3 ms·
Short answer: Yes. I don't have time to dig up the studies or articles at the moment, but even optimistic-case self-driving car systems aren't going to more th
by jseliger 10y ago
Short answer: Yes.
I don't have time to dig up the studies or articles at the moment, but even optimistic-case self-driving car systems aren't going to more than double or triple existing road capacity. Good rail systems already, today, have about 5 – 10x the capacity of road systems. Self-driving cars and medium- to long-distance urban transit system are actually likely to be complements, not substitutes, especially if/when cities continue to get denser.
- alooPotato 10y agoWhat about shared self driving cars + dedicated express bus lanes? The idea being we tax cars for usage of the road and the buses become effectively free (and faster) while self driving shared ubers are $2/ride. Making roads better and taxing them right (so we can do dynamic pricing) seems so much better than huge chunky capital costs of digging tunnels and installing subway infrastructure. We already have roads, people get to go door to door, and deploying a usage based tax model on roads is just software. Seems so much better than decade long projects.
- tajen 10y agoThere's a lot of added value for the community in mass transport. It costs less per fare than car systems you can think about (even ridesharing & co), consume/pollute less, but more importantl it allows lower-class and middle-class citizen to move around the city. All the cleaning personel, food, assistance personel can afford coming to the city to provide for high-value-added workers. All high-value-added can afford to live farther away along the lines, in better appartments than the constricted downtown space. And the new density created by gathering more people in the same place during the day allow the collaboration of more people.
- alooPotato 10y agoagreed. but buses instead of subways no?
- ufo 10y agoWhen it comes to transport capacity its usually Subway >> Light Rail ~ Bus Rapid Transit >> Regular Bus >> Cars
- alooPotato 10y agoI'm imagining buses that go down major arteries like Geary. They'd come often and there would be a lot of them and they'd have dedicated lanes. Seems so much more flexible than fixed infrastructure.
- ufo 10y agoPublic transit doesn't need to be flexible though. Individuals might change their routines every day but when you average the traffic for the whole city the throughtput of the major arteries is very predictable. The biggest priority in these situations is making the transport be cheap and efficient and make it scale to demand. And just because a mode of transportation is on wheels doesn't mean it flexible. If you look at a Bus Repid Transit system[1] you would notice that the buses are specialized for driving in separate lanes that go in a straight line and the bus stops are custom built (and are less frequent than a regular bus). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_rapid_transit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_rapid_transit
- eru 10y ago> All high-value-added can afford to live farther away along the lines, in better appartments than the constricted downtown space. Just build up. There's plenty of room in downtowns. The elevator can be the most important form of `public transport'.
- closeparen 10y agoThere seems to be unlimited appetite for high-rise apartments at luxury to extreme luxury prices. Particularly from people who will never live in them. Is there any evidence that high rise apartments (say more than 10 stories) affordable at middle incomes can exist or ever have existed?
- niftich 10y agoI wonder about this a lot in major cities -- whether the seemingly massive number of apartments in luxury high-rises are actually occupied full-time by those with high incomes, or are they actually more affordable than I suspect? Or are most of them empty, and just used to park monetary value?
- closeparen 10y ago>In a three-block stretch of Midtown, from East 56th Street to East 59th Street, between Fifth Avenue and Park Avenue, 57 percent, or 285 of 496 apartments, including co-ops and condos, are vacant at least 10 months a year. From East 59th Street to East 63rd Street, 628 of 1,261 homes, or almost 50 percent, are vacant the majority of the time, according to data from the Census Bureau’s 2012 American Community Survey. [0] I'm going with "used to park value." It's been mentioned elsewhere that real estate is the last place you can easily park a literal suitcase full of cash without being subject to any KYC rules. [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/26/realestate/pieds-terre-owners-dominate-some-new-york-buildings.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/26/realestate/pieds-terre-own...
- eru 10y agoDoesn't really matter which end of spectrum you build housing at---any housing built is good: if you don't build luxury housing, the rich will just bid up less glamorous units. To avoid empty apartments, a land value tax works fairly well.
- sliverstorm 10y agoFor the compliment story- One of the challenges with things like rail is getting to and from the station, and parking. If you could step out your door, ride to the train, get dropped off, get on the train, get off, and ride to your office- rail could become dramatically more compelling for people who are not very close to the stations. In short self-driving cars could improve rail's "last-mile" challenge
- closeparen 10y ago>Good rail systems already, today, have about 5 – 10x the capacity of road systems Do they have that capacity in seats or in hands on the overhead rails with backpacks held in hands and zero personal space? If the latter, that's a fairly disingenuous comparison.
- eru 10y agoWhy? Still gets you from A to B.
- closeparen 10y agoBanning air conditioners in the South would be great for energy efficiency. It's just comfort, not survival. Forcing people out of cars (or previously available train seats) onto standing room only trains because "you still get from A to B" would be roughly the same. Everything is "more efficient" if people simply accept worse outcomes. That's not an accomplishment. Contrast with actual improvements over status quo like more effiently packed passenger cars, self driving cars, rail service with enough seats, etc. Upward change is good. Lateral change is fine. Reaching into people's lives and making them worse because "you didn't really need that, and my values are more important than yours" is disturbingly fashionable in these threads.
- eru 10y agoI agree, but the context of my comment was jseliger comment further up about capacity alone. No need to force people out of cars. But often the limiting factor for road transport happens to be congestion: when people are in effect running an auction with their time, and persons most willing to set in traffic are the highest bidder and `win the road'; then it is economically more efficient to make people pay with money instead of time and introduce a congestion charge or an Certificate of Entitlement system like in Singapore. The road still gets rationed by an auction, but instead of bidding by wasting your time, you bid with actual money that can be re-used for other things. (And time is, of course, money.) I hope you forgive me what seems like a digression: what looks like `forcing people out of their cars' might actually just be replacing wasteful time-bidding with money-bidding.