3 ms·
>Good rail systems already, today, have about 5 – 10x the capacity of road systems Do they have that capacity in seats or in hands on the overhead rails with b
by closeparen 10y ago
>Good rail systems already, today, have about 5 – 10x the capacity of road systems
Do they have that capacity in seats or in hands on the overhead rails with backpacks held in hands and zero personal space? If the latter, that's a fairly disingenuous comparison.
- eru 10y agoWhy? Still gets you from A to B.
- closeparen 10y agoBanning air conditioners in the South would be great for energy efficiency. It's just comfort, not survival. Forcing people out of cars (or previously available train seats) onto standing room only trains because "you still get from A to B" would be roughly the same. Everything is "more efficient" if people simply accept worse outcomes. That's not an accomplishment. Contrast with actual improvements over status quo like more effiently packed passenger cars, self driving cars, rail service with enough seats, etc. Upward change is good. Lateral change is fine. Reaching into people's lives and making them worse because "you didn't really need that, and my values are more important than yours" is disturbingly fashionable in these threads.
- eru 10y agoI agree, but the context of my comment was jseliger comment further up about capacity alone. No need to force people out of cars. But often the limiting factor for road transport happens to be congestion: when people are in effect running an auction with their time, and persons most willing to set in traffic are the highest bidder and `win the road'; then it is economically more efficient to make people pay with money instead of time and introduce a congestion charge or an Certificate of Entitlement system like in Singapore. The road still gets rationed by an auction, but instead of bidding by wasting your time, you bid with actual money that can be re-used for other things. (And time is, of course, money.) I hope you forgive me what seems like a digression: what looks like `forcing people out of their cars' might actually just be replacing wasteful time-bidding with money-bidding.