since 1999. Better to use market cap (which is share price times the number of shares outstanding).
(According to wikipedia) Microsoft reached a market cap of $618.9 billion in December 1999, which is $879 billion in 2015 dollars. In contrast, Microsoft's market cap today is significantly less, namely, $447.5 billion.
BTW, in Feb 2015, Apple reached a market cap of $775 billion. Since the computing industry's share of the economy was significantly lower in 1999 than it was in 2015, the data on market caps suggests that the 1999 version of Microsoft was significantly more dominant over the industry than the 2015 version of Apple was.
- hacknat 10y agoYeah, but 1999 was a mother-of-a-bubble.
- ucha 10y agoYou understand though that if MSFT had 100B USD in cash and spent it all in stock repurchase, then, in theory, its stock price wouldn't move but its market cap would go down by 100B. The market cap is not a perfect indicator of the value of a business either. If we start to nitpick, why not calculate share price in real dollar terms (take inflation into account), adjust for the average P/E ratio of US stocks, adjust for dividends etc... That quote is just trivia.
- insightful 10y agoYour assumption is completely and absolutely wrong. Not just wrong, but actually the opposite of the traditional reality -- market cap usually doesn't even consider cash and short term equity reserves for traditional companies, so you end up with companies that have more book value than market value. Which is exactly why these companies buy back shares -- a smaller circulation benefits their shareholders more than money sitting in an account on the company books.
- arcanus 10y ago> if MSFT had 100B USD in cash and spent it all in stock repurchase, then, in theory, its stock price wouldn't move but its market cap would go down by 100B ? In the process of buying shares back, the market capitalization would increase due to the increase in share price. The share price would absolutely move. This is why companies have stock buy-backs, in order to pump up the share price. The 'buyback ratio' is the amount spent on buybacks in the past 12 months as a percentage of the company’s market capitalization, and is often used as a means to flag companies that are acting in a manner such as this. The market capitalization is just share$ * # of shares. Did you mean book value? The book value of a company would reduce if you burned 100B in share repurchases, but even then I don't think it would be so simple, as that 100B in shares would now be listed as assets to the company and could be used as remuneration for the employees, among other things.
- kgwgk 10y agoSometimes people has some difficulty to understand than spending money in buybacks does reduce the market cap of a company, but I think is the first time I see someone argue that spending money in buybacks increases the market cap.
- rifung 10y ago> This is why companies have stock buy-backs, in order to pump up the share price. Why does this matter to them? Stocks are very strange to me.. when I think of owning a business, I'd hope to get some share of the profits, which as I understand it, is dividends for stocks. This being the case, I always thought stock buybacks were a long term investment in the sense that the company would pay more upfront so they'd have to pay less dividends. This makes sense except that companies seem to barely pay dividends now, I'm guessing because it's unfavorable due to tax reasons. This makes it seem like there's a strange disconnect between owning a business and deriving income from it, because now most people only buy hoping to sell at a higher price to others. But why do other people buy it at a higher price if the company doesn't pay more dividends? I find it all very strange.. Why does a company care about its stock price? Is it just to please shareholders? Prevent buyouts? Make it easier to compensate employees?
- blazespin 10y agoWell said. How do you think it should be valued?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 10y agoConsider that Microsoft started paying dividends after 2000, a yield of about 2.5%. A rough calculation of that compounding for 16 years is 150%.
- MagnumOpus 10y ago2.5% compounded over 16 years is exactly 48.5%, nowhere near 150.
- WalterBright 10y agoYou're right, my mistake.
- jeffshek 10y agoBut you're compounding the 2.5% only with itself. If you had reinvested the dividend back into the stock (common), the return is higher than 48.5%.
- pesenti 10y agoNo. 1.025^16=1.48 - that's the reinvestment scenario. What you describe, no reinvestment, is just 2.5%*16=40%.
- zzleeper 10y agoYou should also subtract cash from mkt cap, as both are huge for 2000s MSFT an current aapl
- m_mueller 10y agoWhy would you subtract the cash to evaluate a company? Cash can easily be turned into something with actual value, so IMO it should be included.
- candiodari 10y agoExactly for the reason you say : Market cap - what a company "owes" it's investors. Definitely on the liabilities side. The value of the company. Cash - what a company definitely owns (and could, for instance, pay to it's investors) So there is this measure of company's worth called "enterprise value" which is Market cap + debt - cash - assets. It sort-of is what you'd get if you acquired the company and immediately sold everything off. To put it another way : it's everything Microsoft has, other than the business it's involved in. It can indicate that there are deals to be had. For instance if you pay $50 million for a company that has running accounts with $40 million on them, have you really paid $50 million for it ? You had control (through a company) over $50 million, and now you have control over $40 million and a company, so there is an argument to be made that you "only paid" $10 million. So "enterprise value" is what you would really have to pay for a company, and for a lot of people considered a more useful metric than market cap.
- snnn 10y agoWhat if you want to buy this company? His cash is your debt. The more he has, the more you need to borrow. The actual you get is the selling price minus the cash you get from this buying.
- joshcohen 10y agoDo you know why share count decreased? I was under the impression that new shares have been continuously issued.
- Tom1971 10y agoThey buy back stock all the time. Just a few weeks ago they announced a $40B stock buy back program.