3 ms·
NDAs are a real, if insane, thing still to this day Some of the big security bugs recently have been disclosed to big players like Google and AWS before they w
by michaelt 10y ago
NDAs are a real, if insane, thing still to this day
Some of the big security bugs recently have been disclosed to big players like Google and AWS before they were publicly disclosed.
If you want to retain that privilege, you need to show you can keep your mouth shut when security researchers disclose something to you - NDA or otherwise.
- barkbro 10y agoWhat's the rationale for disclosing vulnerabilities to for example Google before going public (unless the bug is in Google's software)?
- NeutronBoy 10y agoBecause big players can take remedial action prior to the bug being disclosed to protect users - for example, banning a specific framework from browser extensions.
- michaelt 10y agoWhen you release a patch, anyone who gets it can see what you changed and figure out an exploit from that. Because it's good for people to be patched /before/ that happens, some vendors give certain major customers early access to patches - so long as they maintain a proven track record of not disclosing anything about them. For example, Xen has a 'pre-disclosure list' [1] so if they have a critical security patch, Amazon, Google, Linode, Oracle, Rackspace, and several Linux distro developers [2] get the patches early. Obviously, we can debate the morality and wisdom of this policy - personally as I haven't discovered any critical security bugs, I've never faced this particular moral conundrum. [1] https://www.xenproject.org/security-policy.html https://www.xenproject.org/security-policy.html [2] http://www.securityweek.com/several-flaws-patched-xen-hypervisor http://www.securityweek.com/several-flaws-patched-xen-hyperv...