4 ms·
If you really want to improve the integrity of elections, you should require less, not more pieces of ID to vote. Currently, the integrity of elections is compr
by vkou 10y ago
If you really want to improve the integrity of elections, you should require less, not more pieces of ID to vote. Currently, the integrity of elections is compromised via policies that deliberately prevent poor and non-white voters from exercising their rights.
In Canada, you didn't need a proof of residence to vote for the longest time - if you had someone vouch that you live where you said you live. Someone vouched for could not vouch for another person. You could only vouch for one people.
Without this, I wouldn't have been able to vote. I lived with my parents, I didn't have bills addressed to my name, and I had no recent tax forms, by virtue of being a student.
The voter fraud impact on an election (As found by every study and investigation into the question is completely insignificant.) Disenfranchising people like me, or the homeless, on the other hand, is quite significant. Naturally, the Tories, who don't have much luck with either the student, or the homeless demographics, gutted vouching.
Turning one person away from the polls is far worse then allowing one case of voter fraud to slip through. In the case of voter fraud, you have after-the-fact redress - invalidation of ballots, jail time, deportation. In the case of disenfranchisement, its tough shit, try again in four years. Any policy that results in more of the former then the latter is contrary to its purported goals.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CWuestefeld 10y agoYou're assuming that the democratic process is best served by having the largest number of people voting as possible. I, and Mike Rowe for another, don't believe that. Democracy is not best served by voters who don't fully understand the issues. Someone who's not willing to invest the effort in getting proper ID (or one of the other ways of voting, like an absentee ballot) is likely also not investing much in becoming educated on the issues. IMHO, setting a low threshold to weed out folks who are voting on a whim, without having invested in the process, will help the project of democracy.
- vkou 10y ago> Someone who's not willing to invest the effort in getting proper ID (or one of the other ways of voting, like an absentee ballot) is likely also not investing much in becoming educated on the issues. Great idea. Why not bar people without a college education from voting? Better yet, why not bar people who don't own land from voting? If you aren't willing to jump through a few hoops, why should you have a say in how the country is run? The hoops that people need to jump through to become eligible are, by design, made more difficult for certain demographics. This is deliberate disenfranchisement. The whole point of democracy is that everyone gets to have a say in it - not just the people you like.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoWhy not make a strawman argument? I'm not advocating that we set up intentional barriers, like the poll taxes of old. What I said was that if a side effect of a legitimate effort has a side effect, it's not a bad thing. I was taking that from the idea that uninformed voters aren't helping the process; Mike Rowe explains that better than I can [1]. This is deliberate disenfranchisement. No. There may be other folks who do want to gag people and would use this as a pretense. You shouldn't simply assume that I am one of those people. You're putting words in my mouth, and trying to say that I'm lying about what my motives are. If that's how you're going to approach debate, then I don't think it's worth wasting bits on you. [1] http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2016/08/19/mike-rowe-delivers-some-undeniable-reality-about-celebrities-who-urge-the-masses-to-get-out-and-vote/ http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2016/08/19/mike-rowe-deliver...
- unclenoriega 10y agoI'm sympathetic to Rowe's argument that people who don't care or don't know what they're talking about shouldn't vote, but that's different than saying they should be prevented from voting. If I'm remembering correctly, Rowe said that we shouldn't encourage people to vote who aren't otherwise motivated. I don't see anything wrong with that, but the issue then becomes what barriers you're setting up. If the barriers we set up are costs, either for an ID card or lost wages, I think it's pretty easy to argue that we're excluding poor people, not uninformed people. If, on the other hand, the barrier is you have to mail in a ballot, then that's probably acceptable. I think the best thing we can do is try to find ways to inform more people about public policy issues, not ways to casually disenfranchise apathetic or uninformed citizens.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoYou're right that I'm taking it a step farther than Rowe did. The thing is, those who oppose this really are putting forward a strawman, at least relative to what SCOTUS has told us is in-bounds. They've found that a law requiring ID for in-person voting was OK, because it also provided for A) A means to obtain IDs for free; or B) People without ID could still vote by (as I recall) going to city hall and showing other identifying documents With these conditions, I think it clearly changes from a question of excluding people because of money, to one more like I said, where it's just testing whether people are willing to get off their butts and invest a little bit of effort.
- wang_li 10y ago> The voter fraud impact on an election (As found by every study and investigation into the question is completely insignificant.) A non-partisan elections monitoring group in Virginia has documented thousands of people who identify themselves on jury duty forms as non-citizens but who have registered and voted. Thousands of voters can easily sway local and state elections. For example, in the 2004 Washington State Gubernatorial race the margin of victory was 129 votes. (The vote tallying was a complete mess. During the manual recount King County poll workers discovered a number of ballots that were invalidated for improper signatures, and also "discovered" 162 previously uncounted ballots in a tray in a warehouse. Additionally King County had 895,660 listed voters and 899,199 counted ballots. Election fraud happens and it has happened recently and it changes the results of races.) > In the case of voter fraud, you have after-the-fact redress - invalidation of ballots, jail time, deportation. No you don't. You might be able to jail and deport someone, but there is zero connection between a ballot and a voter. There is no way to remove the invalid ballot and have a correct count. Note that if it were possible to connect a ballot to a voter then you cannot have free and fair elections.
- vkou 10y ago> A non-partisan elections monitoring group in Virginia has documented thousands of people who identify themselves on jury duty forms as non-citizens but who have registered and voted. Thousands of voters can easily sway local and state elections. This should tell you more about how much people want to do jury duty, then how much they want to perform voter fraud. Also, have you considered that they may have become citizens between the time that they were called up, and the time that they voted?
- wang_li 10y agoThere are three possibilities: 1 - citizen who lies on their jury duty questionnaire to get out of serving. 2 - non-citizens who told the truth on their jury duty questionnaire. 3 - non-citizens who became citizens, but were registered to vote before they became citizens. The first have committed perjury and are ineligible to vote. The second are ineligible to vote, plus there is some weirdness associated with them even being selected for jury duty, read on. As for the third, jury lists are drawn from voter registration as the requirements to vote and the requirements to be on a jury are the same. It's unlawful to register to vote if you aren't a citizen. So the third group has also committed a crime and are ineligible to vote. And ineligible to become citizens and would face deportation if anyone bothered to followup.
- trendia 10y agoThere are two ways the disenfranchise voters: 1) not being allowed to vote, despite being qualified to do so (your vote doesn't count) 2) voting, but allowing people to vote twice. (this dilutes your vote) Many people attempt to address one of these problems but not the other. Specifically, avoiding any sort of identification fixes (1) but not (2). The Supreme Court has found that there are some ID laws that address both of these problems and do not impose any undue burden on people greater than that of normal voting. [0] Specifically: 1) voter ID is free 2) you can vote up to 30 days before the election 3) you can vote once and only once In this case, since you can vote far before "election day", you do not have to worry about being "turned away", as you mentioned. Now, not all voting policies address both of these issues. Some address (1) by disenfranchising people, while other policies address (2). However, the Supreme Court said that the Crawford case is a perfect example of a policy that ensures that every qualified person gets a vote, and nobody can vote more than once. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crawford_v._Marion_County_Election_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crawford_v._Marion_County_Elec...
- vkou 10y agoIn some cases, voter ID may be free, but if the nearest place that issues it is in a town 50 miles away, that's only open 10-4 on Mondays through Thursdays, it may as well cost a million dollars to some people. In other cases, the requirements for getting voter ID may be beyond what is possible for a voter. Again - consider the homeless, the recently relocated, people who don't pay bills. And speaking of Indiana, you realize that this is also the state that just seized ~50,000 in-progress voter registrations, on suspicion that some number of them may be fraudulent (The bar for which is surprisingly low)? [1] Exactly how many of the non-fraudulent ones do you think will be forwarded by state police to their intended destination, before the election? Would failing to do so even be illegal? This nonesense is precisely what vouching is supposed to address. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2016/10/15/group-accuses-mike-pence-of-voter-suppression-after-state-police-raid-registration-program-in-indiana/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2016/10...
- trendia 10y ago
- akytt 10y agoOr we could give everybody an id card as a basic public service?